In the Arena

Iran Update

The next big event in the saga of the Green Revolution and the Purloined Election will occur on Friday when Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani delivers the sermon at Friday Prayers. Rafsanjani is, among other things, the most prominent Mousavi supporter roaming the Iranian landscape at present, still chair of the Expediency Council and the Assembly of Experts (although those posts may not mean very much these days), still accused of corruption by Ahmadinejad–and yet, still able to speak at Friday prayers, which must mean something…but what?

There’s lots of speculation about what Rafsanjani might say. One Iranian friend said, “It’s the speech of his life, a chance to redeem his career. He must call for the rejection of the election results.” Unfortunately, that’s never been Rafsanjani’s style and is an unlikely alternative now. But he and his family are also too closely identified with the protest movement for him to just acquiese and kowtow to the Revolutionary Guard Corps-dominated government. Another Iranian friend predicts, “He’ll announce the formation of a political front that will work within the system but oppose the Ahmadinejad government.” That seems more plausible.

If such a front does form, he could be a broad one–stretching from pure reformers like the Khatami brothers, to more traditional moderates like Mir-Hossein Mousavi (and Rafsanjani himself), to some of the so-called principalist conservatives who abhor Ahmadinejad’s confrontational style and populist economics. According to the New York Times today:

On Tuesday, Resalat, a conservative newspaper that supports Mr. Ahmadinejad, published an editorial warning the president that intellectuals and much of the political elite lacked confidence in him. The editorial urged him to avoid hasty decisions and to include opposition politicians in his cabinet.

Any sort of optimism based on these straws in the wind would be foolish. But it does seem that the dust is still settling in Iran, the possibility of  dissent still exists–although the probability of the dissenters having  much impact  seems  to be in the nil to  microscopic  zone.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Robert F. Bukaty / AP

    In Maine, Ron Paul Vies to Extend Mitt Romney’s Losing Streak

    Mitt Romney hoped to avoid a fourth straight election setback Saturday in the GOP presidential nomination race, but feisty Ron Paul could extend that losing streak with a victory in Maine’s caucuses.

    Romney: I Was A 'Severely Conservative' GovernorHuffPost Politics

    Ben Garvin / The New York Times / Redux

    Political Pictures of the Week, Feb. 4-10

    TIME’s photo editors bring you the best pictures of the past week from the Beltway and beyond.

  • yutsano

    Any sort of optimism based on these straws in the wind would be foolish. But it does seem that the dust is still settling in Iran, the possibility of dissent still exists–although the probability of the dissenters having much impact seems to be in the nil to microscopic zone.

    Of course predicting anything regarding Iran is a rather tricky business but are you certain of this Joe? The cracks are still there and exposed, the Khamanei faction hasn’t even made a single move to cover them up yet, all they have done is stamp down harder and harder. It may turn into a long slow boil but I don’t see any signs the opposition has given up yet. I’d say the next really telling event will be Ahmadinejad’s inauguration. I get the feeling that will be another round of riots as the Iranians are forced to accept a leader they may or may not have chosen.

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    Is it possible Joe that any assessment that the movement is likely over is based on making a comparison of factors that resulted in change the last time around. Unfortunately, conventional wisdom has an unnerving habit of basing everything on the last iteration and while the past can be a good indicator of future behavior, we have to leave room for people to learn lessons from history and choose to conduct things differently. You have to admit that’s why pundits were wrong so often in the 2008 election.

  • kathy

    How about a speech from Rafsanjani calling for a return to the principles of the revolution, which Ahmadinejad and Khameni are violating.

    Joe, a reader on Andrew Sullivan’s site reports that the Dish is blocked in Iran. Do you know if Iranians are still able to get Time and Swampland?

  • pirooz88

    Dear Kathy,
    yes, we do, it’s not a new problem. we have lots of undergrad communities. it’s 30 years that satellites, movie, gathering, concert, party, drinking …or even newspaper are illegible(in Islamic Government thought and rule) but people have all of them undergrad. we have news faster than you think. anyway these days we are so happy that you are worry about us and you guys interest what’s going on in Iran.

    Cheers to Green

  • hidayatm

    on Friday when Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani delivers the sermon at Friday Prayers he should invite all to accept the result of the election and all to support President elect Dr Mahmoud Ahmadinajad.
    Rule of law separates good citizen from a terrorist or lawbreaker in any society. Iran is no different
    Khatami and Mossavi are losers, they need to grow up and learn how to be gracious and bow out and not to disgrace themselves any further.
    it certainly is a golden opportunity for Rafsanjani to redeem himself.

  • Joe Klein

    Kathy–As the two Iranian commenters below you have noted, Swampland seems to get through because it is associated with Time Magazine, which is not filtered. Andrew’s blog–and most others that are unaffiliated–seem to be blocked by the powers that be.

    And to my Iranian readers, speaking for all your friends here in the States: We think about you all the time. We admire your courage. We hope for sanity from the government, but don’t expect it. Please be careful as you go about the business of making Iran the great, grand lovely country that it should be. Please be safe.

  • yutsano

    Joe, beautiful sentiment, nothing to add to that really.

  • jcapan

    Happy to associate myself with that 2nd paragraph–ditto from Japan!

  • http://peace-post.com/?p=652 What Will Rafsanjani add to The Green revolution?

    [...] TIME magazine Share and [...]

  • kathy

    Thanks for the reply Joe, and ditto your sentiments. well said.

  • http://xpostfactoid.blogspot.com asp48

    Joe, Andrew Sullivan is not unaffiliated; he’s hosted by The Atlantic. Do Iranian authorities block the whole Atlantic? If so, it would be because of the Daily Dish.
    My guess is that the key point is not “affiliated or not,” but Andrew’s conversion of The Dish into one of the top handful of news conduits for the uprising in Iran.

  • readeroftealeaves

    Ditto the ‘admire your courage’ sentiment.

    It’s fascinating to watch a nation with such ominous demographics (half the population under 30!).

    In addition, if it is true that the literacy rates have jumped from around 56% in 1979 to around 82% today, then it’s inevitable that there will be huge social changes in Iran. The way that expresses itself politically will be interesting to watch; so far, it’s been inspiring.

  • http://www.defendyourvote.com/featured/2009/06/16/iran-an-electoral-crisis/609 Iran: An Electoral Crisis! #iranelection | Defend Your Vote

    [...] There’s lots of speculation about what Rafsanjani might say. One Iranian friend said, “It’s the speech of his life, a chance to redeem his career. He must call for the rejection of the election results.” [...]

  • http://linkthe.com/2009/07/13/iran-uprising-blogging-week-of-july-13/ Iran Uprising Blogging: Week Of July 13 | linkthe.com

    [...] There’s lots of speculation about what Rafsanjani might say. One Iranian friend said, “It’s the speech of his life, a chance to redeem his career. He must call for the rejection of the election results.” [...]

  • http://www.therantingpersian.com/?p=80 A Month On: Thoughts on Today’s Friday Sermon | The Ranting Persian

    [...] this sermon will be carefully listened and analyzed for any political messages. This could be the most important moment in his political career. Indeed, from a strategic perspective, this presents an opportunity for “redemption” [...]

  • http://www.defendyourvote.com/breaking-news/2009/07/22/iran-an-electoral-crisis-iranelection-archive-6/1250 Iran: An Electoral Crisis! #iranelection – ARCHIVE 6 | Defend Your Vote

    [...] There’s lots of speculation about what Rafsanjani might say. One Iranian friend said, “It’s the speech of his life, a chance to redeem his career. He must call for the rejection of the election results.” [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus