Will the Real Tea Party Please Stand Up?

A group of disgruntled Tennessee Tea Partiers held a guerilla press conference in an adjacent lobby to the National Tea Party Convention here in Nashville this afternoon. Their message was about as organized as the movement itself – proudly “grassroots,” meaning verging on chaos.

“We wanted the average citizen – not politicians or people who can afford this thing – to have a convention,” said Antonio Hinton, a Knoxville Tea Party activist not participating in the convention. “I wish we could afford it. We would love it if they would come and work with us.”

So was protesting the convention cost the point of their press conference? After all, few could afford the $549 fee to attend the three-day shebang organized by Judson and Sherry Phillips of the Nashville Tea Party – under a for-profit banner than irked many other Tea Partiers and politicians such as Reps. Michele Bachmann and Marsha Blackburn, both of whom withdrew as speakers. Um, not quite, after all, they’re pro-capitalism, too. “The Tea Party organization from across the state and met with Phillips and asked him to expand this venue so that the average citizen could attend and we were told that we didn’t have the same vision and values and that he wanted to keep it elite,” says Andrew Shreeve, an Eastern Tennessee activist. Shreeve said he had an e-mail to prove this allegation, but when asked he referred reporters to a Politico reporter whom was nowhere to be found.

So, it’s about elitism – top down versus bottom up? Kinda. “Yesterday, Judson Phillips said that when he’s done here he’ll unify the Tea Party movement in Tennessee and we’re here to tell him that it’s already unified. We were first state in nation to form a statewide tea party on January 23 and we represent 34 or the state’s 44 Tea Parties,” Hinton said.

So are they the real grassroots Tea Party movement? “We didn’t say that,” Schreeve said. “These are people just like us – they’re concerned about the country. We’re not here to criticize the people in that room or the sponsors or anybody like that – we’re just here to let the media know the Tea Party movement in Tennessee is unified.”

All of the speeches this week, and most activists when you ask them say they want to keep the movement grassroots – no formal leaders or organizing. “The tea party movement has no leader, and let me tell you something, neither did the American revolution,” Phil Valentino, a talk radio host who spoke just before Sarah Palin, said to raucous cheers from the crowd of 1,000+. If today proved anything, they’re getting their wish.

Subscribe to Jay Newton-Small on Facebook
Related Topics: national tea party conference, protest, tennessee, 2012 Election, Republican Party, Sarah Palin
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / The White House via Getty Images

    Political Picures of the Week, May 18-25

    TIME’s photo editors bring you the best pictures of the past week from the Beltway and beyond.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    From left: AP; ABACAUSA

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

  • Cliff

    “The tea party movement has no leader, and let me tell you something, neither did the American revolution,” Phil Valentino
    .
    Really.
    .
    Do you think you could ask him to clarify that, JNS?

  • formerlyjames

    Good point, Cliff. Phil needs to study up on his history. He’ll find that there were leaders of the American Revolution, and they need not worry about fight for the limelight. They were not ordinary folks or average citizens. They were aristocracy who were offended that they weren’t appreciated by the English aristocracy. They had the average citizens serve as their minions and carry the burden to break away. All these years and not much change, eh?

  • formerlyjames

    This grand party seems to be self-destructing in the first convention. Surprise, surprise. And with all those anxious followers waiting in the wings. Remember Ross Perot? These movements are just that. Movements, as in bm, because they are led by frauds and fakes.

  • http://www.ghostnote.com Cookie Puss

    $549? Freedom really isn’t free.

  • formerlyjames

    Cookie, I could afford that, if only it were so simple. But what a laugh that those folks there think nothing of that and the other costs of attendance, to protest giving an equal amount for tax support.

  • Cliff

    Well, you know, a million dollars really isn’t all that much after taxes.

  • charlieromeobravo

    It’s hard to organize a cohesive movement around people who’s only commonality seems to be a free form anxiety that Democrats are back in the majority in Washington.

  • pafro

    600 people show up for some convention and every single news organization makes it THE news for the week, even though actions with enourmous repercussions for our nation, like a Republican vowing to filibuster every single presidential nominee went nearly unreported.
    Meanwhile, while the BIG “grassroots” movement of 600 people are celebrating their coup over the corrupt media, over 3,000 people showed up today for an impromptu snowball fight.

  • 3xfire3

    All you libs can continue to make fun of the Tea Baggers, call them names, but remember they helped make something happen in Massachusetts that all of you thought was impossible.
    This movement is growing rapidly across the country and as you will find out in the elections of 2010, they will help elect enough Republicans and Conservatives to prevent Obama and the Liberal Democratic members of Congress from making the USA into a European Socialist State. You laugh and say they are not unified. Neither are the Democrats or Republicans.
    Make your jokes, call them names but they will leave you in the dust bin of history. The correct place for Elitist Liberal/Progressives like most of you. Americans believes in individual freedoms for its citizens and not your socialism.

  • sacredh

    So the Tea Party is unified (except when they’re fighting and criticizing each other). They represent the average person (except when they charge high admission fees and are elitist). They’re all alike (except when they argue who’s a top or a bottom). They have no leaders and everyone has a voice. Well folks, when everybody talks at once you can’t understand anything anyone says. Mission Accomplished. Carry on.

  • charlieromeobravo

    Complacency, an inordinately weak Democratic candidate, and a very moderate Republican candidate had nothing to do with the results in Mass, huh? I wouldn’t be overly proud of that win if I were a tea bagger because Brown isn’t the sort of candidate that generally fits their bill. Time will tell I suppose.

  • apr2563

    Their heroes in attendance and speaking
    Joe the Plumber who didn’t know the Constitution had amendments called the Bill of Rights
    Tom Tancredo Xenophobe
    Farah Birther
    Sarah Palin Quitter
    Such uplifting speakers. Paranoia reigns.

  • apr2563

    Jay, follow the money. Report the connections between the different Tea Party groups. Which groups do FOX, Army, Norquist and others support? How truly grassroots are they? Who are their corporate sponsors? Try to find out how much of Palin’s money for her speech actually leaves her PAC for Tea Party candidates.
    Don’t assume you know people’s motives. Just like no one figured out the Arkansas project and the sponsorship of Richard Mellon Scaife and the money behing the Swiftboaters until the damage had been done, it will be too bad if someone doesn’t do a thorough reporting on the Tea Party groups. It is the presses job.

  • apr2563

    Sarah Palin talks to the hand. Take a look at this. It will increase your respect for Sarah. Not!!
    http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/2/7/834684/-HandPromter-Hilarity:-Read-The-Words-on-Palins-Hand

  • kevin

    Yes, please, follow the money.

  • kevin

    So Cliff is really Michael Steele?

  • 3xfire3

    charlier,
    Sorry to burst your bubble but Brown is exactly the type of candidate that Tea Baggers will support. He has an independent open mind just like a majority of the Tea Baggers. Elitist Liberals try to paint these people as right wingers but the majority are not. They are simply average Americans who want the best for their country.
    Keep rationalizing why you lost in Massachusetts. Weak candidate, weak asleep party whatever you are smoking. If a Republican can win in this bluest of states they can win anywhere in the country. This fact is reality. Learn to live with it.

  • rhys6blue

    I have a couple of frustrations with the Jay’s and other media’s coverage of the teapary convention which I can’t help posting.

    First – Why is there not more basic information on who these 600 people attending are? I guess Jay’s too busy speculating on what this means polically to do any real reporting. For example I’d like some basic demographic information on whose attending. How many minorities and how many whites? What’s the age of attendees – What percentage is over 50 vs what percentage is under 30? Where are these people from? Are there representatives from all 50 states or is one region of the country more represented than others?

    Why no information like this? Is it too boring for Jay? Has she and the rest of the media forgotten how to actually do journalism? Or is it something else? What it is that they are all hiding?

    Mark

  • rhys6blue

    Oh and my second frustration. From what I can tell all these tea party people are for “smaller government” and against “deficits” and “higher taxes”. Yet its all big generalizations. Why is no one asking specifics of these people on how they want to accomplish these things? For example are the tea parttiers going to pressure their candidates to campaign on and support big cuts to medicare and medicaid or defense? Those are the only government programs which have the room to make up the difference but I can’t think this would be very popular with the tea partiers. Why is no one in the media asking this group the tough question on what they stand? Jay? You had a perfect opportunity at the convention to do this and you blew it?

    Since the media is not I can only believe that this is all just another big corporate media distraction. They’ve once again successfully displace the countries anger away from themselves and their reckless behavior (the banking crisis that lead to our current recession and onto empty political talk. And even appear to be on their way to helping elect more republicans, the party who supports these corporations without question (and by the way created the deficit mess we are in).

    Well done Jay! Your Time-Warner masters will be pleased!

    Mark

  • andersensix

    Hi, apr2563. Could you provide some links to the videos of your public speaking engagements? It’d be great to learn from you; I’m not that good at this point and can use some serious pointers.

    By the way, did you happen to watch the rest of Palin’s speech? It is pretty interesting, and she had many substantive things to say in the 60 minutes she spoke.

  • apr2563

    Scott Brown has been running away as fast as he can from Sarah Palin and the tea party. He couldn’t even remember talking to Palin after his election and has stated he really has nothing to do with the TPers. Of course, there is a video of him speaking to them.

  • apr2563

    ander I took Speech 101. I would not have passed the class had I put crib notes on my hand. I’ve given a lot of speeches. I was expected to know my topic without cheating. No videos however. Do you not feel it odd she needed crib notes for a so called interview?
    I have heard Sarah Palin speak on a number of occasions. What I hear is rambling non sequitors and generalizations, no serious policy suggestions. What I hear is demonizations and divisional rhetoric.

  • apr2563

    Sorry, see 6.1

  • apr2563

    Sacred, sorry. Posted in wrong thread.

  • 3xfire3

    apr and kevin,
    Boy you clowns really are worried about Sarah Palin.
    I think we need to come up with a name for this kind of fear. Doctors always give catchy names for newly discovered diseases. Let see?? How about the “ Palin Induced Irrational Behavior Syndrome” or PIIBS for short. I like that.
    Fear on little libies.

  • andersensix

    @apr2563: She spoke for an hour, and had like 5 words on her hand. I guess you could do better, I dunno.

    About demonizing, unfortunately, our President seems to have decided to make a career of that. Bankers are fat cats; our soldiers bombed innocent people and air-raided villages (which he said during the campaign); Pennsylvanians cling to their guns and Bibles; “Republicans are the party of no” during the SOTU, and the next day saying he’d read all of their proposals; Fox News isn’t a real news organization; insurance company executives; the Bush Administration’s domestic spying, before adopting it himself; Washington lobbyists, before he hired 30 of them as “exceptions” to his policy of not hiring lobbyists; said Boston cops “acted stupidly” before he got all the facts; now it seems they’ve even decided that Toyota should be chosen, perhaps to help GM; doctors (“you’ve got a bad sore throat, or your child has a bad sore throat or has repeated sore throats, the doctor may look at the reimbursement system and say to himself, you know what, I make a lot more money if I take this kid’s tonsils out.”); even the Supreme Court was bullied when they coiuld say nothing after they stood for the First Amendment.

  • 3xfire3

    Not for long.

blog comments powered by Disqus