767 Pages of Single Payer

Heeeeeeeere we go. Right now in the Senate chamber, GOP delay tactics on the Democratic health care reform bill are in full swing. The Senate clerk is reading out aloud the text of an amendment by Sen. Bernie Sanders that would insert a single-payer system into the health care bill. The process of verbally entering amendments into the official record is typically waived, but a senator – in this case Republican Sen. Tom Coburn – can force it to happen. The Sanders amendment is particularly long at 767 pages. I think it might actually be the longest amendment offered so far, making it a prime target for Republicans looking for a way to slow down Democratic process on the health care bill.

That Coburn is using the rules of the Senate against the Democrats should come as no surprise. As Mark Leibovich reported in the New York Times in October:

As the health care overhaul heads to the Senate floor, Mr. Coburn is preparing for what he considers a career pinnacle of havoc. Enacting the proposal, he says, would be catastrophic, and so if precedent holds, he will try to hinder it with every annoying tool in his arsenal: filing amendments (he has done that 508 times since joining the Senate, second only to John McCain’s 542 in that period), undertaking filibusters and objecting strenuously.

“When it comes to obstructing bills, he is part of a very tiny pantheon in the history of the Senate,” said Ross Baker, a Senate historian at Rutgers University.

To Mr. Coburn, charges of obstructionism are a mark of honor he will wear as proudly as ever in the coming weeks.

“My mission is to frame this health care debate in terms of the fiscal ruin of this country,” said the 61-year-old Mr. Coburn, who recently railed on the Senate floor that the federal debt was “waterboarding” his five grandchildren. “I have instructed my staff to clear my schedule for every minute that bill is on the floor.”

The Sanders single payer provision is a “message amendment” that has no chance of passing, but it’s what some left-wingers consider ideal health care reform, which also makes it an ideal target for GOP obstructionism. The clerk started reading the amendment at 12 p.m. EST and is now on page 40. Guesses on when the Senate might get back to regular business?

Related Topics: bernie sanders, single payer, tom coburn, Congress, Health Care, Senate, Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Audacity of Dope: Tales of a Toking Teenage Obama

    We knew Barack Obama smoked weed in high school because he wrote about it in his books. What we didn’t know until Buzzfeed posted these choice nuggets (I’m so sorry) from David Maraniss’s new book on the President’s younger years, is the giggle-worthy details of his “Choom Gang” lifestyle, which are right out of a buddy stoner flick. Obama and his friends drove around the lush Hawaii countryside, hot-boxing their VW bus and re-upping with a long-haired pizza-tossing dealer named Ray, who Obama thanked in his yearbook “for all the good times.”

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    Obama Stumbles? Why the President’s Right to Talk About Bain

    The meme of the day in journo-world is that President Obama has stumbled at the outset of the general election campaign. The evidence for this? Well, uh, there isn’t very much, really–except that a few Democrats have criticized his campaign’s attacks on Mitt Romney’s record at Bain Capital and that Obama’s fundraising is merely humongous, instead of obscenely humongous. The two phenomena are linked, of course: Obama isn’t getting the usual haul from Wall Street because he has outrageously–outrageously!–tried to regulate the bankers who did so much to crash the economy in 2008. The handful of Democrats squawking are people who either (a) get money from private equity firms or (b) have retired and joined Mondo Casino. But there is another side to this story:

  • http://www.ghostnote.com Cookie Puss

    The Senate is making a strong case for a unicameral legislature.

  • palininatowel

    A simple adjustment needs to be made to this rule:

    The senator wanting it read into the record must be the person to read it into the record.

    My guess is that a jackass like Coburn wouldn’t be interested. He’s far too important for that.

  • rustyreturns

    I have been listening to this as well Kate. I have also read it as well. It is the single payer, public option. It is an amendment that completely destroy our health care system as we know it.
    .
    With over 61% of Americans not in favor of the overall bill to reform Health Care, I see that as a clear majority who are not in favor of Obama Care, Pelosi Care or Reid Care.
    .
    Pick a name, it is all bad for America!

  • freeinpa

    Stop th epresses! Call out the NAtional Guard. Imagine the temerity of a Senator to have actually have the 767 page amendment read let alone understood before voting on it. String up the Bas**rds

  • pintortwo

    “My mission is to frame this health care debate in terms of the fiscal ruin of this country, regardless of what the truth may be.
    .
    There, fixed that for you Tom.

  • constantweader

    Great idea! Absent that, the Senator who is SO INTERESTED in hearing every word of a bill that he needs it read aloud should at least be forced to sit & listen to the reading.

    The Constant Weader at http://www.RealityChex.com

  • http://thepage.time.com/2009/12/16/dr-no-for-single-payer/ Dr. No for Single-Payer – The Page by Mark Halperin – TIME.com

    [...] really, but he's getting all 767 pages of Sanders' amendment read aloud Wednesday to stall debate. tiiQuigoWriteAd(755778, 1290697, 600, 240, [...]

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    part of a very tiny pantheon in the history of the Senate,

    I had to look twice. I thought it said ‘pathogen’.

  • freeinpa

    Did you think it was a pathogen of the Senate when the Demos on the Judicial committee used rules of the Senate to stall every Bush nomination to the Federal Bench?

    Or are you selectively belligerent again?

  • 53_3

    It might be of interest that in an era when the nation was evenly split on Civil Rights, the filibuster lasted 171 days.
    .
    In an age where 72% of Americans want a public option, I wonder how long a Republican filibuster will last.
    .
    I say put the train on the tracks and run it down the rails…

  • 53_3

    I thought it was a great move.

  • apr2563

    Free: Do you really believe Coburn is sitting there listening to the reading? Do you really believe the amendment had any chance of passing? Do you really believe this reading is nothing but obstructionism on the Republicans part?

  • 53_3

    I’m guessing at 40 pages an hour, it’s going to be at least 20 hours, probably more like 24.
    .
    It’s ok though. The current system will undergo collapse long before whatever passes anyway, if it has a 2013 implementation date…

  • apr2563

    Free: Dems delayed every judicial appoint to the bench by Bush? Please list all those nominations and how they were ALL delayed. EVERYONE?

  • deconstructiva

    Kate, how fast is the reader going? I wish they’d use an auctioneer. It would follow the letter of the law and they’d be done in an hour. Or they could use Pontius Pilate or his friend Biggus Dickus from Monty Python’s “Life of Brian”. (caveat – of course we’re not supposed to make fun of speech impairments, but the film is still freakin’ funny …and I used to have a terrible stuttering problem as a kid, so I’m granted an exemption)

  • cfukara

    Q: ” ..obstructionist political party A looks for a way to slow down legislative process on the bill. .. using the house rules against the ruling party B should come as no surprise. ”

    A: Something that would happen in a banana republic.

  • arkansasconstituent

    Frankly, I APPLAUD Senator Coburn in his efforts!
    This whole healthcare Bill needs to be scrapped and the whole process began anew! We need elect more like him and of his common sense reasoning!

    These “looney Democratic Marxist Leftist” need to be replaced in Congress and those with “fiscal responsibility” replace them and represent the true voter constituent, who are 60%+ fully against this Socialist program! We have a group of “looney nut-cases” who are out of touch with their voting constituents – who are not “illegal and criminals in this country and who are sick and tired of supporting such people by government programs and healthcare and who have violated our laws in being here and having their “Anchor Babies” at the middle income class taxpayer’s expense – who is sick and tired of doing so – and who want to see some fiscal responsibility returned to Congress and the Administration!

  • pdzxc

    So Coburn needs a single payer amendment read to decide if he will vote on it, as if there were a chance in hell he world? Give me a break.

  • http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2009/12/16/re-767-pages/ Re: 767 Pages… – Swampland – TIME.com

    [...] Re: 767 Pages… Posted by Karen Tumulty Wednesday, December 16, 2009 at 2:30 pm Submit a Comment • Trackback (0) • Related Topics: congress, health care, senate, stupid Senate tricks, tom coburn They really don't pay the clerks of the Senate nearly enough to make them do this. [...]

  • apr2563

    Here we go with the incoherent, ignorant name calling.
    You do realize that Coburn was part of the Republican majority who allowed unfunded wars, unfunded perscription benefit, continued and increased pork barrel spending, allowed the crash of our economy.
    I could use some name calling about the Repulcians:
    Facists
    Oligarchs
    Emperists
    Obstructionist
    Theocrats
    Know Nothings
    Supremists
    Xenophobes
    Palinites
    I never use these stereotypes, but have to admit, it makes me feel better.
    Anyone else have an adjective for the Republilcans?

  • rustyreturns

    We can only hope that enough of us turn out to vote the bums out of office in 2010, ark.
    .
    Keep up the good work! Keep sounding the alarm!

  • http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2009/12/16/and-theyre-back/ And…..They’re Back – Swampland – TIME.com

    [...] • Related Topics: bernie sanders, single payer, tom coburn When Republican Sen. Tom Coburn forced the the reading of a 767-page single-payer amendment from Bernie Sanders – a task estimated to take [...]

  • pintortwo

    Careful what you wish for, Ark. Fiscal conservatives would have never started wars of choice, never lowered taxes once a war started and never financed a war with foreign money. They might even raise taxes to pay for it- at least while the war rages. They would look at our military budget and might conclude that defense spending can be significantly cut. They would argue that the government has no business legislating morality- ya know: gay marriage, abortion… They would suggest that lower taxes are the reward of prudent government- not that less taxes cures the economy. In short, the current Republicans are not a party of “fiscal responsibility”. They’re more of a Social Conservative, Pro- corporate, Religious Fundamentalism hybrid…

  • pintortwo

    Also, you put looney Democratic Marxist Leftist in quotes. Who are you quoting?

  • spob

    Kate refers to GOP obstructionism. I searched the phrase “Democratic obstructionism” in Time.com’s archives. Zero mentions.

  • kbanginmotown

    Look up “up or down vote” in the TIME archives to see how many times it was uttered by a Republican versus a Democrat.
    .
    Reid’s spinelessness has afflicted his vocal cords.

  • apr2563

    spob: There is no Santa. I looked it up.

  • freeinpa

    Hmm if it doesn’t have a chance of passing why are the brainthrusts of the left wasting the time of the Senate by preparing such a bill?

    I would guess Coburn would never vote for a single payer. I also believe that most of the ones who might vote for one had no idea what was in it either. For a leadership and administration that promised so much transparency, this entire bill was written behind closed doors under the cloak of darkness.

    The left keeps ranting that (pick your number) want health care reform or a public option. Problem is when they discover what that might include they quickly change their mind. So the response is try and ram it through then scream they are obstructing us. This is malpractice not legislation

    Grow up!

  • freeinpa

    apr2563:

    They never came out of the judicial committee as Leaky Leahy blocked them. And you can look up the list if bored.

  • deconstructiva

    …if you can’t find “Democratic obstructionism” then it must not exist. If you disagree, prove it with examples …oh wait, you can’t find any.

  • apr2563

    Free: The only thing that bores me as your typical name calling response. Tell me, did Leahy block ALL of the nominees. What bores me is your hyperbole and LIES.

  • xarchenko

    I send mail (my paper) *appeal to your people*, for you, so you know.
    History of Ukraine contains all roads which pass through its state is the state of the Black and Caspian Sea states of Europe and the Russian Federation and Belarus and the Baltic States. In this environment, Ukraine was and will be, but you should know about the many communities of national minorities in Ukraine, which should assist the indigenous population to win the victory over Russian chauvinism and cynicism.
    Many professors from the science of physics know what the torsion fields, which affect the human brain, and at different frequencies program commands to perform the person will be in it in the brain. This experiment was prepared and holding extensive amount in Ukraine during the Orange Revolution, the square of the capital and major cities of Ukraine. During the Orange Revolution, where I took part in rallies, I was surprised by the behavior of a video camera operator, who runs a video camera on the faces of people actively speakers for Yushchenko and Ukraine’s future. Why people who participated in the election of President Yushchenko and the future of Ukraine, located in a large garden and joy (remember the first speech by President of Czechia) after the election. I am a former journalist was surprised not competent operator, because the video camera does not include dae signal on a video shoot. To me, at my invitation arriving Jaroslav Ksonzhek, Consul of Poland, where our conversation and confirmed abuse of the Moscow government. It turns out that Moscow is continuing research to control and possess the human brain. It turns out that Putin is in this regard will have the state not only Europe and America but to solve their business programs. Carrying gas pipe through the Baltic States. I want to thank the many Jew for their help when I conducted an investigation, rabbi warned their communities do not come to the square, then be bad for health and psychological disorder. In order to save not only the state president, people, foreign embassies are located in Ukraine, I send the mail letters and telegrams to the President, but in the presidential administration or the children sit or bureaucrats. I understand that Ukraine is very far from your country and therefore should be realistic and simple plan for withdrawal from such situations. You may be surprised by my feeling high torsion fields “But I believe in God and constantly attend Protestant church Evangelicals, Bible study, psychology, folklore, cultural studies, analytics, folk music and songs. Second great experience to travel by military enterprises of when I worked in a factory where assembly consisted of turbines in Krivoy Rog. So I like the saying: The wisdom of man checks only way direction and goals. To convey to the President of Ukraine is a question I have for the first time in its life wrote a letter to the USА Embassy Vil’yamu Taylor, knowing that letters to foreign embassies can check (I wrote the text of the letter to enter a deadlock that people check messages on Post Office in Kiev ) counting on professional psychologists embassy. Maybe my innocence and romanticism great kindness not give me a quiet life, so I thought that everything will be like in the movies. For example, Come from Kiev or the USА embassy good man, and on home phone inviting meeting in Dnipropetrovsk administration and great pity it is all fairy tale, which shows in the film. How can I feel a major role analysis on various issues when I sent a fax wife Ekaterina Yushchenko president and then president’s wife appealed to the USА Ambassador (because her aides have not read Catherine fax). So no one sees me as an expert, thinking that I am working with the USА Embassy, President of Ukraine in 2006, invited himself to the USА Ambassador and the Ambassador of Poland. Unfortunately there is not securing for copyrights. Very please note the danger, that Russia may give your country, and protect my copyright on intellectual property, to realize their potential to the benefit of our good relations. Now, please imagine if Russia can use the torsion field during military operations as well as in public (panic, revolution, rebellion and what you want) to be a civil war and chaos in the elections and other companies. If Russia will send a torsion field in the brain of miners from the city of Donetsk, what then will be in Kiev?. Why do I appeal to you Your Majesty, for help! Because you are a patriot of the United States Americas and the state can imagine that a person before the rally (The action darling) can drink tea or coffee active liquid, the influence of torsion fields resulting in a mutation of the body!. This is a question that I have studied, we save lives and you and the President of the United States Americas and many people! And the main thing that Ms. Catherine Chumachenko was born in the United States and was the square with the children. With great respect to you and hope for your tolerance and kindness, Your Majesty. And for me there will be enormous gladness when any man will arrive to me in guests that could make sure in veracity of my moral principles.

    Valeriy Kharchenko, son of Mary Chumachenko father Vladimir Kharchenko. Kirovograd region, Dolinsky district, village Vasylivka.

    city DNIPROPETROVSK 49029
    Street. Заміська 39-1
    phone mobile 380985052947
    home 38056 7166470

    UKRAINE xarchenko2009@meta.ua

  • http://politicsorpoppycock.com/2009/12/17/767-pages-of-single%c2%a0payer/ 767 Pages of Single Payer « Politics or Poppycock

    [...] 32 Comments • Trackback (3) • Related Topics: congress, health care, senate, bernie sanders, single payer, tom coburn [...]

  • ghwright3

    Wow, there are people upset that Congress is actually reading the legislation… That’s just sad.

  • http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2009/12/18/the-week-in-review-and-whats-next-for-health-reform/ The Week In Review and What’s Next for Health Reform – Swampland – TIME.com

    [...] Stayed tuned to C-SPAN or C-SPAN 2 to watch it all unfold – highlights may include additional dramatic readings as part of the GOP effort to obstruct the process. Howard Dean and David Axelrod are scheduled to [...]

  • citizennyc

    This is not “Health Care Reform”, Health Care, or any other form of Health Care. It is MANDATORY HEALTH INSURANCE — a new TAX that is paid to…Insurance Companies. I suggest you review the lobbying documentation at http://www.opensecrets.org and really consider WHO LOBBIED FOR and Who is really going to benefit from this MANDATORY HEALTH TAX. Once again, the politicians create double speak to dupe Citizens of the true consequences of this bill. Health Care and Mandatory Health Insurance are NOT the same thing. This bill only creates a public and private bureaucracy that wedges itself between Doctors and their patients. CitizenNYC, HTTP://www.newbroomparty.org

  • http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2010/03/05/the-gop-campaign-to-scare-house-dems/ Reconciliation, Health Reform, House Democrats and Republican Scare Tactics – Swampland – TIME.com

    [...] Republicans would employ? Remember Republican Sen. Tom Coburn forcing the Senate clerk to read all 767 pages of a single payer [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus