Rock Bottom

Take a good look around, Democrats, this is likely to be as bad as it’s going to get. As Kate Pickert and I note in a story out today on time.com, the 24-hour cable net cycle has been stuck on ugly process maneuverings in the vacuum of no score from the Congressional Budget Office and no bill. This meme just adds to the back room aura and sweetheart reputation the legislation has enjoyed for months. You’re getting hit on all sides – from the President, the Speaker, constituents, even donors. Oh, and, it turns out most folks really do hate you.

But, oh how quickly things can change. If you pass the bill, next week’s coverage is likely to trumpet triumph, the most productive legislative session since LBJ, an historic and seminal victory. It’s getting from here to there that’s the hard part – especially for those 12-20 swing votes under the most pressure. For them, especially the vulnerable ones, this might not be rock bottom: they may well lose reelection. On the other hand, as Paul Begala told the House Democratic Caucus yesterday, does anyone think that voters at the polls in November will remember self-executing rules and the Cornhusker kickback? They didn’t remember Tom DeLay’s arm twisting (which won him a reprimand from the House Ethics Committee) on the Medicare Prescription Drug bill, no matter how hard Dems tried to remind them. So, really, this whole process brouhaha is directed at those swing Democrats, attempting to scare them into bringing down the bill. Because, if Republicans really thought that passage of health care reform was going to be bad for Dems, would they be protesting quite so much right now? As Republicans used to say before the 2004 elections defending Medicare Part D, it’s hard to spend hundreds of billions of dollars expanding health care coverage and not have it be a net positive in the polls.

Subscribe to Jay Newton-Small on Facebook
Related Topics: 2012 Election, Democratic Party, health care reform, House passage, 2012 Election, Barack Obama, Congress, Democratic Party, Health Care, Nancy Pelosi, Republican Party, White House
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / The White House via Getty Images

    Political Picures of the Week, May 18-25

    TIME’s photo editors bring you the best pictures of the past week from the Beltway and beyond.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    From left: AP; ABACAUSA

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

  • allthingsinaname

    Now that is a Rock Bottom Report.

  • stuartzechman

    Jay Newton-Small:
    .
    But didn’t you hear?
    .
    PhRMA is going to run a $6 million ad campaign to pressure Dems into voting for the Senate bill!
    .
    link to Drudgico story
    .
    Victory for reform must surely be at hand, now that PhRMA is living up to their side of the White House deal.
    .
    You can’t quite call a huge industry ad buy to push the Senate bill “Rock Bottom,” can you?

  • deconstructiva

    Jay, thanks for pointing out how quickly things can change. Some big issues may unite the public once the main HCR mess is over. I really wonder how much HCR will be pushed aside in the news once it passes or fails, and then the next big topic takes over.
    .
    I doubt the D’s and R’s will ever play kissy-face over jobs and unemployment benefits, esp. Bunning, but R filibusters (fake or real) don’t look so good here. Finance reform may be another kumbaya moment if not screwed up? (meaning it will be screwed up,of course) Many tea party groups hate corporate corruption both on politics and in itself (bonuses, bad banking practice that caused the recession). Same for progressives. Watching the R’s filibuster in defense of Wall Street will be highly amusing. Are you seeing hints of these already, Jay? Thanks for your thoughts.
    .
    …and btw. I don’t know whether you, KT, Kate, or Amy will be covering finance reform (along with Barbara Kiviat, I presume). Hopefully the wonkish upcoming debates over derivatives, crappy mortgages, bank reserves, and lending practices don’t put YOU to sleep. Think of the public reactions, tea parties, etc. over these Wall St. outrages instead.

  • allthingsinaname

    ‘Oh, and, it turns out most folks really do hate you.”
    .
    .
    Not really, the overwhelming majority of incumbents get reelected. We hate the other guy’s politicians.

  • nflfoghorn

    I think she’s saying the sniping right now is as bad as it’s going to get.

  • spob

    JNS, perhaps the arm-twisting went down the memory hole, but the “culture of corruption” message went down pretty well, and shenanigans like DeLay’s arm-twisting added to the message.
    .
    “Because, if Republicans really thought that passage of health care reform was going to be bad for Dems, would they be protesting quite so much right now?”

    Maybe they think the thing is bad for the country.

  • http://theblindspotsofgod.wordpress.com lawyermommy

    Excellent piece! I could not agree more.

    The Republicans are aware of how short public memory can be when a politician “wins” his “fight”– DeLay’s case was a great example.

    The problem is that Democrats have been caught up in their own re-election concerns fueled in large part by Republican driven outcries–which for the most part were and are baseless.
    Consequently, many Democrats failed to recognize the dire need to focus on the passage of a comprehensive health-care reform bill.

    The public has a short attention span if you win and in most cases, long one if you lose. :)

    The beneficiaries of a successful passage of this bill into law will be Obama and the Democrats.

    LM

    http://theblindspotsofgod.wordpress.com/2010/03/10/technology-savvy-nigerian-criminals-are-the-greatest-threat-to-national-security/

  • http://www.twitter.com/jnsmall Jay Newton-Small

    bingo nflfoghorn

  • square1

    as Paul Begala told the House Democratic Caucus yesterday, does anyone think that voters at the polls in November will remember self-executing rules and the Cornhusker kickback?

    No, but what Begala has to worry about is that people will remember how much their insurance premiums and co-pays have gone up, including over the past year, and that this “historic” legislation does virtually nothing to prevent further significant increases.

    I just don’t see how fining the uninsured for being uninsured until they buy an expensive and unpopular product is the same as universal health care.

    Even when Herbert Hoover promised a “chicken in every pot and a car in every garage” he didn’t try to achieve his goal by fining people until they purchased those products.

  • stuartzechman

    I’m saying that the sniping amongst Democrats is going to get even worse, much worse.

  • nflfoghorn

    I’m zinging it like Sidney Crosby or somethin’ ;)

  • stuartzechman

    You don’t think that PhRMA’s huge ad buy promoting the Senate bill will convince folks that their premium bills aren’t actually going up, that it’s just their eyesight or something?

  • nflfoghorn

    Zech, that may be true later but in terms of passing the bill (which at this point is all that matters) if Dems can weather the storm they’re golden.

  • nflfoghorn

    That’s secondary to “this thing could really sink us as a party so let’s kill it.”

  • Paul-no not that one

    Stuart-YOU are concerned about sniping between/among Democrats?

  • allthingsinaname

    Going up anywy. Just can’t sit back and do nothing because something is going to change.
    .
    It is the reason why so little gets done, if I do this this happens, if I don’t it happens anyway it just doesn’t look like it is my fault.
    .
    Pass the thing.

  • grape_crush

    …it turns out most folks really do hate you.

    That’s an odd statement, considering that the ‘first thought’ at the link says,

    In the poll, just 17% approve of Congress’ job, while a whopping 77% disapprove.

    While I don’t dispute the feeling of negativity toward Congress, I don’t think it’s fair for you to say that it’s purely an issue for Democrats.

    As a side note, that ‘First Thoughts’ section over at MSNBC is a rehashing of insider conventional wisdom, not a serious attempt at analysis. Small wonder you’d be attracted to that, Jay.

    From the Time.com article:

    In the short term, the GOP tactic to focus attention on process may be working, at least among the Washington press corps.

    And problem is at the root of any sort of concern about winning the war of messaging: the press is either sympathetic to the Republican lines of attack, unwilling to take the time to become better informed, or too sure of their intellectual prowess of themselves and their peers. It’s an uphill battle against the false arguments offered by Republicans when a complacent media fails to fulfill its role.

  • newfreedomblog

    It doesn’t matter unless you can somehow appease the pro-life Dems. Stupak has just said again on Fox, “no, I will not vote for this bill”.
    .
    Done, gone, cue the fat lady to start singing!!

  • FlownOver

    Sounds to me as if much of the problem lies with your irresponsible and/or incompetent colleagues, Jay.

    If the media could get around to responsible reporting instead of parroting and sensationalism maybe we’d get more responsible behavior from the people making policy.

    …yeah, that’s gonna happen.

  • stuartzechman

    PNNTO:
    .
    If some Dems start literally using PhRMA ad campaign talking points –perhaps even unwittingly– in support of this legislation’s passage, then, yes, you could say that I’m just a tad “concerned.”

  • grape_crush

    “their intellectual” should read, “the intellectual”

  • stogiefan2010

    Paul Begala was an idiot shill for the Clinton White House, and he’s is still an idiot shill

    1)November is right around the corner
    2) do u honestly think the Repubs/conservatives will let the public forget about this bill and the way it passes (IF it passes)
    and
    3) Hey Paul, I have 4 words for u : “BROWN ELECTED IN MASSACHUSETTS” !!

  • http://effingconservatives.blogspot.com MrMaryk

    Jay, were you a cheerleader in High School?

    ‘Cause you sure are cheerleading here.

    Less advocation, more straight down-the-line reporting, please. It doesn’t make your employer look good.

  • higgins1990

    It will only get worse from here on out for the Dems.

    Time, a partner with CNN and the DNC.

  • jackdavis1

    A majority…that’s A MAJORITY…of Americans DO NOT want Obamacare to pass. Get it? A majority.

    If the Dems strong-arm this abomination through, and I’m borrowing from Harry Truman here, they will experience a rain of ruin the like of which NEVER has been seen in American politics.

  • http://wareagle01.wordpress.com wareagle01

    Not sure I get it. Are you saying that you, a journalist, are going to give waivering Dems positive coverage if they pass the bill? Isn’t that advocacy, and as a professional journalist should you really be writing that?

  • dophouse

    Hmmm?

    We got our first Black President, They want him to fail

    They say if you ain’t Conservative, You going to Hell,

    But my God don’t play no Politics

    If he had to vote I bet it’d be Obama b*tch!

    Ya’ll fools more dumb than Potsie

    How you gonna call a Black Man a Nazi

    Those are some lyrics, now check out the video for

    SOMETIMES I… by Macarone

    Download free at http://www.thedopincrecords.com

blog comments powered by Disqus