Morning Must Reads: The Mission

Getty

Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images

–Obama and McChrystal are meeting face-to-face this morning and the administration’s full AfPak team will convene shortly thereafter.

–More consequential than any personnel decision is the overall direction of the war.

–McChrystal is reportedly telling administration officials he’s “compromised the mission.”

–The Washington Post ed board argues his dismissal would do just that.

–Eliot Cohen writes he has to go.

–Bill Kristol more or less agrees.

–Tim Geithner and Larry Summers lay out Obama’s agenda at the upcoming G20 economic summit in Toronto. Much of what they sketch out is long term thinking — stabilizing debt-to-GDP ratios, energy reform, etc. — but they notably give a nod to China’s currency move and emphasize the need for international agreement on capital requirements for the financial sector.

–Financial reform conference committee continues today at 1 p.m. ET. A measure exempting auto-dealers from consumer finance oversight is on tap, but it’s other exemptions that pose a greater risk to the overall potency of the bill. The importance of Scott Brown’s vote and his requested carve-outs for Massachusetts insurance and asset management companies could compromise the Volcker Rule.

–South Carolina Rep. Bob Inglis fell to primary challenger Trey Gowdy in last night’s runoff, the third House incumbent to be unseated so far this cycle.

–Nikki Haley won her runoff without breaking a sweat.

–And John McCain is really loving this J.D. Hayworth infomercial:

What did I miss?

You can contact Adam at swampland@time.com.

Related Topics: 2012 Election, Afghanistan, Barack Obama, Budgets, Congress, Democratic Party, Economy, Miscellany, Republican Party, Senate, White House
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / The White House via Getty Images

    Political Picures of the Week, May 18-25

    TIME’s photo editors bring you the best pictures of the past week from the Beltway and beyond.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    From left: AP; ABACAUSA

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

  • pintortwo

    Go USA Soccer!
    Win today and advance.

  • michaelfury

    “the overall direction of the war”

    http://michaelfury.wordpress.com/2010/02/08/right-of-way/

  • http://elvisberg.wordpress.com Elvis Elvisberg

    More about the fall of Inglis:

    Inglis had a very conservative voting record, and scored well among the far-right organizations that grade lawmakers on their positions.

    But Inglis expressed a willingness to work with Democrats on energy policy; he urged his constituents not to take Glenn Beck too seriously; he thought Joe Wilson was wrong to heckle the president during a national address; and he said his main focus as a lawmaker was to find “solutions” to problems. Last year, Inglis said the Republican Party has a chance to “lose the stinking rot of self-righteousness” and “to understand we are all in need of some grace.”

    And as a result, Republicans turned on Inglis and he lost by 42 points.

    -
    Sometimes, it almost seems like the GOP is more interested in venting animal emotions than in policy!

  • destor23

    McChrystal denies Joe Klein’s scoop about offering his resignation.

    http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/06/mcchrystal-denies-offering-resignation.php?ref=fpi

    Sign me up for an “I Believe Joe” t-shirt but I think he need to hear from Mr. Klein on this.

    And by the way Joe, you should give your scoops to us, your ever-lovin’ Swamplanders before you give them out on CNN!

  • http://selmas1sunshine.wordpress.com selmas1sunshine

    There has been some unheard of things going on in this administration. Too many attacks (treasonous) on the current administration.

  • danielatlanta

    McChrystal is correct, he has compromised the mission. He is a liability now and must be relieved of his command.

  • jsfox

    What surprises me about McChrystal saying that no he hasn’t offered to resign, but that he said anything at all.

    What is so hard for this guy to utter two simple words: No Comment.

  • newfreedomblog

    “If anything, the case for dismissing McChrystal is strengthened by what the article exposes as his failure to win over the hearts and minds of his own men. There is considerable doubt among ordinary soldiers that counterinsurgency is the right strategy, and their commander does not come out of confrontations with them very well. But for insulting behaviour towards the administration? Look elsewhere.”

    .
    http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/adrianmichaels/100044497/general-mcchrystal-has-been-stitched-up/
    .

    “Too many attacks (treasonous) on the current administration.”

    .
    Too many attacks? Oh please expand on this for us all. Or, are you just confusing rhetoric against this Administration’s failure to do anything right as your justification.
    .
    Pointing out the failures of someone (Obama) is not the same thing as failure of that specific person (Obama) to have the ability or intelligence to do the right thing. That is simply not “treasonous”.
    .
    The entire strategy from Obama is the failure. I for one am glad McChrystal has pointed out how bad Obama is at being a Commander in Cheif. Right or wrong, insubordinate or not is not the real problem in Afghanistan. The problem lies directly at the feet of the occupant of 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
    .
    Obama has never had the experience to be President. This has been pointed out over and over again. Jimmy Carter, welcome your new buddy into the failed Presidents’ Club.

  • grape_crush

    He is a liability now and must be relieved of his command.
    .
    That, or busted down to Colonel and assigned to the staff of the next person to be put in charge of the US military presence in Afghanistan…to assist that person in their transition to that theater. McChrystal’s bigmouth aides should be similarly busted down in rank and foot patrol in Tagab, where the could be useful.
    .
    If any of them offers to resign, stop-loss them…as we are stretched thin personnel-wise.

  • danielatlanta

    Actually, George W. Bush is the new president of the Failed Presidents Club. The only thing Bush has done well in his entire life is to fail.

  • newfreedomblog

    An act of kindness for our military.
    .
    I received this in an email today. We can only hope there are more Americans like this lady “on-board”.
    .

    “Sack Lunches”

    I put my carry-on in the luggage

    compartment and sat down in my
    assigned seat.

    It was going to be a long flight..

    ‘I’m glad I have a good book to read

    Perhaps I will get a short nap,’ I thought.

    Just before take-off, a line of soldiers

    came down the aisle and
    filled all the vacant seats,

    totally surrounding me.

    I decided to start a conversation.

    ‘Where are you headed?’ I asked the
    soldier seated nearest to me.

    ‘Petawawa. We’ll be there for two weeks

    for special training, and then we’re being deployed to Afghanistan .

    After flying for about an hour,

    an announcement was made that
    sack lunches were available for five dollars.

    It would be several
    hours before we reached the east,

    and I quickly decided a lunch would
    help pass the time..

    As I reached for my wallet,

    I overheard a soldier ask his buddy if
    he planned to buy lunch.

    ‘No, that seems like a lot of money for
    just a sack lunch.

    Probably wouldn’t be worth five bucks.

    I’ll wait till we get to base.
    His friend agreed.

    I looked around at the other soldiers.

    None were buying lunch.
    I walked to the back of the plane

    and handed the flight attendant a
    fifty dollar bill.

    ‘Take a lunch to all those soldiers.’

    She grabbed my arms and squeezed tightly.

    Her eyes wet with tears,

    she thanked me.

    ‘My son was a soldier in Iraq ,

    it’s almost like you are doing it for him..’

    Picking up ten sacks,

    she headed up the aisle to where the
    soldiers were seated.

    She stopped at my seat and asked,

    ‘Which do you
    like best – beef or chicken?’

    ‘Chicken,’ I replied, wondering

    why she asked.
    She turned and went to the front

    of plane, returning a minute
    later with a dinner plate

    from first class.

    This is your thanks.

    After we finished eating,

    I went again to the back of the plane,
    heading for the rest room.

    A man stopped me.

    ‘I saw what you did.

    I want to be part of it.

    Here, take this.’

    He handed me twenty-five
    dollars..

    Soon after I returned to my seat,

    I saw the Flight Captain coming
    down the aisle,

    looking at the aisle numbers

    as he walked,I hoped he was not looking for me, but noticed he was looking at the numbers
    only on my side of the plane.

    When he got to my row he stopped, smiled,
    held out his hand, and said,

    ‘I want to shake your hand.’

    Quickly unfastening my seat-belt

    I stood and took the Captain’s hand.

    With a booming voice he said,

    ‘I was a soldier and I was a military pilot.

    Once, someone bought me a lunch.

    It was an act of kindness I never forgot.’

    I was embarrassed when applause

    was heard from all of the passengers.

    Later I walked to the front of the plane

    so I could stretch my legs.

    A man who looked 20 was seated about

    six rows in front of me reached out
    his hand, wanting to shake mine.

    He left another twenty-five dollars
    in my palm.

    When we landed I gathered my

    belongings and started to depart.
    Waiting just inside the airplane door

    was a man who stopped me, put
    something in my shirt pocket, turned, and walked away without saying a word.
    Another twenty-five dollars!

    Upon entering the terminal,

    I saw the soldiers gathering for their
    trip to the base.

    I walked over to them and handed

    them seventy-five dollars.

    ‘It will take you some time to

    reach the base. It will be
    about time for a sandwich.

    God Bless You.’

    Ten young men left that flight feeling

    the love and respect of their fellow travelers.

    As I walked briskly to my car,

    I whispered a prayer for their

    safe return. These soldiers were
    giving their all for our country.

    I could only give them a couple of meals.
    It seemed so little…

    A veteran is someone who,

    at one point in his life, wrote a blank
    check made payable to

    ‘The United States of America ‘

    for an amount of
    ‘up to and including my life.’

    That is Honor, and there are way

    too many people in this country
    who no longer understand it.’

    May you have the strength and

    courage to pass this along to

    everyone on your email buddy list….

    I JUST DID

  • grape_crush

    correction: “where they could be useful”

  • Ffred

    From Brad Tuttle: From June 2009 to March 2010—the heart of the health care debate—only 9% of media stories about health care reform actually “focused on a core issue — how our health care system currently functions, what works and what doesn’t,” according to a Pew Research study; the study says that 41% of health care stories were devoted to tactics and strategies for getting reform passed (or not), and 69% of Americans said the debate was hard to follow

  • m0mentom0ri

    Chuck Schumer, the banker’s best friend. Can we get a primary challenger against him? Pretty please?
    .
    http://www.openleft.com/diary/19202/house-conferees-pass-swipe-fee-compromise-schumer-goes-to-gop-to-seek-further-exemptions

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    Firing the most capable man for such an important job because he’s overly candid is a terrible idea. No doubt, McChrystal totally scr***d Obama: An uber respected general hailed as the only competent one over there basically admits to the public he has little respect for the administration. It makes Obama look terrible. But firing McChrystal makes Obama look weak.

    Nothing to do but suck this one up and move on for the prez, lest he look like a vain 18th century royal who would rather lead his country into disaster than take a blow to his pride.

  • pintortwo

    The entire strategy from Obama is the failure.
    .
    It’s Petraeus and McChrystal’s strategy. Unless you mean that by deferring to his hold-over generals and not developing a new plan upon taking office, Obama has failed- in which case, I agree.

  • Ffred

    Speaking of pretty please, can we get a decent Dem challenger in AZ? For any position whatsoever?

  • jsfox

    If he is the most capable then we have bigger problems. No general is irreplaceable. Next, he has already admitted he has now compromised the mission.

    And you need to go read article 89 of the UMCJ. This has zero to do with looking like a vain 18th century royal. And everything to do with command structure, trust and respect.

    Good grief Bush et al fired generals left and right for far less transgressions

  • grape_crush

    What did I miss?

    - And here I thought we could go a day without a right-winger saying something stupid.

    “We’re here on Wall Street. We are on Main Street. Trust those people who built the economy in the past.”

  • pintortwo

    Notice how the WaPo editorial staff, dominated by neoconservatives, opines that Obama should keep McChrystal.
    .
    By keeping Mulen, Gates, Petraeus, McChrystal and Odierno, and allowing them to craft policy, Obama has tacitly approved the mission they were appointed to complete by the previous administration. The neocons are happy.
    .
    Obama, IMO, was too concerned with taking heat from the right-wing media. He should have replaced this whole crew and gave his new Pentagon orders to get us out- in order to better protect Americans. Hopefully, the fuss over McChrystal’s insubordination will provide Obama the opening to change direction.

  • freeinpa

    “And here I thought we could go a day without a right-winger saying something stupid”

    And yet it will in no way offset the stupidity of the left.

  • grape_crush

    - But what about the deficit?

    “The request came in a letter on Tuesday from President Obama to the House speaker, Nancy Pelosi, asking for $500 million in additional border security spending to go with 1,200 National Guard troops Mr. Obama plans to send.

    ‘This request responds to urgent and essential needs,’ Mr. Obama wrote without elaborating, though administration officials have previously said that their plans fit an 18-month effort to increase border security”

  • porkdumpling

    Michael Crowley embarrassed himself on Morning Joe today. Luckily, the editor of Rolling Stone was there to refute all of Michael’s assertions to the point that Crowley had to take them all back, tail between his legs. A pathetic performance.

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    Ha. Please don’t come at me with your paucity of expertise! I have read the article, as has everyone who’s been following the situation.

    I’m not a military expert or a DC insider so I don’t know for sure, but the CW is that McChrystal is by far the best man for the job.

    Of course some generals are irreplaceable. Get rid of Rommell and North Africa falls to the Allies much sooner.

    As I mentioned in another thread, it’s like if you’re deathly ill and you fire your best doctor because he’s arrogant. Sure, you can do it, but it’s moronic.

    He’s only “compromised the mission” in the sense that he’s made the administration look awful.

  • freeinpa

    You can almost hear the music from “Send in the Clowns” It’s too late they are already here!
    =

    New Home sales down 33%- lowest ever recorded

    =
    3 Federal Court Ninth District had 3 decisions overturned by Supreme Court- Sotomayor voted with Ninth District

    =
    Nearly 1,300 prison inmates wrongly received more than $9 million in tax credits for homebuyers despite being locked up when they claimed they bought a home, a government investigator reported Wednesday
    =
    President Barack Obama’s nominee to serve on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit, Robert N. Chatigny, did legal work as a private defense attorney in 1992 for convicted serial killer Michael Ross and then, in 2005, as a federal district judge, led a proceeding that resulted in a delay in Ross’ execution.
    =
    Backing up his rhetoric behind the scenes, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is quietly working on a new regulation to determine when insurance price increases are “unreasonable” and potentially prohibited by law. (A Government takeover coming to your town soon)
    =

    The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), a liberal consumer advocacy organization, has announced it will sue McDonald’s unless the fast-food franchise stops using toys to market its “Happy Meals” to children.

  • grape_crush

    - Status on the Disclose Act.

    “Rep. Mike Castle (Del.), one of just two Republican sponsors of a sweeping campaign finance bill, is so upset about late changes to the measure that he is considering withdrawing his support and voting against it.

    ‘He’s absolutely opposed to the exemption,’ Castle spokeswoman Kate Dickens told The Hill. ‘The exemptions are getting bigger and bigger. I don’t think they are even done yet.’”

  • square1

    Shorter Rusty: blah, blah, blah, blah, Obama failure, blah, blah, blah, blah.
    .
    Rusty, feel free to cut and paste the above to save yourself typing time.

  • porkdumpling

    Generals are always always replaceable. Always. The military wouldn’t work if they weren’t.
    .
    The only thing that matters is the mission. McChrystal forgot that when he and his aides shot of their mouths. He compromised the mission. (And he wasn’t doing that good a job before this story came out.) He’s got to go.

  • porkdumpling

    How about that story on David Vitter’s aid who attacked his girlfriend with a knife a couple years ago? Family values, huh?

  • grape_crush

    - Invest in your future.

    “The Obama administration on Tuesday backed a proposal to spend up to $6 billion more on subsidies for electric vehicles, amid renewed interest on Capitol Hill in measures to cut petroleum consumption in response to the Gulf of Mexico oil spill.

    The proposals include more spending for research and development of car-battery technology, aid to utilities and homeowners to build recharging outlets, and consumer tax credits to offset the higher costs of battery-electric vehicles.”

  • grape_crush

    - If you really want more, scream it out louder / Get it on the floor, bring out the fire

    “Spending tops the list. A full 80% think it would help at least a little. Poll-takers’ last choice was personal income tax cuts, with 67% of the vote. Fascinatingly more people (73%) think budget cuts would help than that. If anyone can identify a time when budget cuts in a vacuum (which would almost certainly include government job layoffs) during a weak recovery created jobs, please point it out, because you might win a Nobel Prize for economics.”

  • freeinpa

    - Invest in your future.

    Is French for spending more money we don’t have to force people to do things they don’t want to do

  • http://selmas1sunshine.wordpress.com selmas1sunshine

    McChrystal should be given an early retirement..What was he expecting. Heck he is a well seasoned officer he knows better. To take the low road and disresprect the Presidents Adminisration I think was delibrate.

    Someone should pass a bill that military personnel should not interview with mags like Rolling Stone. They need to be working not playning footsie with rock stars!

    He has no respect for authorithy and has demonstrated a lack of good judgement.

    Also his record is not a rosey one.

    He is treasonous!

    UCMJ read it!

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    Saying “generals are alway replaceable” is nonsensical. Was Robert E. Lee replacable? His military brilliance is widely credited as being the only reason the south had any major success in the Civil War. Was Napoleon, who conquered Europe with a relatively small army, replaceable?

  • freeinpa

    How about that story on David Vitter’s aid who attacked his girlfriend with a knife a couple years ago
    ==
    Let’s focus on one guy while the entire country and economy is going down the crapper. I suppose the left would be more forgiving if it was an illegal immigirant instead

  • porkdumpling

    Wouldn’t have brought it up but for your intense interest in some judicial nominee in the 2nd circuit. Pick and choose, free.

  • freeinpa

    What about the deficit?
    =
    Put a moratorium (Obambi seems to like that) on give aways to union, activist groups and other programs that are fraud pockets and actually perform a duty that is defined in the constitution–Protect this country!

  • freeinpa

    Maybe a tub of lard ex-VP and the largest source of global warming

    http://www.katu.com/news/local/96980354.html

  • porkdumpling

    Actually, it’s not nonsensical, and if you had any idea of how the military worked, you’d know that. In the military, the group, the mission, the purpose is always more important than one guy. And generals are, for the most part, one guy.
    .
    If Robert E. Lee didn’t get the job done, then yeah, he’s replaceable. When Napolean lost at Waterloo, he was ‘replaced.’ McChrystal is not getting the job done, this flap with Rolling Stone being the latest buffoonery. So replace him. Your reverence is misplaced and comes from ignorance.

  • freeinpa

    He has no respect for authorithy and has demonstrated a lack of good judgement.

    Also his record is not a rosey one.

    He is treasonous!

    ==
    Had to go back and re-read your first paragraph, I thought you were describing any number of current Demos in office including the First Tourist

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    New Home sales down 33%- lowest ever recorded
    .
    I thought you believed in free markets Freep. Supply and demand. Are you actually suggesting that the government should be trying to prop up home sales in the face of a glut of inventory?

  • centfan

    Until gas prices are $5 a gallon, the lead time to get a Chevy Volt is 18 months, and no bus or train services have been improved or even kept up for ten years.

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    Well if you knew anything about elementary logic you would know never to use “always” in a debate.

    You seem confused. No one, except for yourself, has mentioned firing McChrystal for his performance. That wasn’t on the table before or after his gaff. The question is if he should be canned for this gaff, period.

  • porkdumpling

    Or it’s free’s way of stating his support for the stimulus, that included the home buyers’ tax credit which recently expired and is credited with the 33% drop for the month.

  • porkdumpling

    I said always and I meant always. You have no idea what was on the table and off the table before this gaffe and after. Are you unaware that things in Afghanistan have not been going well?
    .
    Nevertheless, this one gaffe alone has undermined McChrystal’s own role by exposing him as a clumsy buffoon with no discretion, enough to get him canned. He’s lost credibility from above and below. What a disgrace.

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    Freep is the only adult I know who still thinks that ‘I’m rubber, you’re glue” is actually funny.

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    If that’s your opinion, fine, but you are confusing the issue. You are saying that McCrystal should be fired for his overall performance while the rest of the world is debating whether he should be fired for his gaff.

    Saying he should be fired for doing a lousy job is like taking a stand that the desert is incontestably hot.

  • porkdumpling

    No, I didn’t say that, if you read my post at all. I said this gaffe was offense enough to fire him, but that his performance previous to the gaffe wasn’t that great either, certainly not good enough to hang onto him. News from Afghanistan has not been good for a while, so this change in leadership will bring new energy and renewed purpose.

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    Your opinion on his performance would seem to be in the extreme minority.

  • porkdumpling

    You’re on crack, or haven’t been reading or watching the news. Afghanistan has not been going well for a while.

  • apr2563

    Who gives a rats a$$ what Bill Kristol thinks? He has been consistently wrong in his neo-con predictions. He has probably enabled the death of thousands. He has supported torture. Why include him in any serious discussion?

  • http://ringwalk.wordpress.com ringwalk

    Only 2/3 of the surge troops have been deployed. “You’re on crack.” You’re a big one for throwing stones but not a big one for information.

    It doesn’t matter that McCrystal is gone; you know they are still going to follow his plan and strategy right?

    Of course that is only according to a guy at a DC military think take, not the omniscient “pork dumpling.”

  • maverick2k9

    About the failed president’s club – Dubya has all the qualifications.
    .
    Coming to the one term President’s club, I have a lot more respect for Bush Sr than his son or The Dear Leader Ronald Regan.
    .
    Better to be a one term President than run the country to the ground in 8 years.

blog comments powered by Disqus