Bill Frist on Health Bill: I’d Vote For It

  • Share
  • Read Later

Or so the former Senate Republican Leader, a surgeon who has written a new book on health care, told me a few minutes ago in an interview.

Were he still in the Senate, “I would end up voting for it,” he said. “As leader, I would take heat for it. … That’s what leadership is all about.”

This is not to say that Frist is entirely happy with everything that is in the bill.

For one thing, he doesn’t think it does nearly enough to bring costs under control. In his view, it does not fundamentally change the incentives that providers now have to provide more care, rather than better care. “There is really nothing to bend the cost curve,” he says.

And Frist also predicts it will extend coverage to only 20 million or so additional Americans–far short of true universal coverage. Given the fiscal constraints, he says a better approach would be to provide a more bare-bones package of benefits, known as “catastrophic coverage.” That less expensive insurance, while not covering as many routine medical services, would be affordable to more people and provide for care should they suffer a serious illness or condition that might otherwise bankrupt them.

However, he strongly supports other aspects of the bill–most notably, its requirement that individuals be required to purchase coverage, if they do not receive health insurance through their employers or under government programs. And he also lauds the provisions that would eliminate practices that allow insurance companies to discriminate against people based on their health history, including pre-existing conditions.

Frist also faults some in his own party for injecting alarmism into the debate. “Clearly, the death panels and public plan arguments have been overblown,” he says. Frist noted that Republicans themselves voted for a Medicare prescription drug bill that would have established a version of a public plan–with the government negotiating directly with drug companies–if private-sector competition had failed to materialize. That is similar to the approach that Republican Senator Olympia Snowe is taking with her amendment to establish a public option with a “trigger.”

While Frist believes that the bill will pass, he worries that the Obama Administration and Congress have not given enough attention to what happens next: the implementation. The first few years are likely to be rough, he predicts. States will be struggling to set up new marketplaces for insurance coverage, their medicaid rolls will grow, taxes will go up, and consumers will not yet see the benefits. “The Republicans will go wild,” using the start-up difficulties as a tool for fundraising and for making their case in the next election, Frist says. “In the Congress, nobody’s thinking about that.” His advice for the Obama Administration: “Stay nimble,” and be prepared to make adjustments as difficulties arise.

UPDATE: Our friend Jon Cohn has an interesting observation:

For those keeping a tally, that’s three former Republican Senate Majority Leaders who have endorsed the sorts of reforms President Obama and his allies are pushing. Previously, Howard Baker and Bob Dole signed on to a plan they negotiated with Tom Daschle and George Mitchell, former Democratic counterparts, through the auspices of the Bipartisan Policy Center.

And this is as it should be. For all of the crazy talk about a radical government takeover, health care reform 2009 is an amalgam of compromises, many based on ideas taken straight from former Republican proposals–the kind of proposal, in other words, at least a few Republicans should be able to embrace in good faith.

Now if only some currently serving members of the party could take a cue from the retired elder statesmen…

14 comments
jackwhitey2
jackwhitey2

It really is so important that everyone has health coverage. The bills can rack up so quickly if you don't and have an accident. Just having the peace of mind that you will be okay if anything ever happened goes a long ways. http://ADCderm.com

john34howard
john34howard

I think this health bill is going to impact our lives a lot. I think that people don't understand how it is going to impact their lives. I think in a couple years people are going to understand how that works out.  http://www.branchburgchiropractor.com/ 

sgreenovich1
sgreenovich1

Dentistry is a major health concern. Usually it is the first concern that is addressed when it comes to an individuals health. Fortunately it is also one of the least expensive health concerns to deal with.

http://www.skeelsdentistry.com/

BobStrong
BobStrong

I am glad that he is stating his opinion and standing behind his words. There are a lot of different views on the current health bill. Too many politicians are bouncing back and forth between their stances. Whether Bill Frist is right or wrong, I respect him for at least being true to himself.  http://www.southshoretherapies.com/our_services/speech_therapy/

mansonjak
mansonjak

Now that takes a true leader to take full responsibility for his actions and the things that they do. I know that those are the kind of people that I want in charge and know that they know exactly what they are doing. It is really great that there are still those kinds of people in this world and we need more like them.

Jak Manson | http://www.desmoines-dentalassociates.com/oral-surgery.cfm

samesh1
samesh1

I really enjoy reading this. I've been wonder what was going to happen with health care and I was kind of nervous.  I'm not so nervous now that I know what to expect. http://arizonaeyes.net

jackwhitey2
jackwhitey2

It is so interesting how we are able to change laws that are holding us back or causing problems. The change and development in our country will never stop.  http://www.advancetherapy.com

bearobrien1
bearobrien1

I am excited about this happening because it will be a lot easier for me to afford a good obgyn in Maplewood, MN if this is in place. http://www.mnwcare.com

john34howard
john34howard

I think if this bill gives me help then I'm all for it. I take some sleep medicine and I think it really helps me. If I that was to no be there then I don't know what I would do. http://pmabellevue.com/services-2/