President Obama Finds New Approach To Healthcare Stump

. . . Well not entirely new. But it was notable, in light of the apparent collapse of his major legislative initiative this week. From the top of his Town Hall today, at the Lorain County Community College in Elyria, Ohio. (In his opening statement, he used a variation of the word “fight” 20 times.)

Now, since this has been in the news a little bit this week — (laughter) — let me say a little something about health care. I had no illusions when I took this on that this was going to be hard.  Seven Presidents had tried it, seven Congresses had tried it — and all of them had failed.

And I had a whole bunch of political advisors telling me this may not be the smartest thing to do. “You’ve got a lot on your plate:  the biggest economic crisis since the Great Depression; two wars.  You may not get a lot of cooperation. you’re going to have a lot of pushback from the insurance companies and the drug companies.  It’s complicated.  Don’t do it.”

Now, let me tell you why I did it.  I knew that insurance premiums had more than doubled in the past decade.  I knew that out-of-pocket expenses had skyrocketed.  I knew that millions more people had lost their insurance, and I knew that because of that economic crisis that was only going to get worse.  When you lose 7 million jobs, like we lost over the last two years, what do you think happens to those folks’ health insurance?  What happens when their COBRA runs out?

I took this up because I wanted to ease the burdens on all the families and small businesses that can’t afford to pay outrageous rates.  And I wanted to protect mothers and fathers and children by being targeted by some of the worst practices of the insurance industry that I had heard time and time again as I traveled through this country.  (Applause.)

Now, let me dispel this notion that somehow we were focused on that, and so, as a consequence, not focused on the economy.  First of all, all I think about is how we’re going to create jobs in this area.  All I think about is how do we get banks lending again.  I’ve been doing that the entire year.  So have folks like Sherrod and Marcy and Betty.  But what I also know is, is that health care is part of the drag on our economy.  It’s part of the eroding security that middle-class families feel.

So here’s the good news: We’ve gotten pretty far down the road.  But I’ve got to admit, we had a little bit of a buzz saw this week.  (Laughter.)

Now, I also know that part of the reason is, is that this process was so long and so drawn out — this is just what happens in Congress.  I mean, it’s just an ugly process.  You’re running headlong into special interests, and armies of lobbyists, and partisan politics that’s aimed at exploiting fears instead of getting things done. And then you’ve got ads that are scaring the bejesus out of everybody. (Laughter.)  And the longer it take, the uglier it looks.

So I understand why people would say, boy, this is — I’m not so sure about this — even though they know that what they got isn’t working.  And I understand why, after the Massachusetts election, people in Washington were all in a tizzy, trying to figure out what this means for health reform, Republicans and Democrats; what does it mean for Obama?  Is he weakened?  Is he  – oh, how’s he going to survive this?  (Laughter.)  That’s what they do. (Laughter.)

But I want you — I want you to understand, this is not about me.  (Applause.)  This is not about me.  This is about you. This is not about me; this is about you.  I didn’t take this up to boost my poll numbers.  You know the way to boost your poll numbers is not do anything.  (Laughter.)  That’s how you do it.  You don’t offend anybody.  I’d have real high poll numbers.  All of Washington would be saying, “What a genius!”  (Laughter.)

I didn’t take this on to score political points.  I know there are some folks who think if Obama loses, we win.  But you know what?  I think that I win when you win. (Applause.)  That’s how I think about it.

So if I was trying to take the path of least resistance, I would have done something a lot easier.  But I’m trying to solve the problems that folks here in Ohio and across this country face every day.  And I’m not going to walk away just because it’s hard.  We are going to keep on working to get this done — with Democrats, I hope with Republicans — anybody who’s willing to step up.  Because I’m not going to watch more people get crushed by costs or denied care they need by insurance company bureaucrats.  I’m not going to have insurance companies click their heels and watch their stocks skyrocket because once again there’s no control on what they do.

So long as I have some breath in me, so long as I have the privilege of serving as your President, I will not stop fighting for you.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    Audacity of Dope: Tales of a Toking Teenage Obama

    We knew Barack Obama smoked weed in high school because he wrote about it in his books. What we didn’t know until Buzzfeed posted these choice nuggets (I’m so sorry) from David Maraniss’s new book on the President’s younger years, is the giggle-worthy details of his “Choom Gang” lifestyle, which are right out of a buddy stoner flick. Obama and his friends drove around the lush Hawaii countryside, hot-boxing their VW bus and re-upping with a long-haired pizza-tossing dealer named Ray, who Obama thanked in his yearbook “for all the good times.”

  • stuartzechman

    …I will not stop fighting for you.

    Please pardon the length, but this, fellow commenters, is an allegory:

    MINSTREL (singing): To fight, and–
    .
    ROBIN: Shut up! Um, oo, n-nothing, nothing really — I, uh, j-j-ust to um, just to p-pass through, good Sir knight.
    .
    ALL HEADS: I’m afraid not!
    .
    ROBIN: Ah. W-well, actually I am a Knight of the Round Table.
    .
    ALL HEADS: You’re a Knight of the Round Table?
    .
    ROBIN: I am.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: In that case I shall have to kill you.
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: Shall I?
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: Oh, I don’t think so.
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: Well, what do I think?
    .
    LEFT HEAD: I think kill him.
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: Well let’s be nice to him.
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: Oh shut up.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: Perhaps-
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: And you.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: Oh quick get the sword out I want to cut his head off!
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: Oh, cut your own head off!
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: Yes, do us all a favor!
    .
    LEFT HEAD: What?
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: Yapping on all the time.
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: You’re lucky. You’re not next to him.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: What do you mean?
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: You snore.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: Oh I don’t — anyway, you’ve got bad breath.
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: Well its only because you don’t brush my teeth.
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: Oh stop bitching and let’s go have tea.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: All right, all right, all right. We’ll kill him first and then have tea and biscuits.
    .
    MIDDLE HEAD: Yes.
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: Oh, but not biscuits.
    .
    LEFT HEAD: All right, all right, not biscuits, but lets kill him anyway.
    .
    ALL HEADS: Right!
    .
    LEFT HEAD: He buggered off.
    .
    RIGHT HEAD: So he has, he’s scarpered.
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): Brave Sir Robin ran away
    .
    ROBIN: No!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): Bravely ran away away
    .
    ROBIN: I didn’t!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): When danger reared its ugly head,He bravely turned his tail and fled
    .
    ROBIN: No!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): Yes Brave Sir Robin turned about
    .
    ROBIN: I didn’t!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): And gallantly he chickened out Bravely taking to his feet
    .
    ROBIN: I never did!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): He beat a very brave retreat
    .
    ROBIN: Oh, lie!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): Bravest of the brave Sir Robin
    .
    ROBIN: I never!
    .
    MINSTREL (singing): Packing it in and packing it up…And sneaking away and buggering off…And chickening out and pissing about…Yes, bravely he is throwing in the sponge…

    Thanks, commenters, for your indulgence; again, my apologies for the length.

  • freeinpa

    Dear Mr. President:

    When th ehorse is dead– dismount

  • anon76

    I don’t get it Stuart- you didn’t want the bill to pass. You were adamant about how the bill, as drafted in the senate, was completely unacceptable to you, and how you would not support politicians who voted to pass it. Now people around the president (though I haven’t seen anything from Obama himself) have indicated that he will be backing off the legislation, and you have done nothing but complain about that decision as well. What do you want? Obviously a better bill would be nice, but you’ve consistently gone on record as stating that the current bill is no better than the status quo. Why are you not happy to see the president putting his effort elsewhere (presuming that that is what he’s doing), where he might actually shepherd some legislation of which you approve? Do you just not like to see political waffling? I have a hard time believing that, considering what you wrote about the wisdom of Bush’s ‘don’t blink when running into a brick wall’ approach.

  • spob

    Talk is cheap.

  • kbanginmotown

    Are you fired up?!?

  • kbanginmotown

    What would have made this speech better is a roadmap, a to-do list, of what comes next. This speech comes to mind:

    Not only are we going to New Hampshire, Tom Harkin, we’re going to South Carolina and Oklahoma and Arizona and North Dakota and New Mexico, and we’re going to California and Texas and New York … And we’re going to South Dakota and Oregon and Washington and Michigan, and then we’re going to Washington, D.C., to take back the White House! Yeah!!!

    Time to take back the momentum!

  • stuartzechman

    If you’re incapable of recognizing at least some inconsistency between this (yesterday)


    Asked today if health care was on the back burner, Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said, “The president believes it is the exact right thing to do by giving this some time, by letting the dust settle, if you will, and looking for the best path forward.”
    .
    He said the administration wants to give Congress time to figure out their next move.
    .
    “The President thinks the speaker and the majority leader are doing the right thing in giving this some time and figuring out the best way forward,” he said.
    .
    He also noted that President Obama “has a very full plate” with financial reform, the economy, the wars and other matters.
    .
    “As the majority leader and speaker continue to look to the best way forward, the president has a very full plate,” Gibbs said. “There’s plenty of work for the president to do in the meantime.

    and this (today)


    And I had a whole bunch of political advisors telling me this may not be the smartest thing to do. “You’ve got a lot on your plate: the biggest economic crisis since the Great Depression; two wars. You may not get a lot of cooperation. you’re going to have a lot of pushback from the insurance companies and the drug companies. It’s complicated. Don’t do it.
    .
    let me dispel this notion that somehow we were focused on that, and so, as a consequence, not focused on the economy.
    .
    I’m trying to solve the problems that folks here in Ohio and across this country face every day. And I’m not going to walk away just because it’s hard. We are going to keep on working to get this done…
    .
    I will not stop fighting for you.

    , then you probably won’t find much humor in that little sketch, I’m sorry.
    .
    As far as what I want, I want a way forward on health reform that isn’t a joke at the public’s expense, that’s what I want. I want the leadership that I was promised, that we were all promised. I don’t accept that it’s the corrupt way or the highway, and neither do most Americans, for that matter.
    .
    Screw what I want, though. The country really, really needs reform, and the Senate bill isn’t it. Passing the Senate bill as is would be the worst thing for real reform, and if the Administration wants to pretend that it’s the Senate way or the highway, and that this is it, that it can’t recommend (not introduce, different thing) its own triage-type, immediate reform, emergency pre-bill to the Congress, and demand its passage, then they deserve all of the cynicism that Obama said was our, the public’s, responsibility to suspend.
    .
    So we deserve better, all of us, and so I hope that these people Obama, Democrats do whatever the f*ck it takes to get a simple, easy-to-understand, effective set of minimum absolute requirement reforms out of the worthless Congress right now, and not to stop yelling about it until it’s done or half the Senate are still filibustering or committing hara-kiri on the floor.

  • stuartzechman

    Forgive me, since this is posted elsewhere, but this is what I want:
    .
    link to Balls Beer
    .

  • pafro

    I hope the Dems on the Hill take this weekend to go on a serious bender and reflect on the situation. And come back understanding that they can’t abandon ship and they also can’t shift to a plan that is going to waste another 6 months.

    They need to coalesce around a plan to use the Senate Bill as a start and get a reconciliation fix going.

    This needs to happen fast, like in a matter of weeks, so they can get on to the task of making Republicans vote to defend Wall Street banks over and over again for the next 9 months.

  • stuartzechman

    You know, if the Senate bill contained a Medicare buy-in, it might be worth passing…maybe.
    .
    It’s possible that people could be talked into supporting that…maybe.
    .
    So there is actually a way forward with the current legislation.
    .
    Obama would have to fight for it, though. He’d have to fight his own New Democrat Senate Coalition, because those are the Democrats who would hold it up. He’s have to publicly take this little gang on in order for it to work.

  • apr2563

    stuart, I sent the Balls Beer video to family members earlier. It sums up what I’d like to see. Very funny.
    Also, posted this earlier on Swamp and KOS. It is funny inspirational for all libs:

  • stuartzechman

    Something is beginning to make sense to me…
    .
    …who were the Democrats who voted against the Dorgan amendment, again?

  • allthingsinaname

    Health Care isn’t going to happen. The Dems are goning to take a beating period..
    .

    I just do not see Obama leading on this, he hasn’t and he wont which confuses the hell out of me. It is his agenda, It is what he promised us was the most important thing, but he never to the lead, he never fought for it, and now he askin g why is everyone in a tizzy..
    .
    He is disconnected, sorry I ever voted for him, I will not again.

  • jcapan

    God, I’d give at least one testicle for a Dean White House! Jim Webb as veep. I’d give up the whole plumbing unit for someone to pistolwhip Rahm’s arse onto the lawn. Saturday afternoon, the ale is flowing : )

  • jcapan

    Agree with just about every word here. If I had to vote again, I’d go Kucinich in the primary and Clinton in the general. However, “not again”? Even against Romnoid or Palin? Sitting home or voting green, I can’t condemn you but don’t think I can get there. Of course, my own opinion is that the incumbent should always be primaried. Better yet, a single 6 year term.

  • jcapan

    SZ, I’d not watched your link before discussing my anatomical charity at 5.2. Just saw it @ Sully’s–brilliant encapsulation of our politics. AS said at another pt: “we have a Congress of total pussies on the left and maniacs on the right and little in the middle”

  • jcapan
  • tjoyce994

    “You know, if the Senate bill contained a Medicare buy-in, it might be worth passing…maybe.”
    -
    Agreed. It would provide an answer for people who can’t purchase a policy because they are uninsurable. Medicare is a known quantity, and is accepted by all doctors. In addition to the premiums, there would be an administrative charge. But it should be minimal. The coverage should also be cheaper than what the insurance companies can offer, because profit isn’t an issue
    -
    If they do a Medicare buy-in, get rid of the pre-existing condition, the ablility to rescind policies when policyholders become ill and lifetime caps, the insurance companies will have a problem. Their lobbying tactics will have lost millions of healthy patients, and there is a real alternative for the middle class.
    -
    I disagree with those who believe such a scenairo puts the insurance companies at a disadvantage. 30 years ago, states had an auto risk pools of bad drivers. These drivers were divided up among all admitted carriers in the individual states. Their poor driving records affected everyone’s rates. Enter non-admitted insurance companies, who created products and payment structures for those drivers. I don’t believe states have assigned risk pools anymore. There isn’t a need for them. There is a segment of the insurance market designed specifically to serve poor drivers.
    -
    I don’t understand why health insurance wouldn’t work the same way.

  • tjoyce994

    Maybe we should cut him some slack on “taking the lead.” My understanding was that Rahm was working behind the scenes. That is taking the lead. Whether Rahm was the best man for the job is open to question.
    -
    There was a certain logic to him not repeating the Clinton’s mistake and giving the appearance of ramming this down congresses’ throat. And if Obama was obviously engaged in the negotiations would provide the media with a daily tally of Obama wins and losses. In hindsight, that isn’t any worse than what we have now. But who knew? The point is his strategy was grounded in logic.
    -
    I think his biggest mistake was that he blew too much time trying to get Republicans on board and there wasn’t enough spin on the better aspects of the bill. Early on the Republicans made it clear that they were obstructionist, but his adminstration allowed them to control the process and the message. Even today, I am amazed at the number of people who have opinions but have no idea what’s in the bill.

  • kbanginmotown

    tjoyce: I’m with you on your assessment. Whenever a president shows leadership by saying he’d like to see “X” (X=public option or expanded coverage or mandates) in a piece of legislation, the legislators get cranky and the process bogs down.
    .
    By being vague on the specifics, and supporting the effort behind the scenes, Obama gave the congress plenty of rope. All Reid could manage to do was loop it around…

  • kbanginmotown

    Sobering article. Thanks JC.
    .
    P.S.: How’s the little one doing?

  • kbanginmotown

    Hear, hear! Dean/Webb would be kickin’ @ss and takin’ names.
    .
    I’m curious about the anger directed at Rahm, tho’.
    .
    Frankly, given his salty rep, I’d have thought that various Dem congresscritters would have declared “I can’t work this this man.” But, that hasn’t happened.
    .
    Are his fingerprints on the backroom deals?

  • Paul-no not that one

    ‘What we’ll get instead is rhetoric. It’s cheap, so we can expect a lot of it.”
    .
    Yep.

  • gysgt213

    Young Turks used this video clip to describe what the voters have been saying to the democrats in the last 6 months.
    .

  • bacotawordpress

    This is what we get for electing an inexperienced politician — a president who spends his first year trying to work out how to deal with Congress.

    So what? He’s got at least three more years (hopefully seven). I like this guy.

    A lot of us lost faith in Bill Clinton because he abandoned health care reform when he found out how hard it was. I thought to myself “what the hell did this guy want to be president for, then? Just to get laid?” (I think we all know the answer to that now.)

    So Obama has announced that he’s not giving up. Yay for him! This is the president we need!

    Why didn’t it get passed last year, anyway? Because he tried to let the legislature do their jobs and they couldn’t? Because he wasted so much time trying to reach out to the opposition who apparently want no part of him no matter what? Because his political opponents attacked the plan with fictionalized accounts of “death panels” and “socialized medicine”.

    Personally, I was not an early Obama supporter. I eventually voted for him, though. I’m still waiting for him to hit that home run, but it’s only the third inning and I like the way he’s swinging the bat.

  • bacotawordpress

    How soon we forget.

    Please think back to January 2009 when the economy was in free fall and we were afraid of entering the next great depression. How many of you honestly expected that we’d be back to economic health in 12 months? For those of you that do, how many of you still believe in the tooth fairy?

  • newfreedomblog

    Here you go President Obama, a step by step to get health care reform passed.
    .
    It is all about common sense, something that perhaps your “Harvard” educated brain is not able to grasp.
    .
    http://www.newfreedomblog.com

  • Paul-no not that one

    Rusty, using scare quotes around Harvard while suggesting BHO is not smart sort of undercuts whatever point you are trying to make.

  • Ike Jakson

    Read your own Swampland Blog about Massachusetts:

    http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2010/01/23/anatomy-of-anger/

  • http://ikejakson.wordpress.com/2010/01/23/chatterboxes-of-comedy/ Chatterboxes of Comedy « Ike Jakson’s Blog

    [...]  http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2010/01/22/president-obama-finds-new-approach-to-healthcare-stump/ [...]

  • stuartzechman

    back to economic health in 12 months
    .
    The Obama Administration predicted that we’d be under 8% unemployment in 12 months, actually.

  • jcapan

    K-Bang, to me it’s a matter of symbolism. Obviously, any respons. lies with Obama (buck stopping). Same holds true w/Bernanke, Summers etc. The moment Obama cuts some of these blokes loose is the moment I’ll buy his suddenly populist rhetoric.
    .
    And BTW, la nina is awesome. Thanks for asking. Nothing like a child to add to the evasive meaning of life.

  • http://thecrossedpond.com/2010/01/25/obamas-stalking-horses/ The Crossed Pond » Obama’s Stalking Horses

    [...] in that same vein, back to health care: We are going to keep on working to get this done — with Democrats, I hope with Republicans [...]

  • http://www.grahamelesh.com/2010/01/25/44/ Can The Sane Man Save The Crazy People?

    [...] he quotes the President’s speech in Ohio. He is fighting: … So if I was trying to take the path of least resistance, I would have done something a lot [...]

  • http://andrewcarr.org/?p=1701 Chasing the Norm » Blog Archive » This is the change I’ve been waiting for

    [...] I supported Obama during 2007, 2008 for the skills he represented, far more than the position he held. I was always prepared to be disappointed, he is not my national leader, he was the most conservative of candidates, and yet his strategy of clinging close to the congressional leadership had led him closer to Health Care Reform than any man before him, Republican & Democrat. While believing every man deserves his due support, over the last few months, my enthusiasm has wained, along with his seeming political skill. Yet here, post-Massachusetts, in the depths of despair I find this, the very statement I have been wishing for him to make for the last few months: Obama in Ohio 22 January 2010 [...]

  • http://obama.loraincounty.com/president-obama-finds-new-approach-to-healthcare-stump President Obama Finds New Approach To Healthcare Stump

    [...] Well not entirely new. But it was notable, in light of the apparent collapse of his major legislative initiative this week. From the top of his Town Hall today, at the Lorain County Community College in Elyria, Ohio. (In his opening statement, he used a variation of the word “fight” 20 times.) Read On The Swampland [...]

  • http://grahamelesh.com/2010/01/25/44/ Can The Sane Man Save The Crazy People? « GrahameLesh.com

    [...] he quotes the President’s speech in Ohio. He is fighting: … So if I was trying to take the path of least resistance, I would have done something a lot [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus