Morning Must Reads

–As Kate writes, political posturing pervades ahead of Thursday’s health care summit with Democrats and Republicans scrambling to score points. There’s plenty of that to come in the next 48 hours.

–To wit: Obama communications chief Dan Pfeiffer offers to post a Republican plan on the White House blog in a transparently backhanded dig at their proposals.

–And Minority Whip Eric Cantor rules out any chance of a deal by telling “Good Morning America” the Obama plan posted yesterday is a “non-starter.”

–Bipartisanship is not entirely dead. As Jay mentioned, the Senate managed to invoke cloture on Leader Reid’s jobs bill last night with five Republicans on board. Scott Brown, the 41st member many Republicans hoped would be blocking Democratic legislation, joined Snowe, Collins, Bond and Voinovich to break the filibuster.

Ben Smith reads into Brown’s decision: “He’s choosing a shot at re-election in Massachusetts — and a lot of power in the Senate — over conservative stardom…”

–Getting the bill through looks to me like a win for Reid when he desperately needs one, and something Democrats really want to get done before taking another vote on health care.

–In wake of cooperation on the jobs vote Nate Silver asks, “Is 56 the new 60?”

Marc Ambinder delves into the tricky business of reading polling on independents, explaining a key difference between identification and behavior. The short version: Most self-identified indys are every bit as partisan as party stalwarts at the ballot box.

David Brooks laments what he sees as the death-by-a-thousand-cuts of the excise tax, and gives this sunny take on the state of health reform legislation: “It has just become a fiscal time bomb. The revenue will never come.”

-And finally, when it rains it pours. Michael Steele gets some heat for spending freely at the RNC and Charlie Crist loses some staff.

What did I miss?

Related Topics: 2012 Election, Barack Obama, Congress, Democratic Party, Economy, Harry Reid, Health Care, Miscellany, Republican Party, Senate, White House
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / The White House via Getty Images

    Political Picures of the Week, May 18-25

    TIME’s photo editors bring you the best pictures of the past week from the Beltway and beyond.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    From left: AP; ABACAUSA

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

  • diecash1

    The Ambinder article nailed the myth of the independent voter, one of the most over-used phrases in politics. True independents are an extremely small group and though they are important in an election, they are not nearly as important as your base/leaning groups. Perhaps this myth can finally be put to rest.

  • pafro

    Here is my morning read.
    http://news.firedoglake.com/2010/02/22/senate-votes-on-motion-to-proceed-on-jobs-bill/

    …OK, this was hilarious. There was a long, long wait on this bill, with just a few Senators who were capable to vote left: Blanche Lincoln, Kit Bond and Mark Pryor. Obviously Bond was waiting forever to force Lincoln and Pryor into carrying the vote. Pryor wasn’t around initially, so it looked like Lincoln was the only one left to be the deciding 60th vote. She clearly didn’t want to vote for it and was trying to wait it out until Pryor got there. But she couldn’t any longer, and finally signaled an Aye vote. At that moment, Kit Bond immediately added an Aye vote, and Pryor showed up a couple minutes later to vote Aye. The final vote was 62-30. It looked like Lincoln shot a look to her colleagues after voting.

    The thought of the hateful and dim-witted little Wal-Mart harpie having to vote with Democrats when she really wanted to go a teabagging with Ben Nelson is absolutely hilarious, and restores my faith in humanity for a couple hours.
    I might have to go back and watch Obama’s Q&A with the Senate Dems again to watch Obama smack Lincoln down when she whines that she doesn’t want to do her job.

  • http://theblindspotsofgod.wordpress.com lawyermommy

    This is news???

    It is not unexpected or surprising. I know Obama expected these sorts of immediate– and continued– opposition. Oh well.

    LM

    http://theblindspotsofgod.wordpress.com/2010/02/15/stalking-criminality-the-law-and-women/

  • michaelfury

    You missed the Washington Times going off the reservation:

    http://michaelfury.wordpress.com/2010/02/22/meanwhile/

  • Matt

    So where was this brilliant strategy from the White House a year ago? They have painted the GOP into a corner by essentially saying they need to play ball right now, or else go home for good. Offering to post the GOP plan on the WH site is even better. They can’t because the GOP doesn’t have a plan!

    http://www.political-buzz.com/

  • FlownOver

    Really? You’re blogwhoring in a clip post? Have you no shame?

  • pintortwo

    What did I miss?
    .
    Unfortunately, a grim milestone was reached:
    .
    “U.S. death toll in Afghanistan hits 1,000″
    (link)

  • kevin

    This is hilarious. After complaining endlessly that the Democrats’ health care bills were “too long,” Boehner’s office is now complaining that the White House proposal is “too short.”
    .
    http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/02/boehner-obamas-health-care-proposal-is-too-short.php?ref=fpa

  • diecash1

    I guess he prefers something like the completely nondescript, one page GOP plan:
    Link to GOP “plan”

  • grape_crush

    In early versions of Goldilocks and the Three Bears, Goldilocks was an unpleasant old woman who was chased out the window, never to be seen again.

  • freeinpa

    What corner? Pfeiffer asks if the Repubs will post a plan that is posted. This passes for communications? It seems the Republicans have determined the following:

    1) Demos are offering the same pablum that has been rejected by the public.

    2) After weeks of going on about fiscal responsibility, the President hands in “his plan” that the CBO has too little details to anlayze. It is a solid bet that taxes skyrocket as does the deficit.

    3) The President’s “plan” contains none of what the Republicans told him were items needed in the HC bill when he lectured them in Baltimore.

    To believe that this will be bipartisan in nature is someone not based in reality. The President proved with his “plan” he barely reached to the end of his aisle let alone across it. The Repubs can point to the bipartisan jobs bills that Dingy Harry pulled the rug out from under them.

    It is quite easy for them to argue that the Demos cannot be trusted on forming a bipartisan bill and they can point to the proposed Dems bills that the public does not want. Repubs are ignoring school yard taunts as their opponents dig a deeper hole.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    I think the saddest part of this whole story is that no one even seems to notice. These young men should be front and center on everyone’s mind, but this whitehouse has done an excellent job of burying them on the last page. Healthcare is not the number one issue, and I am pinning alot of that on my party as well as the dems. Our troops should come first, along with national security, and jobs, jobs, jobs! Screw healthcare! Nothing is going to work in this country until we go back to work. Without money everything will suffer, it’s that simple.

  • freeinpa

    “too short”

    Yes too short on specifics like how much more in total taxes and how much more the deficit will rise. CBO has stated there is not enough info to calculate the damage.

  • diecash1

    “too short” — Like the one page Repub plan that offers no specifics, no numbers and no change from the status quo?

  • kevin

    Of course it can’t be scored — it merely recommends changes to the Senate and House bills. Having the full details requires a long bill. The kind Republicans can’t bring themselves to read.
    .
    But what happens when the CBO does score it, though? The CBO scored the Senate bill at $849 billion over ten years and indicated it would reduce the deficit by $127 billion over the same span. They showed it would reduce the deficit and improve things across the board, and the Republicans still attacked it as something that would explode the deficit.
    .
    Sorry, you can’t complain the current proposal hasn’t been scored by the CBO after thumbing your noses at the one that was scored by the CBO and shown to work well.

  • freeinpa

    “Of course it can’t be scored — it merely recommends changes to the Senate and House bills”

    So the President doesn’t have a plan either, so why complain about Republicans? I guess its easier than dealing with the fact that the public has weighed in on the plans and its the Demos running for cover not the Repubs

  • pafro

    Where is the bicameral Republican plan posted?

  • pafro

    Again 2/3, get your own job. Why are you always expecting a handout job?

  • stuartzechman
  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    Screw you Fro! What exactly is a handout job? I’ve spent my whole life breaking my back to earn what I have. Never wanted anyone to “give” me anything, and don’t want it now. Yours is the party of give, give, give and take, take, take from those whom you feel have too much!

  • diecash1

    You do seem to be whining at Obama to give us jobs, jobs, jobs a lot lately. This from the “I hate government and want it out of the way” contingent is more than a bit ironic.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    I hate a government that does everything in it’s power to stifle small business. That’s right get the @#ck out of the way, and let the free market fix this mess. High taxes and strict regulations that do nothing but push the little guy out of business, is what I’m talking about. When B.O’s best friend and most frequent visitor is the Big union boss man, it makes it kind of hard for the small working man to believe he is anything more than anti-small business. When I say give us jobs what I really mean is yeah, get the hell out of the way. Good old fashioned hard work is what built this country, and is the ONLY thing thing that can fix it.

  • diecash1

    Maybe you missed it but the “free market” caused most of our economic problems — unadulterated greed, refusal to perform oversight, the unregulated and deregulated financial industry, etc. Maybe you missed that. Combine that with the ruinous, job-killing policies of W and his Repub minions and you have our current state of the economy.
    ..
    How exactly is government standing in the way of small businesses? I recall a variety of tax cuts passed in the stimulus and more targeted tax cuts proposed in the jobs bill. Please detail precisely what government is doing to hold back small business.
    ..
    Give your anti-union talking points a rest too. How exactly are unions harming small business? Feel free to detail that too.
    ..
    I’m sure the evidentiary hurdles I’ve set will be more than you can or will meet because you would rather piss and moan about talking points than have a fact-based discussion of the issues.

  • kevin

    The biggest problem facing small businesses lately has been the withdrawal of government oversight, specifically in the realm of anti-trust.
    .
    There’s a reason the giant corporations have been merging like crazy and squeezing out small businesses, twothirds, and it’s not because the government has been too involved in the free market.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    Your oblivious die! You wouldn’t know a fact if you tripped over. Look up the true definition of free market. Although it’s a very simple easy concept to understand, it obviouslty goes right over your head. But then again I don’t believe that either, you know full well what the free market is, but since Obama is dead against it , you are too. Greed is greed, period. It can attach itself to any situation, and suck the life out of anything, including the free market, but that doesn’t mean it is a product of such. But you know that. I don’t nurse at Obama’s beanbag the way you do, therefore I am your enemy, ain’t that right die? Tell us what you really feel die! In your mind it’s B.O’s way or the highway. His bandwagon is becoming more empty by the day, but you will ride it straight to hell! That’s what defines you. I will not waste my time answering questions that anybody with half a brain already knows the answer to. Take that and run in any direction you want to with it. The union hates small business, the earth is round on that one.Now before you open your lips, no, I’m not bashing the workers. you know who I’m talking about, and you also know that it’s no secret the relationship B.O has with the union. If it’s proof you want just look….anywhere!

  • diecash1

    “I am your enemy, ain’t that right die?”
    ..
    No, I just find your commentary woefully devoid of logic, facts and reasoning.
    ..
    I’m not sure when this became a discussion about Obama and his bandwagon, but nice attempted deflection anyway. It’s entirely more useful if you could make a fact-based, cogent argument for what you believe. You have utterly failed here and the best you could do is mudsling and accuse me of being a monolithic Democrat. Pathetic.
    ..
    “The union hates small business, the earth is round on that one.”
    ..
    More utter nonsense and talking points. How exactly are unions holding back small business? Can you even come up with one fact-based example?
    ..
    I’m still waiting for you to tell us how the big, bad government is holding back small businesses too.
    ..
    “Tell us what you really feel die!”
    ..
    Your posts and argumentative skills represent an epic fail.

  • pintortwo

    High taxes and strict regulations that do nothing but push the little guy out of business
    .
    We’re currently talking about allowing Bush tax-cuts to expire for the top 2% of income earners in the US (candidate McCain proposed the largest cuts for the top earners). The restrictions/oversight include enforcing anti-trust regs (no “too big to fail”, stop collusion by industry leaders), Hedge Fund disclosure, commodity trading oversight (no Enron fiasco), not allowing derivatives to be AAA rated (they are based on mortgage liabilities after-all), monitoring the size and tactics of the derivative market…
    .
    The restrictions are intended to stop large corporations from using their influence to gain an unfair advantage over small businesses; from creating Unequal Opportunity– the antithesis of free market capitalism.

  • pintortwo

    PS. How did we get here from my initial comment?

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    In your eyes Die, but that is the least of my concern. I’ve spent my life in small busines and in a small business community. Sometimes as an employer, other times as an employee. More thn once my family business has lost a contract to the union, only to find out that their price was higher than ours, and seeing first hand that their end product was way below ours quality wise. We were simply told point blank, “you did not get the job because you are not union”. There’s my proof. I do not have to prove anything to you. You live and die by links, I have no use for them. Just propaganda. My proof is what I see with my own 2 eyes. Anybody who is self made can easily see the same things I see. We don’t don’t give a rat’s ass if you belive it or not.

  • diecash1

    You live (and die apparently) by “what I see with my own 2 eyes.” How completely anecdotal of you! Is the Earth flat where you live too? The whole planet must also be flat then, huh? You are fundamentally incapable of seeing the larger picture of, apparently, anything. Sad.
    ..
    BTW, if you are “self made” did you put yourself out of a job? Keep on blaming the government. Just be sure to let us know when you plan on flying a plane into a building in protest.

  • apr2563

    I love Canadians. They are usually a very modest people. I lived on the American side of the border for years. I always marveled at how polite and civil Canadians were. They have had to listen to their more extroverted neighbors to the south, who constantly claim the US is superior in everyway and chose to remain modest.
    Hooray for the Canadians. They have stood up and said, Americans, your health care system sucks, we are thrilled with our system, and you can only wish you could compete with ours.
    Now some contributors on this site will jump in with anecdotal comments about how Canadians pour across the border to get health care in the US. Not true but hey if it makes them feel better, so be it.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    A typical diecash sarcasm laden response. Yeah I live and die by that, along with millions of Americans who do the same. All of your crap laden stats mean nothing to us when we head to the ballot box, we feel the way we feel and will vote accordingly. We’re all feeling the same way. You’re on the outside, the fringe, as it were, but don’t take my word for it. Watch and learn. It must be disheartening for you to realize the overwhelming population of this country is devoid of intelligence, and knowing there’s nothing you can do about it. I guess you and a few of your fellow swamplanders have a hell of a mountain to climb between now and Nov. if you’ve any chance of getting your message across.

  • diecash1

    “we feel the way we feel and will vote accordingly.”
    ..
    That’s why W was such a perfect President for you. He followed his feelings, facts be damned! Look how well that turned out…….8 years of utterly failed policy of every kind.
    ..
    One definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again while expecting different results.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    Well you’re really gonna get a kick out of this one then Die! So many of my friends ( many whom I remember used to cuss ole George) are now saying, “damn, at least when Bush was president I had a job”. Have you ever heard anything so silly?hahaha! More than one of them though remember some pretty damn good times back then and also remember the wheels starting to come off about the same time that “your guys”took over the house and senate. Coincidence? Who knows? But that’s what they see, and don’t forget, these “idiots” vote. And there’s lots and lots of em, me included. Right or wrong these are the opinions that will decide things Come Nov. and again in 2012. Your message isn’t getting across. You need to take a different tack. You can deride and condescend and ridicule me all you want, but I represent an overwhelming majority that is growing daily. How do I know this? I SEE it everyday! Damn your getting tired of that one ain’t you?

  • diecash1

    “I represent an overwhelming majority that is growing daily.”
    ..
    In your own small mind…………..

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    So are Americans now pouring across the border for some o’ that there super duper Canadian healthcare? I’m being serious now. I mean….. I get this pain in my shoulder when I do this…….

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    An A+ to die, for consistency…..

  • apr2563

    2thirds: I can only tell you what I witnessed. The town I lived in is very rural. The only health insurance plans available are indemnity. Very expensive. So, yes, many went to Canada for health care. Also, because drugs are so much cheaper, lots of people went there for their medications. My nephew has a health savings account. He is the editor of a weekly local newspaper and his salary is very modest. He is diabetic. The health savings acct. does not begin to meet his needs. He goes to Canada. As I stated before, where are the mass of clinics along the border if Canadians are thronging here. Also, go on line and see how many sites offer Canadian pharmacuticals.
    Living in California now, I have witnessed a number of people going there for treatments and medication.
    Having worked in the health care insurance industry for years, I can tell you there is a big problem.
    Every statistic shows that our health care system is inferior in cost and outcomes. It is time to make us the best by reform.

  • apr2563

    2third: If it is the takeover by the dems of the congress that has caused all our problems what besides stem cell research did GW, hero of the 10 year decline of the middle class, veto to keep those radical leftists in check?

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    I can’t think of anything apr. That’s the major dissapointment I and the majority of my fellow conservatives had in him. He didn’t fight it hard enough. He did sound the alarm, several times, as far back as 2002 actually, but he didn’t follow through, and you have never heard me say differently. I blame Dodd, and Frank, and Paulson and Bernanke, and a host of others. They hovered and covered Fannie and Freddie(the democrats baby) Bush knew about it and didn’t stop it. But he damn sure didn’t create it. What little bit of power he had he didn’t use, and the takeover of the house and senate in ’07 pretty much left him a lame duck. Powerless to do much of anything from that time on. What else would you like me to say? Everybody says Obama shouldn’t be able to solve the countries problems in only a year.Well I say he and his gang have had 3 years and have only made things worse, not better.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    Fix it. Yes. Total transformation and government takeover? Absolutely not! I don’t know enough about Canada’s healthcare system to be able to honestly say whether it’s good or bad. But I do know there’s quite a few medical procedures that cannot be performed there, and certain very expensive but neccessary drugs that are simply not available there. We have the very best health care in the world bar none. Are there ways to make it better? Yes. Are there ways to increase it’s availability to more of our citizens? Certainly. I’ve never seen government fix anything that needed fixing. They’ve only made it worse. Turning something as vital and crucial as our healthcare over to the government? Bad idea. Perhaps you don’t see them coming in droves, but people do come here for medical procedures that can be found nowhere else on the planet.

  • apr2563

    Oh 2thirds I give up.
    http://www.kff.org/insurance/snapshot/chcm010307oth.cfm
    http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSN07651650
    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20228552
    What are the procedures that can’t be done in Canada? What are the formularies that can’t be accessed in Canada?
    2third America is not always the best at everything. It is ok to admit that and learn. Gretzky is probably the best hockey player ever. For a long time the Canadians and Russians dominated hockey. We had to admit they were better. We learned and improved.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    Well upon viewing these links and graphs I think I’ve figured out what the problem is here in the good ole USA. We’ve just got too damn much freedom. We don’t need more healthcare we just need a nanny to tell us when to eat, how to eat, what to eat and how much. I’m not totally doubting these sites(i am taking them with a grain of salt though) but I am however wondering how much freedom these people have to give up in order to have this healthcare, and how much of their hard earned money they have to give up also in the way of taxes and fees. Are they as happy and thrilled with their way of life as we are here in America. For some reason I don’t see that mass exodus of people headed for other countries in search of such fabulous healthcare. I think it all has to do with freedom, and how much of it we are willing to give up. But I think our current government is testing that theory, whether we agree to it or not.

  • apr2563

    2thirds: I knew no matter how many links I sent you, and there are dozens, you would not except the documentation. Living next to Canada, I went there often to dine out. I don’t recall anyone dictating what I could eat. In fact they had great French, German, and Italian restaurants.
    Evidently you don’t get the part where our current system is going to break us. Our premiums will continue to sky rocket and we have no way to contain the costs.
    I don’t see any European or Canadians fleeing to this country in order to have access to our health care system. And, yes, I think the people in those countries are happy with their way of life.
    Are people in third world countries happy with their lives. Mostly not. Where do they flee to. Not just America. Canada has a huge immigrant population.
    Why is it so hard for you to think we might have something to learn from other countries.
    All of my Grandparents came from Europe. I am glad they did. But, it is now 2010 and I think conditions there have improved since they left. I am proud of my country and how my ancestors countries have evolved. Europe and Canada are prosperous, advanced countries. We should welcome their parity.

  • http://2thirdsrocks.wordpress.com 2thirdsrocks

    Pssst! we’re already broke.

blog comments powered by Disqus