Rick Scott’s Tea Party Budget

Our colleague Tim Padgett reports on the red ink battle raging in sunny Florida:

…last week Scott — speaking not from the state capital, Tallahassee, but from the Tea Party hotbed of Eustis, Fla., to show his disdain for all things public sector — delivered a budget proposal that slashes $4.6 billion (7% of current spending) and pink-slips 8,700 state employees, while gutting services like aid for disabilities and juvenile justice.

“Reviewing a government budget is much like going through the attic in an old home,” said Scott, a health care industry multimillionaire who resigned in disgrace as CEO of the world’s largest hospital corporation in 1997 when it was accused of massive Medicare fraud (though he never was). “And I’m cleaning it out.” That drew roars from the Tea Partiers jammed into the First Baptist Church of Eustis, who like Scott believe that bulldozing the budget has to be part of his “7-7-7″ mission — seven steps to 700,000 jobs in seven years.

But in a state where unemployment topped 12% last year, the idea of jettisoning such a large number of workers didn’t go down as well outside Eustis, no matter how loudly Scott insisted that his way will beget far more employment in the private sector. Back in Tallahassee, even fellow Republicans, who control the legislature and are trying to plug a more than $3.5 billion hole in the budget, considered Scott’s budget nonsensical, including his rejection of remaining federal stimulus dollars. “It’s imperative that you go back and you redo the numbers,” GOP state Representative Janet Adkins told a Scott aide at a hearing. Adkins was questioning Scott’s 15% cut, or $3.3 billion, in education spending, at a time when the school reforms and funding of his predecessors in office, Republican Jeb Bush and independent Charlie Crist, are starting to yield improvement.

It was an especially important warning, not just for Florida, but for the rest of a nation trying to absorb the meaning of November’s Tea-phenomenon. That’s because while closing perilous budget deficits certainly has to be a priority today, there’s a big difference between mopping up red ink and rubbing out state government.

Read the whole thing.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    Audacity of Dope: Tales of a Toking Teenage Obama

    We knew Barack Obama smoked weed in high school because he wrote about it in his books. What we didn’t know until Buzzfeed posted these choice nuggets (I’m so sorry) from David Maraniss’s new book on the President’s younger years, is the giggle-worthy details of his “Choom Gang” lifestyle, which are right out of a buddy stoner flick. Obama and his friends drove around the lush Hawaii countryside, hot-boxing their VW bus and re-upping with a long-haired pizza-tossing dealer named Ray, who Obama thanked in his yearbook “for all the good times.”

  • newfreedomblog

    Why no reports or blog posts on what Obama is doing to this Nation? Afraid to report that 3 billion is nothing in comparison to what Obama has proposed?
    .
    Unbelievable.
    .
    http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/feb/14/debt-now-equals-total-us-economy/

  • gysgt213

    The people of Florida voted for the guy. Let him work his magic.

  • freeinpa

    “That’s because while closing perilous budget deficits certainly has to be a priority today, there’s a big difference between mopping up red ink and rubbing out state government.”
    .
    Cutting 7.7% of current of current spending is rubbing out state government? Do you have a passing acquaintance with the word “exaggeration”.
    .
    Why is every tax increase fair and nominal but every cut is catastrophic. To even giving glancing credence to the farce that government spending is efficient and not a dollar is wasted is at best just stupidity at worse is nothing but an out and out lie and borders on journalistic malpractice.

  • shepherdwong

    …pass the popcorn.

  • CP in FL

    Yea, I can’t wait to see more of his “magic.” He promised in his campaign to not cut the education budget in Florida. He then slashed about 3 billion dollars from the education budget. Florida is already close to last of all the states in graduation rates, standardized testing and college preparedness. I guess governor q-ball wants to be last.

  • http://gum0nshoe.wordpress.com gumOnShoe

    I get the whole “train wreck can’t look away” thing, but I’m honestly worried if this is something our system is capable of producing and if our nation is in a position where its ready to do it…

  • apr2563

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Scott

    On March 19, 1997, investigators from the FBI, the Internal Revenue Service and the Department of Health and Human Services served search warrants at Columbia/HCA facilities in El Paso and on dozens of doctors with suspected ties to the company.[18]

    Following the raids, the Columbia/HCA board of directors forced Scott to resign as Chairman and CEO.[19] He was paid $9.88 million in a settlement. He also left owning 10 million shares of stock worth over $350 million.[20][21][22]

    In late 2002, HCA agreed to pay the U.S. government $631 million, plus interest, and pay $17.5 million to state Medicaid agencies, in addition to $250 million paid up to that point to resolve outstanding Medicare expense claims.[23] In all, civil law suits cost HCA more than $2 billion to settle, by far the largest fraud settlement in US history.[24]

    .
    This is the guy Floridians elected to run their finances. Maybe it wasn’t butterflly ballots that caused the votes for Buchanan it that misbegotten state.

  • apr2563

    http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/02/new-wisc-gop-governor-pushes-hard-for-rolling-back-workers-rights-by-decades.php?ref=fpa
    .
    The race is on. Who can be more reactionary?
    .
    New Wisconsin GOP Governor Pushes For Massive Rollback Of Worker Rights
    .
    “In an interview with the Associated Press, Scott Walker proposed stripping nearly all government workers of their collective bargaining rights. And as a warning shot across the bow, he told Wisconsin reporters Friday that he’s alerted the National Guard ahead of any unrest, or in the event that state services are interrupted.”

  • nflfoghorn

    “Let him work his magic”
    .
    Yeh, I’m going to enjoy watching him pull $ out of his bald rump. Balance a $3B budget shortfall by cutting taxes and services.
    .
    Not only is he an unindicted crook, he’s stupid to boot.

  • sasquatch08

    “That’s because while closing perilous budget deficits certainly has to be a priority today, there’s a big difference between mopping up red ink and rubbing out state government.”
    .
    Or we could try Obama’s new strategy: cut $110 billion a year for the next decade from the deficit while still running a deficit of over $1 trillion per year…
    .
    That’s like me saying I overspent on my credit card last month by $1000 (money I don’t have) so the answer is that next month, and for the rest of the year I can fix my mistake by only overspending by $900/month, while totally ignoring the fact that doing so only serves to put me $9000 deeper in debt by years end. It’s insane.

  • nflfoghorn

    What can I say, apr? We got a huge case of the stupids.

  • apr2563

    Well nflfoghorn: My state elected Arnold Scwartzenegger. Twice. How stupid were we? (Disclaimer: I didn’t vote for him) Maybe Rick Scott can learn from the Gropenator.
    .
    One time he had a road crew dig a pot hole in a street so he could be filmed filling it. Rick may need this skill to take the place of all those “guberment” workers who maintain the roads.

  • nflfoghorn

    I’m guessing this will be our new education slogan: “iftieth and Proud of It!”
    .
    He’s certainly not endearing himself to the ‘real’ media down here. He’s doing his best to alienate them by not talking to them. This kook brags about not reading state papers!
    His latest stunt while having a dinner with legislators is to pick a pool reporter insteada fielding questions from everyone. The ‘real’ media effectually told him to stuff it; he went with an online “service” called Sunshine State News, a chicken outfit that thinks Baldy Crook is a “hero.” I mentioned this site last week:
    .
    http://www.sunshinestatenews.com
    .
    God help us if a major hurricane comes this way. State Farm (our largest property insurer) will bolt and we won’t have any $, any insurance – or any plan – to fall back on. >:O

  • nflfoghorn

    I don’t even think our GOP-dominated Legislature much cares for his budget as is. Even they know that we’ve got to pay our bills.

  • nflfoghorn

    “…[W]hile closing perilous budget deficits certainly has to be a priority today, there’s a big difference between mopping up red ink and rubbing out state government.”
    .
    Amen.

  • nflfoghorn

    4.3 s/r: “Fiftieth…”

  • nflfoghorn

    BTW, Florida is one of a handful of states with no income tax.

  • http://erieangel.wordpress.com erieangel

    My brother in law worked for Columbia when he retired from the service in 1996. He lasted six months and, despite opposition from my sister, quit his job because he couldn’t stomach their business practices, though he made no formal complaint against them. Several jobs later and my bil is back working for the army in a civilian capacity. His job is to convince soldiers not to leave the army.

  • freeinpa

    And isn’t it amazing that it managed to survive all of these years without one. How can that be? Taxes are the only way to create jobs, grows entitlements to the point of bankruptcy and grow the economy.

    Say it ain’t so!

  • http://erieangel.wordpress.com erieangel

    I would be ok with a 15% cut to my city’s education expenses, so long as the cuts came in the form of a pay cut to the superintendent. Unfortunately, cuts usually do little to affect those at the top, it is the kids who will suffer from these cuts-as in the lack of books, an increase in class size, further cuts in the arts and sciences but of course, sports programs are seldom touched.

  • jdintlh

    This governor and his ideas are the real consequences of 50,000 vote margin.

    A hurricane? BP oil spill? The damages he is going to wreak on our state will last much longer than any of us can fathom.

    Thanks for nothing, Charlie Crist.

  • shepherdwong

    “…Florida has a broken, “Ponzi scheme of financing government” that relies on population growth to pay for government, said economist Sean Snaith. And with little or no population growth, the state’s finances won’t improve.
    .
    “Florida’s tax structure is flawed fundamentally,” said Snaith, director of the University of Central Florida’s Institute of Economic Competitiveness, which issued a recent report on the state’s troubled condition.
    .
    • Population growth will slow to a trickle as only 37,000 newcomers move to Florida by 2010 — a 60-year low — according to projections by the University of Florida Bureau of Economic and Business Research.
    .
    • The number of jobs in Florida will shrink by another 4 percent in 2009 and increase less than 1 percent in 2010, state economists say.
    .
    • Tax collections will increase only $1 billion next year and another $2 billion in 2011, the economists say. Tax collections for the general revenue portion of the budget dropped $5.5 billion in the last two years.
    .
    • New home construction won’t see any significant uptick until 2012, in part due to an inventory of 300,000 unsold homes, according to forecasts from the Florida Homebuilders Association.

    http://www.tampabay.com/news/politics/legislature/article999627.ece

  • sasquatch08

    That was an overly harsh statement on my part, it’s not like Republicans have a fantastic plan either.
    .
    One of the problems with government spending is that it’s fairly easy to start and difficult to stop, and if you combine the democrats electoral strategy with that of the republicans you end up with a government that is trying to be all things to all people and failing miserably at most of it, which is exactly what we have now.
    .
    $1.1 trillion over the next ten years isn’t going to fix the problem, neither is $500 billion this year; they’re both band-aids on a sucking chest wound. What has to happen is we need to spend about $1.5-$1.8 trillion dollars less every single year going forward. That way we not only get rid of the deficit but actually have a chance at paying off our current debt. Making that debt larger is not an option at this point, because our debt is rapidly approaching our GDP.
    .
    This, unfortunately means deep cuts is many things and the outright elimination of many programs and governmental departments. Everyone is going to have to see cuts in programs they like as well as elimination of “sacred cows” regardless of where you fall on the political spectrum. Simply balancing our budget, quite frankly, is not good enough. We have to have money left over each year to pay down the debt. Even if Obama was suggesting $1.1 trillion in DEBT reduction over the next ten years it would still take almost a century and a half to pay off the national debt.
    ,
    Now, we don’t have to bring the debt down to 0, and I honestly don’t think that’s even possible, but we do have to at least cut it down to $9-$10 trillion in the next decade, which means getting into the black [ink] by at least $300 billion per year going forward and using that money to pay off the debt.
    .
    The truly frightening thing is that this is just the national debt, as a collective the states are in much worse shape in terms of unfunded liabilities which may well prove to be literally impossible to live up to. There’s a whole other layer to this very depressing cake and if the federal government can’t actually handle our debt then the political will to do what needs to be done at the state level doesn’t exist.

  • sasquatch08

    erie,

    You’ve hit the nail right on the head.
    .
    Cities, States, School Districts and yes, even the feds have signed contracts that it’s basically unfeasible to live up to, while at the same time making it virtually impossible to get rid of these people, hire someone new and put a decent contract in place.
    .
    The salaries and benefits of these people are not negotiable, and even if they were legally, they wouldn’t be with the unions. That means everything else, is sort of like the discretionary spending we hear about in the federal budget, and that’s where the money has to saved.
    .
    Science labs don’t get new equipment and end up teaching out of books, new books are not purchased, music programs are cut and in some cases schools are closed and consolidated all for the sake of unionized workers pay and benefits many of whom as you point out are administrators who drive a Benz. They sure do where I went to high school. The administrators drive BMW’s, Mercedes, Lexus’ etc, while the teachers drive a ten year old Volvo, Subaru or Ford.
    .
    There is one thing I would take issue with, and that’s the sports programs. Your name suggests that you’re from Ohio, but even if you aren’t look into what’s going on with the schools in Springfield, Ohio (I went to college there). They screwed the pooch so badly that they don’t even have sports teams anymore and have closed half the schools in the city. (Some of this has to do with demographics, such as the fact that the old people in the town don’t have kids in the schools anymore so they won’t vote yes on school levies.)
    .
    But the point is this; when public sector unions (or unions in general for that matter) are not willing to give an inch, even when they know they’re getting a fantastic deal for their members, everything else goes out the window to pay the union members. Just ask the people who used to work at Northwest what happens when unions get greedy.
    .
    Unions are a great idea, until they become very powerful and start demanding more than the system can bear, which seems to happen reasonably often in both the private and public sectors.

  • troubador222

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_gubernatorial_election,_2010

    Scott was elected with less than 50% of the vote too. I am in Florida. Only thing I can say is I am glad my children are grown and are not in school.

  • rover27

    sasquatch08, I hate to say this, but you’re full of it.

    When George Bush took office in 2001 he inherited the 4th straight budget surplus in a row. The huge National Debt that Clinton inherited from Reagan/Bush I had stabilized for 8 years ans was projected by CBO to be paid off in 10 years. Remember we have always had a National Debt in the U.S. except during Andrew Jackson’s term. But it was always manageable.

    That changed when Reagan, under non-emergency situation, ran up more debt in 8 years than the total debt of all the previous presidents in total.

    After 2001, we had 2 huge tax cuts, 2 unpaid for wars, an unpaid for Medicare prescription program, and deregulation-mania that turned Wall Street into a casino with massive fraud. And gave us the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression.

    All of which was INHERITED by his successor. And now the GOP wants to double down on the “trickle down economics” of the last 30 years that got us here. Are you up for that? We’ve tried it the GOP way for 20 of the last 30 years. And we’ve tried it the Democratic way for 10 of those years. You choose. Plus no president has inherited a situation like Obama. FDR didn’t take office with a huge National Debt to tie his hands, 2 unpaid for wars going, and a GOP congress that tried to sabotage and obstructed every thing he did.

    Like I said, you’re full of it.

  • sasquatch08

    Rover,
    .
    You are either the most economically challenged or the most ideologically driven person in the world.
    .
    Let me drop some factual numbers and reality on you:
    .
    A study done at Harvard, the bastion of conservative thought that it is, showed that of 24 “advanced economies” over the past 800 years shows that they all ceased to grow economically when their debt to GDP ratio hit 90%, many of them collapsed. If we’re not growing our debt will out-pace our income and destroy this country, it really is that simple. So if you care about the “little guy”, it’s time to wise up and get fiscally responsible.
    .
    Obama’s proposed budget for FY 2012 (56% entitlement spending):
    .
    Medicare/Medicaid/CHIP: $1.4 trillion.
    .
    Defense: $730 billion
    .
    Social Security: $761 billion
    .
    Non-Defense: $611 billion
    .
    Interest on our debt: $242 billion
    .
    We spend $4 billion dollars a DAY for interest on the debt. 40 cents of every dollar in that proposed budget is borrowed money, while he did reduce the deficit from $1.6 trillion to $1.1, a step in the right direction no doubt, we’re still set to spend another trillion dollars that we don’t have on top of the $14 trillion we already owe, and that’s with a budget that contains $1 -$1.6 trillion dollars in new taxes over the next ten years. Even raking in another cool $100-$160 billion a year the hole still gets deeper. Oh, and guess what else came out today? Tim Geithner said that we can expect the interest on our debt to TRIPLE by 2016. That would be $726 billion a year almost what he proposes we spend on defense or Social Security next year, that’s $12 billion dollars a DAY. That’s insane, and we simply can’t afford it.
    .
    You can’t tax the rich and get out of this, recinding the Bush tax cuts would net the government about $100 billion a year in increased revenue. Compare that to the $125 billion the government openly admits it misspent last year in “erroneous payments”. It doesn’t even cover the money we paid to people we weren’t supposed to! Not to mention the fact that half of all Americans pay no income tax…
    .
    You can scream about how republicans got us into this mess all you want, but it doesn’t change the fact that we’re in it and spending trillions more dollars we don’t have is not going to get us out of it. You also conveniently ignore how Clinton rode an economy propped up by the dot-com bubble, which like all bubbles, housing included eventually burst. You totally discount the fact that we had a recession after 9/11 and it’s generally agreed that the Bush era tax cuts got us out of it mainly because our economy is 76.7% services and if people don’t buy items or services our economy basically stops. Whether they should be extended is another matter, but blaming Bush for the incompetence of your preferred party is getting rather old.
    .
    “…deregulation-mania that turned Wall Street into a casino with massive fraud…”
    .
    An argument that is just as valid can be made that HUD, combined with policies of Freddy and Fanny, born from the idea that since a house is people’s primary source of real wealth everyone should have one led to the liar loans and 3% down that precipitated a massive bubble in housing values that we are now paying for. It certainly played a part, and I’ll know you have no idea what you’re talking about if you dispute that it played any role.
    .
    “All of which was INHERITED by his successor.”
    .
    Bad behavior is no excuse for more of the same.
    .
    “You choose. Plus no president has inherited a situation like Obama”
    .
    I think the American people decided who they favor in the election last year, or did you miss that headline? And stop bringing up the “situation” Obama was handed. He asked for the job, he got what he asked for. Crying isn’t going to change the fact that many Americans don’t think he’s doing a good job on the economy, nor the fact that Democrats sang from the rooftops that they were all about jobs and then spent a year blathering on about HCR before passing the ACA which did NOTHING for the job situation. Further, it does nothing to change the fact that this guy talks a good game but can’t go a year without adding a trillion to the debt.
    .
    Sorry it’s cuts across the board or we go the way of the Weimar Republic.
    .
    You’re the one that’s full of it, or you’re just going out of your way to be obtuse.

  • anon76

    Interest on our debt: $242 billion
    .
    We spend $4 billion dollars a DAY for interest on the debt.

    Not trying to pre-judge who is more full of it squatch, but either you’re typing from a planet that orbits the sun every 60.5 days, or else you have some serious math issues going on.

  • apr2563

    sasquatch: Unions giving a inch. Do you suppose the bonus babies and loophole gazillionaires could give an inch?

    Unionized workers at Ford Motor Co. have approved contract changes that include freezing wages and cutting benefits in a move to aimed at helping the automaker remain competitive.
    .
    The United Auto Workers union Friday overwhelmingly ratified a labor deal with General Motors that included concessions….

    California: State workers endured the latest tortuous turn in an off-again-on-again furlough saga that has left roughly 144,000 of them uncertain from week to week of their work schedules
    .
    This agreement continues our progress toward critically needed pension reform and, along with the previously reached union agreements, will help address the state’s soaring retirement costs. Unfunded retirement benefits for government employees are a huge problem because, as these costs rise, the state has less and less money for the programs that Californians depend on.

    “Not only will this agreement address long-term unsustainable costs, it also brings necessary relief to California’s taxpayers in the current budget with additional savings in employee pay. I commend SEIU for being a part of the solution to these problems
    .
    Slow and steady, the wave is building. Two small state employee unions have joined four others in making sizable pension concessions in the face the California’s $19 billion budget shortfall.

  • apr2563

    sasquatch: Read #4
    Do you think Rick Scott, after defrauding the state for billions of dollars, forced to resign, yet walked away with a golden parachute is the person who should be holding middle class people accountable for “greed”?

  • sasquatch08

    Anon:
    .
    You caught my typo and I didn’t even realize I made it, that was supposed to say that we’re projected to hit $4 billion a day in the “near” of the next couple years.
    .
    Sorry, I’m not actually getting graded on this writings, nor being paid for them so sometimes my proofreading is lacking.

  • sasquatch08

    Apr,
    .
    “Do you suppose the bonus babies and loophole gazillionaires could give an inch?”
    .
    Is giving the government almost half their hard earned money an “inch”? Is that “fair” when half of Americans don’t pay ANY income tax? Hardly. Further, as I pointed out, rescinding the Bush era tax cuts doesn’t even cover the governments “erroneous payments” which the government openly admits are $25 billion more per year than the government would gain from raising taxes to previous levels. On top of that, we’re one of the most highly taxed nations on the planet, yet we can’t pay for our spending. The spending is clearly a significant part of the problem.
    .
    “Unionized workers at Ford Motor Co. have approved contract changes…”
    .
    Great, they finally learned the dang near 20 year old lesson of Northwest: if you want to milk the cow you have to feed it. Or perhaps they were just scared straight by GM’s near destruction, which would have screwed every UAW worker on GM’s payroll if not for government intervention, which won’t happen with Ford given the current public sentiment.
    .
    “State workers endured the latest tortuous turn in an off-again-on-again furlough saga that has left roughly 144,000 of them uncertain from week to week of their work schedules”
    .
    Considering that they are a huge part of the reason California found itself in a $20 billion+ hole, I’m not going to feel bad for them. They finally learned that the hand that feeds them doesn’t have unlimited resources and that biting it off is bad in the short, medium and long term. As I stated before, when the money is GONE, so is their job. The state cannot pay them money it doesn’t have any more than I can give you the Ferrari that’s not in my possession. Maybe they actually got knocked in the head by reality?
    .
    “This agreement continues our progress toward critically needed pension reform…”
    .
    That’s up for the “Understatement of the Year” Award. Or are you actually admitting that public sector unions with their lavish benefits they [generally] pay nothing for have been bleeding us dry at everyone else’s expense?
    .
    “I commend SEIU for being a part of the solution to these problems”
    .
    You mean the problems they were a major player in creating?
    “Do you think Rick Scott, after defrauding the state for billions of dollars, forced to resign, yet walked away with a golden parachute is the person who should be holding middle class people accountable for “greed”?”
    .
    Not living in Florida, I wouldn’t know, or quite frankly care about Rick Scott or his past. But what I can tell you for a fact is that apparently the voters of the fine state of Florida thought he was a better choice than anyone else in the field. Further, according to this posting he was never found guilty or even charged with fraud, so your statement would appear to be guilt by association.
    .
    Would you like me to tie you to every single crackpot progressive liberal idea? Progressives supported Hitler in the 1930’s you know, heck their prophet, George Bernard Shaw implored science to come up with a “human gas… [for] the liquidation…” of those not suitable for society, which the Germans did by using an insecticide called “Zyklon B”. So then, using an extension of your logic, as a liberal do you support mass murder of those who “consume more than they produce”, or would that be outrageous of me to say? Would it be inappropriate of me to suggest that all liberals were part of the “Kill Bush” movement and actually were supportive of a movement to assassinate the President?
    .
    I was called childish the other day for using “straw men” when I used the exact same extension of this type of logic to suggest that liberals were responsible for the Holodomor, and mass murders in Communist Russia and China, yet many on here do the same thing, saying that by extension anyone who disagreed with the actions of the previous Congress or the Administration was a racist. Seems rather rude when the shoe is on the other foot, does it not?

blog comments powered by Disqus