Aloha Neil Abercrombie

There’s a legend in Hawaii about a surfer named Eddie Aikau. In the 70’s Eddie was the top lifeguard in Waimea Bay on Oahu, winning dozens of surf competitions. He was always the guy willing to risk his life, no matter how rough the water, to make a save. Eddie volunteered for the 1978 Polynesian Voyaging Society’s 30-day, 2,500-mile paddling voyage, tracing the ancient route of the Polynesian migration between the Hawaiian and Tahitian island chains. His double hulled canoe developed a leak in one of the hulls and later capsized about twelve miles south of the island of Molokai. That first night Eddie begged the captain to let him paddle on his long board the 12 miles to shore, but fearing for Eddie’s life the captain refused. By the next morning, the situation was getting dire. Though they were now 20 miles from shore, the captain allowed Eddie to go. He was never seen again. The rest of the crew was later rescued by the U.S. Coast Guard and ensuing search for Eddie was the largest air-sea search in Hawaii history. In Eddie honor, Quicksilver sponsors the “The Eddie” – a big surf invitational competition at Waimea Bay held only when open ocean swells top 20 feet (meaning at face height they’re 30 feet).

Throughout the late 70′s bumper stickers were everywhere on the islands, “Eddie would go.” In Hawaii culture it has come to symbolize the ultimate bravery and sacrifice for others and for one’s ideals.

Both Rep. Neil Abercrombie (who went to school Obama’s parents in Honolulu) and President Obama would know the story of Eddie. One could argue that Obama’s pushing through of health care reform at all costs is an “Eddie would go” move. Abercrombie, not so much. Yesterday he resigned, depriving House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of a an “aye” vote at a time when every vote counts on health care reform, to focus on his run for governor. Sure – his departure is mitigated by the resignation of Rep. Nathan Deal, a Georgia Republican – but Dems are asking, Abercrombie couldn’t have toughed it out another month to see health care done?

His departure also means that a special election will be held on May 22 to fill Abercrombie’s seat for the rest of his term. The heavy favorite is Honolulu Council Member Charles Djou, the Republican candidate. The two Democratic candidates, former Rep. Ed Case and State Senate President Colleen Hanabusa have focused their fire on each other. The district, which encompasses Pearl Harbor, is heavily military and is more GOP-leaning than its overwhelming vote for native son Obama in 2008 would imply. Losing the district would be a blow to Dems not only for the lost seat in a blue state but becuase this is literally the President’s childhood home.

Subscribe to Jay Newton-Small on Facebook
Related Topics: 2012 Election, eddie aikau, hawaii's first district, health care reform, neil abercrombie, resignation, 2012 Election, Barack Obama, Congress, Democratic Party, Health Care, Nancy Pelosi, Republican Party, State Governments, White House
  • Latest on Swampland

    Craig Warga / NY Daily News via Getty Images

    Birth Control Debate: Why Catholic Bishops Have Lost Their Grip on U.S. Politics—and Their Flock

    The clash with the White House over birth control is a reminder of just how much influence the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has lost in the 10 years since the child sex abuse crisis erupted in America.

    Romney: I Was A 'Severely Conservative' GovernorHuffPost Politics

    Obama to Submit His Budget to Congress on Monday

    President Barack Obama is pressing for investments in infrastructure while relying on familiar tax increases on the wealthy and corporations to claim progress on the federal deficit in his upcoming budget.

  • kevin

    Pearl Harbor.

  • grape_crush

    Flies, I tell ya…Flies! Dropping! Like!

    Apologies. Still channeling wingnut from over this past weekend.

  • http://www.twitter.com/jnsmall Jay Newton-Small

    Every once in a while my Australian heritage flies its flag. But I changed harbour back to the American spelling.
    JNS

  • square1

    One could argue that Obama’s pushing through of health care reform at all costs is an “Eddie would go” move.

    Yes, one could ague that…if one wanted to make the worst analogy in the history of analogies.

    Pushing through health care reform “at all costs”? Is this a laughable joke or what? From the get go, Obama refused to go to bat for meaningful health care reform. At best, we would get a compromised, flawed bill. At worst — which is where we are now — we would be faced with a bill that is actually worse than doing nothing: the Senate Bill.

    At no time was Obama willing to pass HCR “at all costs”. He was unwilling to fight the insurance industry. He was unwilling to fight the pharmaceutical industry. He was unwilling to risk the loss of campaign donations or the disapproval of corporate Beltway scolds.

    Obama never demanded that Blue Dogs cease their idiotic and self-serving filibuster threats. Never told the GOP to piss off. And never insisted on a Senate floor vote for the public option, the inclusion of which would undoubtedly have saved “Ted Kennedy’s seat.”

    By and large, modern politicians are not courageous figures who will do whatever it takes in the name of good policy. Most, like Obama, are unwilling to make waves or risk re-election.

    The closest a President came to an Eddie Aikau moment in the past 50 years was when LBJ fought for and passed civil rights legislation knowing that the Democrats would lose the South “for a generation.” (Incidentally, he underestimated the unpopularity.)

  • formerlyjames

    square1, I won’t quibble with your excellent point, but would point out that LBJ worked on civil rights legislation from the ’40s when he was the man in the Senate, and at various times he did hold back waiting for the right moves.
    .
    Mostly, I just want to note one of my pet peeves. When civil rights progress is mentioned, it’s always MLK, of course, and the Kennedys, when in fact the giants were LBJ and Truman.

  • billiecat

    Thanks, JNS, for bringing the story of Eddie Aikau to my attention. I mean that sincerely – it’s fascinating and I never knew of it before.
    .
    OT – Are you itching to go to Chile to cement your rep for big quake reportage?

  • FlownOver

    “Its,” not “it’s.”

  • square1

    I’ve reached a point where I give a JNS a pass on the grammatical mistakes. Like with Matthew Yglesias, the typos come so fast and furious from JNS that if we spend our time proofing the blog posts, we won’t have any time to comment on the substance.

  • FlownOver

    It takes very little time once you’ve learned the basic rules – as I did in pubic elementary school decades ago.

    The other reason I carp about grammatical errors in a national news magazine’s online product is to spur employment. Surely Time Inc. can afford a freakin’ copy editor!

    That said, square1, I’ll try to keep my Grammar Nazi persona restrained.

  • constantweader

    Fitch Abercrombie. I know Hawaiians have good healthcare (just ask Rushbo), but Ambercrombie should have waited 6 weeks to retire if he cared at all about the rest of the American people.

    The Constant Weader at http://www.RealityChex.com

  • danventing

    Square1 & Flownover: Thanks for the posts; I was beginning to think that I was the only person who noticed the grammar. AP & Yahoo are the worst: “they sunk the boat”. For an industry of people who make their living with words, they don’t seem to have much of a handle on words, and for it to come from Time is unforgivable. I have no doubt that “like” will be prevalent soon: “they, like, write their, like, comments in a, like, haphazard fashion.”

  • FlownOver

    It’s my personal “À la recherche du temps perdu.” If I had demonstrated inability to spell a simple possessive pronoun correctly my journalism professors would have suggested career guidance. Nowadays “communications studies” has become a safe major for “student athletes” – or would-be governors.

  • peterkay

    Eddie would GOP

  • 2xvietvet

    This article is the absolute WORST analogy I have ever seen. Eddie Aikau was a great surfer who became a hero primarily because he died. What could that possibly have to do with a President who knows the people don’t want the government to run one sixth of the economy and didn’t want Socialized Medicine when Hilary tried to shove it down our throats. A President that thinks that the resounding loss of the Kennedy seat is only an indication that he didn’t EXPLAIN his health plan well enough for the poor ignorant citizens to understand it. I expect his explanation for the rise of the Tea Party is another, “failure to communicate”.
    I lived in Hawaii for over 20 years, worked as a District Attorney and flew in the Guard right after Eddie Went. Hardly anyone remembers him anymore but everyone remembers Abercrombie who is an extremely Liberal throwback to the 60′s with shoulder length hair who looks like a fat, dumpy Charlie Chaplain. His aspirations for Linda Lingle’s seat are simply a matter of political power and apparently the Democratic Party wasn’t willing to make it worth his while to wait.
    Incidentally in all the time I lived, worked and raised a family in Hawaii I never heard of Obama or knew that he went to Punahou, the most expensive high school in the state. A school I couldn’t afford to send my kids to.
    Your article says more about it’s author than about it’s subject matter. Could you possibly kiss his incompetent ass more?

  • FlownOver

    Did you happen to notice you didn’t get around to addressing a single substantive issue in the president’s proposal?

  • deconstructiva

    Not all great writers are greta spellers –
    http://www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/22107

  • apr2563

    Former: Thank you. Truman and LBJ were the Presidential heroes of civil rights. Kennedy had to be relucntantly drawn in due to his political concerns. MLK of course was the provocative lead.

  • apr2563

    correction: reluctantly
    Lord I have tourette’s fingers today.

  • apr2563

    Obama went to Punahou on a scholarship. Sorry you didn’t qualify.

  • anon76

    Flownover,

    As much as I agree with your points regarding grammar, I note that you credit ‘pubic school’ for your own abilities. It’s one of the reasons I try to avoid scolding on grammar.

  • drewomite

    Should not have mentioned Eddie in the same text as Obama. One is honest, ethical and a hero. The other a corrupt punk that should have never been elected.

  • pdw1948

    I agree that the comparison of Eddie and Obama’s tactic’s is poor, but your noting that Charles Dijou is the favorite is misleading. Charles Dijou is in one word “dynamic” and very well qualified. Let’s say he is what I would consider the opposite of Neil Abercrombie in his thinking and in most states would be the favorite, but you must remember that in Hawaii having the “D” next to your name has been the tool to get elected and the “D” by itself has often beat much more qualified, more ethical and people who represent the thinking of the center and right. A Republican or Independent always had a hard time getting elected in most areas of Hawaii even if they have more on the ball and can offer the voters overall better representation. In reality,IMO there are some Democratic politicians who could/should be Republicans in Hawaii, but would not get re-elected as Republicans or would not have won their first election with a “R” after their name
    Charles Dijou is a man of his word, more than strong in personal ethics, quite brillant and very well educated although humble and a quick wit with a great side of humor. Charles Dijou is such a fresh, young and 1000% improvment over the man who just resigned his party’s important seat for personal gain and now attempt’s to bring (if possible) more liberalism to the Governor’s Office. And yes, he has the “D” behind his name which should bring about 30-35% of the vote, but he will have to split the “D” votes between at least one or two other candidates so on that front Charles might just be the favorite———-

  • kinikauai

    Touche’!
    I regret that I have but one district in which to vote, and will use mine against Mazie in September, but I have confidence Djou will prevail!

blog comments powered by Disqus