Ballot Initiative of the Day: Florida’s Abortion Restriction Amendment

  • Share
  • Read Later

Oct. 20, 2012 - St. Petersburg, Florida, U.S. - USF Tampa student Lucia Baker, 21, cheers as feminist, author and political activist Gloria Steinem takes the stage during a get-out-the-vote rally at Jannus Live on Saturday. Baker, an advocate of women's health issues said she came to the rally to stay informed and support the issues she believes in, like voting ''no'' on Amendment 6, to help keep Florida politicians from interfering in a woman's personal health care decisions. Steinem told the crowd of hundreds that Romney refused to take a stand on equal pay for women and would threaten reproductive rights if elected, declaring him the most extremist presidential candidate ever. (Credit Image: © Melissa Lyttle/Tampa Bay Times/ZUMAPRESS.com)

Abortion is always a divisive issue. On November 6, Floridians will vote on 11 constitutional amendments proposed by its GOP-controlled legislature, and Amendment 6, known as the Abortion Amendment, is the most controversial.

Amendment 6 would prevent state tax dollars from being used to cover abortion costs except in cases of rape, incest or life endangerment, and would also make it easier to require that minors have parental consent to terminate a pregnancy. A Florida ballot amendment requiring parental notification, not consent, became law after it passed 65% to 35% in 2004.

The amendment would align Florida law on abortion funding with federal rules–a measure called the Hyde Amendment prohibits federal tax dollars going to abortion coverage. But the debate over parental consent has been heated. If passed, Florida would join 24 other states that enforce parental permission, three of which require both parents to sign off.

Supporters of Amendment 6 say consent is common sense. “In Florida at this time, a minor daughter must have parental/guardian consent for an aspirin at school, a body piercing, participation in an off campus field trip or tattoo, but not an abortion,” says Jim Frankowiak, campaign manager for Citizens for Protecting Taxpayers and Parental Rights, the group leading the Yes on Six movement. “Passage of Amendment 6 will enable a family decide together such a personal decision as health care for their minor child without the interference of government.”

(Photos: Political Photos of the Week, Oct. 12-18)

Opponents argue that pregnant minors have a right to make their own decision. “Simply put, Amendment 6 allows politicians in Tallahassee to interfere in a woman’s right to make her own personal medical decisions and a woman deserves to make her own decisions regarding her own health care,” says Lillian Tamayo, campaign chairwoman for Vote No on Six and president of Planned Parenthood of South Florida and the Treasure Coast. “Women don’t turn to politicians for advice about mammograms, prenatal care or cancer treatments—they want to go speak to their families, to their doctors, to their faith leaders, not politicians.” Sandra Fluke, who became a minor political celebrity advocating birth control coverage, has lent her support to the “Vote No on Six” campaign with a television ad criticizing the measure and urging young Florida to come out in force against it.

According to records filed with the Florida Division of Elections, “Vote No on 6” has brought in over $3.2 million in contributions. The Citizens for Protecting Taxpayers and Parental Rights has reported $409,000. But polling indicates voters are closely divided. An October 2 Suffolk University/7NEWS (WSVN-Miami) poll found that 44% of voters support the amendment while 40% oppose it. The amendment needs 60% of the vote to pass.

13 comments
Hollywooddeed
Hollywooddeed

But how does a bunch of Republican politicians getting involved in parent-child matters fit into the idea of small government utopia?

georgiamd
georgiamd

Parents SHOULD be involved in this life changing decision. It is inconceivable that a teenager could make this decision on her own, without knowing the ramifications of the consequences involved.

Numerous studies have shown that few people anticipate the agony an individual may go through followingan abortion. The physical and emotional stress can be devastating, andoften surfaces months, or even years after the event.

By all means, involve the parents of this teenager. Who better to council and support? She is going to need all of the help she can get and what better place to start, than home. 

Eighteen percent of U.S. women obtaining abortion are teenagers; thoseaged 15-17 obtain 6% of all abortions, teens aged 18-19 obtain 11%, andteens under age 15 obtain 4%.

sacredh
sacredh

I'm not much of a fan of this format. I've been having all kinds of problems with it. I have problems with replys. loads, getting kicked out and other things. I'll try again next week to see if it's just bugs in the new system or a killer. Have fun.

salamiolawumi
salamiolawumi

@elizabethjdias @judithannsoflo @lilliantamayo @time

Ivy_B
Ivy_B

Guess if the father has committed incest, there won't be any problem with his signing the parental consent form. Might be an interesting family discussion, however.

nflfoghorn
nflfoghorn

I don't think it'll get the 60% needed.  None of the 11 amendments needs to be approved IMO. 

nflfoghorn
nflfoghorn

How 'bout a family gets together and decides whether their daughter will be sexually active...and what they intend to do about it if she is.  And to hold the guy(s) accountable.  But no, that's hard stuff.

Ohiolib
Ohiolib

@georgiamd 

 People SHOULD do a lot of things. That doesn't give the state the right to mandate it. I personally loathe my mother. The psychotic b!tch caused 2 suicidal breakdowns after I was living at home after college, one of which put in in-patient rehab for 4 days. You honestly think I want to have anything to do with my mother, especially about something like my health choices? Suffice to say that I have a lot of sympathy for those who would rather not give their family veto powers over their health decisions. You're living in Pleasantville, where life is fair, bad things don't happen, and all problems are solved in an hour (minus ads) or less. 

If you ever make ti to reality, feel free to learn something. 

nflfoghorn
nflfoghorn

@sacredh It seems to work when it wants.  

I was all for getting rid of Disqust, but we got no advance warning.  Heck, I can't pull up my avatar.

salamiolawumi
salamiolawumi

@salamiolawumi @elizabethjdias @judithannsoflo @lilliantamayo @time

pa_stan
pa_stan

@Ivy_B Interesting point. However in a proven case of incest (a necessary prerequisite to obtain a free abortion) wouldn't the minor have been removed from the home? I wonder who decides in that case.