In the Arena

A Jobs Speech with Elbows

The President gave a terrific economic speech today, proposing some new jobs-creating initiatives, one of which–a 0% capital gains tax rate for small businesses–seems a Republican dream, but was hilariously opposed on deficit cutting grounds by Senator Mitch McConnell…whose votes on a range of budget items during the Bush presidency created the bulk of the current deficit.

Indeed, my favorite part of the speech came when the President, in an uncharacteristic display of spit, lambasted the Republicans for their sudden interest in budget-balance:

Despite what some have claimed, the cost of the Recovery Act is only a very small part of our current budget imbalance.  In reality, the deficit had been building dramatically over the previous eight years.  We have a structural gap between the money going out and the money coming in.

Folks passed tax cuts and expansive entitlement programs without paying for any of it — even as health care costs kept rising, year after year.  As a result, the deficit had reached $1.3 trillion when we walked into the White House.  And I’d note:  These budget-busting tax cuts and spending programs were approved by many of the same people who are now waxing political about fiscal responsibility, while opposing our efforts to reduce deficits by getting health care costs under control.  It’s a sight to see…

In the end, the economic crisis of the past year was not just the result of weaknesses in our economy.  It was also the result of weaknesses in our political system, because for decades, too many in Washington put off the hard decisions.  For decades, we’ve watched as efforts to solve tough problems have fallen prey to the bitterness of partisanship, to prosaic concerns of politics, to ever-quickening news cycles, to endless campaigns focused on scoring points instead of meeting our common challenges.

We’ve seen the consequences of this failure of responsibility.  The American people have paid a heavy price.  And the question we’ll have to answer now is if we’re going to learn from our past, or if — even in the aftermath of disaster — we’re going to repeat those same mistakes.  As the alarm bells fade, the din of Washington rises, as the forces of the status quo marshal their resources, we can be sure that answering this question will be a fight to the finish.

It’s nice to see this President throw an oratorical elbow every once in a while–apparently he does it on the basketball court. The craven duplicity of some of his opponents make it a necessary tactic in the arena as well.

Related Topics: Budgets, Economy, Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Audacity of Dope: Tales of a Toking Teenage Obama

    We knew Barack Obama smoked weed in high school because he wrote about it in his books. What we didn’t know until Buzzfeed posted these choice nuggets (I’m so sorry) from David Maraniss’s new book on the President’s younger years, is the giggle-worthy details of his “Choom Gang” lifestyle, which are right out of a buddy stoner flick. Obama and his friends drove around the lush Hawaii countryside, hot-boxing their VW bus and re-upping with a long-haired pizza-tossing dealer named Ray, who Obama thanked in his yearbook “for all the good times.”

    Lewis Eisenberg, Major Romney Donor, Accuses Obama Of Demonizing Wall StreetHuffPost Politics

    Obama Stumbles? Why the President’s Right to Talk About Bain

    The meme of the day in journo-world is that President Obama has stumbled at the outset of the general election campaign. The evidence for this? Well, uh, there isn’t very much, really–except that a few Democrats have criticized his campaign’s attacks on Mitt Romney’s record at Bain Capital and that Obama’s fundraising is merely humongous, instead of obscenely humongous. The two phenomena are linked, of course: Obama isn’t getting the usual haul from Wall Street because he has outrageously–outrageously!–tried to regulate the bankers who did so much to crash the economy in 2008. The handful of Democrats squawking are people who either (a) get money from private equity firms or (b) have retired and joined Mondo Casino. But there is another side to this story:

  • shepherdwong

    Well, someone in a position to lead public opinion should be telling the country that Republicans are naked hypocrites who are completely unserious about governing the country. Thanks for climbing aboard Obama’s coattails, Joe.

  • nflfoghorn

    Why doesn’t he do it more often? He offers his hand in niceness and gets paid back with tread marks. His opponents don’t like anything he says and will say/do the opposite of what he says/does.

  • gysgt213

    What are the 2 wars we are waging right now adding to the deficit or are they deficit netural?

  • destor23

    On McConnell opposing a 0% capital gains tax for small businesses I have to wonder why you’re surprised. The major parties represent large businesses over small ones, for sure.

    I am confused though: do small businesses regularly pay capital gains? Maybe on real estate but I don’t tend to think of a small business as owning a lot of rapidly appreciating assets the way, say, Microsoft might invest its cash hoard.

  • pintortwo

    And the question we’ll have to answer now is if we’re going to learn from our past, or if — even in the aftermath of disaster — we’re going to repeat those same mistakes. As the alarm bells fade, the din of Washington rises, as the forces of the status quo marshal their resources, we can be sure that answering this question will be a fight to the finish.
    .
    .
    Perhaps Mr. Obama should ask himself this question and rethink his Afghanistan policy. Perhaps Mr. Klein and colleagues should ask themselves if they’ve learned anything from their mistakes prior to the Iraq invasion. Does no one want to admit that military spending has significantly contributed to today’s economic mess?

  • bitterpill8

    The President should give up on the bogus “bipartisanship” argument. He leads the Democratic Party. He should work with the Senate and the House to advance a Democratic agenda. Let him be honest and open. Independents always have a problem with trimming. Once they know what you stand for they tend to look at practical results. The deals with Pharma and sundry lobbyists (Daschle???) does a lot to undermine the President’s credibility. Independent s understand someone who governs with integrity. They may not agree with the President; but they respect honesty. Trimming is a loser’s game.

  • freeinpa

    Do anybody find it a bit ironic or possibly hypocritical that Obama has preached for months that we are in an economic mess because of tax cuts? Now to grow the economy and create jobs he is spouting tax cuts.

    I am sure the left will argue it is a “targeted” tax cut because they know best as to who and how should have the tax cut. Here is a little secret for Obama and the left. No one was ever hired by a poor person

    You gotta love it!

  • pintortwo

    Most Americans are employed by what we define as “small businesses” and Obama has always advocated easing the tax burden on the non-elite income earners.
    .
    So no, the irony and hypocrisy is actually shown when he decries “spending programs” while U.S. defense spending in coming years must rise roughly 6 percent on average from the record sum sought by President Barack Obama this year just to meet current plans, Congress’s budget office said Wednesday. But the republicans will never call him on that.

  • jcapan

    Great excerpt from a speech but will the actions match up with the challenge?

    From what he’s seen thus far, Reich says no:

    http://robertreich.blogspot.com/2009/12/presidents-jobs-initiative-doesnt.html

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    Perhaps f the media spent as much energy reminding the public of how badly the Republicans ran this country as they do keeping track of Tiger’s mistresses we wouldn’t have a problem. If the media would make sure the public knew the obstructionist role the GOP is currently playing, how they are helping corporate benefactors run rough shod over real democracy and how ordinary people are being lied to and hurt badly by GOP actions we wouldn’t have this problem. It’s nice to know you like hearing the President speak the truth, but what about those whose job it is to inform, where are all the watch dogs when you need them. I’m so tired of mistress watch, where in the world is Elin living and now illness watch of the mother in law. If there’s one reason that this country is in trouble, it will be because the media pays more attention to Tiger trivia than to the survival of our nation.

  • cdrwayne

    Links please

  • http://www.ghostnote.com Cookie Puss

    Do small businesses pay a lot of capital gains tax?

  • Art Pepper

    When third-world banana republics get into this kind of long-term structural mess, the IMF forces them to clean up their act. Perhaps China will do us the same service.

  • bob1212

    Obama Public Opinion Plan:
    If it works, take credit. If the people cryout, blame the problems on Bush and still take credit for whatever may work.

    How far into a presidency can you still blame things on your predecessor? As long we have the media riding his coattails and staying yes men, he’ll keep blaming failures on Bush.

    Bush increased the deficit by nearly $2 trillion in his eight years and Obama plans to nearly match that in a single year. Anyone see the difference? Bush in his biggest deficit for the year added $400 billion, Obama is adding $1.75 trillion (and that’s by the White House’s conservative numbers). That’s four times Bush’s worst year. And you still want to blame Bush for the deficit?

    Take some heat and quit trying to blame everything on Bush.

  • bob1212

    And by the way, why are we praising mudslinging? Yes, several members of Congress have done more than their fair share of mudslinging, but isn’t this the administration of change? We’re we supposed to be getting away from this ugly politics by voting in Obama. Wasn’t he going to change the way things work and work together in stead of slinging mud? The president keeps trying to say he is above that and is going to clean up Congress, but how can he when he continues the same politics of before?

    Obama, stay your course, rise above the mudslinging and prove that it isn’t needed to get things done in our federal government.

  • pintortwo

    cdrwayne, roll over the italicized quote, that’s the link. For some reason it is not showing in red.

  • ilikechips

    DEE-
    it’s no big secret that MSM is soo far in the tank for Obama and Dems. I don’t think anybody here would honestly disagree with that. Even my Lib friends agree. Remember non stop coverage of evil Bush Cheney Rove. Sounds like you would like crazy Keith Olbermann doing the nightly news.

    I do get a kick out of your semi-retarded posts though

  • gysgt213

    it’s no big secret that MSM is soo far in the tank for Obama and Dems. I don’t think anybody here would honestly disagree with that.
    .
    What fu%#king media are you referring to?

  • abdullah69

    The zero cgt rate is designed to free up the movement of capital by enabling small businesses to liquidate and move into more viable products/services or locations.

  • abdullah69

    Military spending is the biggest social welfare scam in the history of the planet. How much money is spent, how many people are employed, across how many states, on weapons systems that have been redundant for a very long time?

  • abdullah69

    Curious. I would have thought Dee was one of the more articulate and intelligent posters here.

  • http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2009/12/meredith-whitney-the-government-is-out-of-bullets.html Meredith Whitney: The government is “out of bullets” « naked capitalism

    [...] the duelling headlines today where Joe Klein points out a speech with elbows that the President delivered today.  Michael Tomasky was equally [...]

  • freeinpa

    pintortwo

    I would love a definition of what non-elite earners. I recall that with Bill Clinton the “rich” became anyone with a pulse and a job

  • freeinpa

    It’s not small businesses themselves. It depends how you frame that. Investors in small businesses pay capital gains taxes. Those investors may be the owner of the small business.

  • grollican

    Ilikechips – you’ve got the wrong screenname. You ought to be “I like crack”. You’ve never written anything approaching the honesty and insight that Dee customarily shows.

  • eclecticman1

    Finally the president is starting to get real. He has been trying to be above partisan politcs with nicey-nicey talk, but the GOP wants nothing to do with working together to solve our country’s ills; they want him to fail not matter the cost to America. I want him to start throwing punches and show the country exactly what the Republicans are up to.

  • pintortwo

    I made up the phrase “non-elite earners”, you like?
    What I mean is that, as a candidate, he proposed lowering taxes for most and increasing the income tax rate for the top earners. This chart shows what he proposed:
    http://chartjunk.karmanaut.com/taxplans/
    .
    IOW, 90+% of earners would have their taxes lowered while the top 1% would bear the burden.

  • chapalody

    All of President Obama speeches are the same. They go nowhere because President Obama doesn’t believe a word he’s saying. There weren’t any elbows because President Obama is still the weak President he was a week ago and will be the same weak President three years from now. The only elbows being thrown are the ones being used to force the government health down the throats of the American people. Come election time the American people are going to throw their own elbows. How about a little elbow with Iran and North Korea. No backbone there and no elbows either with speeches or spine. Sooner or later the speeches and the excuses are going to run out with this President. Bush is still being used to excuse President Obama for his failures as well as his failed theories on everything. Creating a bogus image of President Obama after what the people have witness for themselves is as useless as President Obama standing up to Iran and North Korea. No backbone for the hard decisions. The new job programs should have been proposed in the beginning. The new programs of President Obama are the one’s he call failed theories of the Republicans. How does crow taste President Obama.

  • grollican

    Boring, and you get a failed grade in English. But you are a GOP troll, so you probably like your work.

  • palininatowel

    My god, bob, Bush and your crew blamed Clinton for everything for eight years. Had McCain won instead of Obama, you’d still be blaming Clinton.

  • palininatowel

    I note that number of Tiger mistresses exposed now exceeds the current unemployment rate.

  • destor23

    @abdullah: thank you. That makes a lot of sense. I think small businesses need more help than that but it helps to see the rationale.

  • lighthouse5508

    wow, all of you are retarded. Firstly if you still believe that there is a 2 party system- then you might as well go out and live under a rock. hold on- wasn’t obama going to bring the troops home? wait where are they… oh ya Still on the other side of the world! who put them there- Bush. Who’s keeping them there- Obama. What did Bush do? cut taxes. what is obama proposing? cut taxes. Obama is only treading water on the economy while the fed desperately tries to fix it’s mess. all you idiots need to pull back the curtain and see for yourself that it’s just an idiot behind the curtain pulling levers. The president is only there to take orders from someone else. all he is is a mouthpiece- does the quote, “Give me control of a nation’s currency and i care not who makes the laws” make any sense? What Obama really needs to do is to protect and uphold the Constitution- something he TOOK AN OATH to do, as did the rest of Congress. Nowhere does the Government have the power to do anything with healthcare or the economy. Why don’t you all actually do something productive and read the constitution- all of it. Here’s a spoiler though- no pictures!

  • textee

    I don’t know what’s more frightening: A clueless socialist like Obama giving a “jobs speech” or an anti-military, William Ayers militant like Obama giving a speech on the United States military and its mission. It might actually be better if Obama remained outside of the United States during his last three years in office and spent his time overseas continuing his endless America Sucks World Tour.

  • conversets

    “retarded” hee hee! “pull back the curtain” hee hee! “no pictures” hee hee!

  • apollyon07

    Both sides do this a lot, though I do seem to remember the 2001 recession blame falling squarely on Bush when in fact it started towards the end of Clinton’s term.
    .
    I mean, if we’re going to be consistent in all of this blaming.

  • conversets

    Just click the “Add to Junk Senders List” next time you get an email like that. Then stay away from the intertubes for a few days until the headaches and voices go away. And please, ALWAYS REMEMBER TO TAKE YOUR MEDICATION!

  • apollyon07

    “Great excerpt from a speech but will the actions match up with the challenge?”
    .
    Probably not. This is why Obama is hemorrhaging support among Independents.

  • diecash1

    “Bush increased the deficit by nearly $2 trillion in his eight years”
    ..
    This is wrong on all counts. Bush increased the national debt by nearly $5 trillion over his term, not the $2 trillion that you contend. How is it you could get that so utterly wrong?
    ..
    01/19/2001 $5,727,776,738,304.64
    ..
    01/16/2009 $10,628,881,485,510.23
    ..
    http://www.treasurydirect.gov/NP/NPGateway

    Read more: http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2009/12/08/a-jobs-speech-with-elbows/?replytocom=115675#respond#ixzz0ZA61HbdQ

  • sacredh

    Everybody seems to be getting a little testy. If the high sheriffs would just disable the cuss filter we could really party.

  • sacredh

    This is one thing I don’t like about working 4-12. By the time I get home everybody has either worn themselves out or hit the rack. Goodnight. The 29th anniversary of Lennon’s murder was today btw.

  • http://russellcb.wordpress.com russellcb

    What!?? Are you serious? Weren’t both wars started before the current administration? Even if the wars were both stopped tomorrow and all the soldiers and equipment and sailors and boats came home, we would still have to pay back all the money that was spent over there since 2001!! That is called a deficit. It is like the Bush/Cheney family took off with your credit card and bought a war or two and left town with your check book as well. Get a clue!!

  • http://russellcb.wordpress.com russellcb

    You are forgetting the budget surplus that Bush inherited. He spent all that and more. He has spent half of the first TARP and most of that to his buddies in Asia to take trips and buy drinks and – you are so blinded by what you think is going on. You think the rich republicans are going to bring you along with the big crash. Truth is they will leave you and your meaningless paper blowing in the wind.

  • http://russellcb.wordpress.com russellcb

    Are you sincere? This is a FOXNews reprint, right? Don’t be surprised when the Republicans bankrupt every government program in search of security and ask you to step up and help them. All the while buying up South American cattle ranches and Oil Fields to retire the entire family too, not including you.

  • freeinpa

    pintortwo

    Yes quite clever. I may borrow that one.

    The only problem with only taxing the rich? They will change their income accumulation behavior and you nevr get the taxes you think you will. And with the deficit at current levels you could liquidate the top 1% and you woudl still have a deficit.

  • freeinpa

    grollican

    Speaking of crack… Every post of Dee’s (the chapters of incoherent blathering) can be boiled down to 2 lines: 1) I hate conservatives (Spare us the brother-in-law anecdote), and
    2) There is a conspiracy between everybody and the mediia because they don’t agree with her blatherings.

    Really it saves time.

  • piper1

    “Both sides do this a lot, though I do seem to remember the 2001 recession blame falling squarely on Bush”

    False.
    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4264572/

    “The president inherited a Clinton recession and turned it into the early stages of Bush prosperity,” Mr. Evans (Bush’s Commerce Secretary) said, pinning the blame on Mr. Bush’s predecessor even though the generally accepted starting date for the recession is a month or two after Mr. Bush took office.” http://www.nytimes.com/2004/09/02/politics/campaign/02econ.html?_r=2

    “when in fact it started towards the end of Clinton’s term.”

    Again, false.

    “At its meeting, the committee ( Business Cycle Dating Committee of the National Bureau of Economic Research) determined that a trough in business activity occurred in the U.S. economy in November 2001. The trough marks the end of the recession that began in March 2001 and the beginning of an expansion.” http://www.nber.org/cycles/july2003.html

    One can place blame for the underlying fundamentals that led to the 2001 recession in a number of places, but the fact is that the recession began while George W Bush was president. Bush presided over the beginning of two recessions in his 8 year term.

  • fhmadvocat

    I find it ironic that people are tired of Obama “blame it on Bush”. Do these folks have amnesia? Did they forget the recession of the early 80′s? After all, when was the last time unemployment was this high? 1983? The 3rd year of the Reagan presidency? Was Reagan responsible for the recession which really hit in mid-1981 and lasted 14 months?

    At this point, Obama has not even been in office a year, and already, the worse of the recession is subsiding. This is impressive considering how much worse we were now than in the 1980s.

    In truth, the fault lines run pre-Bush II. We have been deregulating Wall Street for the past 30 years and our current recession is a result. It did not help we had two wars (one completely unnecessary) and the true numbers were kept off the books.

    Obama has to correct some systematic problems, some of them 30 years old like the banking industry, some more than 70 years in the making, like health care.

    Obama is trying. He never promised everything he did would work. In fact, he stated he would sometimes fail. I don’t remember Bush ever saying that. I may not like everything Obama is doing, but he is trying to do something, which is more than can be said for the Republicans, who only propose “solutions” after the fact.

  • fhmadvocat

    freeinpa,

    There is a time for tax cuts and a time not to cut taxes. When the economy is in a slump and you are trying to pump the economy, tax cuts are a good thing. (i.e. Ronald Reagan in the early 1980s). Tax cuts are a bad thing when you are trying to fund two wars and the government is spending money like crazy (Bush and the Republicans from 2001 to 2006). Even John McCain was honest enough (when he was not running for president) to say it is irresponsible to cut taxes while trying to fund a war. Bush was fighting two wars and the Republicans in Congress went on a spending spree which would make any liberal Democrat proud.

  • http://www.cahomesalessolutions.com/real-estate-news/meredith-whitney-the-government-is-%e2%80%9cout-of-bullets%e2%80%9d/ Meredith Whitney: The government is “out of bullets” | California Home Sales Solutions

    [...] the duelling headlines today where Joe Klein points out a speech with elbows that the President delivered today.  Michael Tomasky was equally impressed. But, this was just a [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus