In the Arena

Republicans and Democracy

Christopher Hill* was finally confirmed as U.S. Ambassador to Iraq yesterday, a month later than he should have been. The reason for the delay was an American patriot named Sam Brownback, the U.S. Senator from Kansas, who allegedly had objections to Hill’s independent conversations with the North Koreans–passively, but not explicitly, approved by the Bush White House–and his failure to excoriate the NoKos on human rights. Brownback knew that his was a losing proposition, especially after General David Petraeus weighed in, pleading for Hill’s swift appointment. After all, Iraq is a fragile state just now and a world-class negotiator like Hill might have been able to spend the past month helping the Maliki government come to terms with the Sunni Awakening militias, and to help ease the Arab-Kurd tensions in the north. I mean, imagine for a moment, if the situation were reversed and Russ Feingold were holding up the appointment of, say, Jerry Bremer, as Bush’s Iraq emissary. The howls would be deafening. Feingold would be accused of crippling the U.S. war effort. His patriotism would be questioned. 

So let’s be clear: Sam Brownback is a solipsistic poseur who has hampered the U.S. war effort in Iraq. I don’t question his patriotism, just his intelligence.

And, by the way, the same goes for the Republicans counseling Norm Coleman to keep up his futile fight so that Minnesota is denied its full compliment of Senators. If Al Franken were doing this, you can imagine what Rush Limbaugh and his GOP minions would be saying. 

*As regular Swampland readers know, my son is a foreign service officer who served on Hill’s staff in the past–and is about to join him in Iraq.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Morning Must Reads: Severe

    Romney: I Was A 'Severely Conservative' GovernorHuffPost Politics

    Seth Wenig / AP

    Birth Control Debate: Why Catholic Bishops Have Lost Their Grip on U.S. Politics—and Their Flock

    The clash with the White House over birth control is a reminder of just how much influence the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has lost in the 10 years since the child sex abuse crisis erupted in America.

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    You could include an addendum to the Republicans and Democracy post with the example of Senator Inhofe pledging to filibuster a judicial nominee, something he himself in the past said was unconstitutional, because he got the particulars of a case the nominee ruled on ALL WRONG.
    .
    http://thinkprogress.org/2009/04/21/inhofe-fillibuster-judge/

  • http://culturedecoded.wordpress.com/ pacer521

    wow — very interesting post. I agree with the speaker — he makes a good arguement, especially because his son is in foreign service.

    http://politicsdecoded.com/2009/04/22/tactical-piece-rebuilding-the-gop/

  • gysgt213

    Joe-Thank your son for his service for me. His is a very important job and you should be a very proud pappa. And thanks so much for the work you do too. Even though I disagree with you from time to time it is very important to a lot of us here that you read and take seriously our thoughts even though you may disagree.

  • spob

    “an American patriot named Sam Brownback”–does anyone wonder why Time Magazine is not taken nearly as seriously as it used to be–with commentary like this, it’s not long until it’s in Newsweek territory.
    .
    The Dems held up scads of Bush nominees when Bush took office.

  • pirate wench (demwoman)

    Even though I be a pirate, I can help bu’ be thinkin’…DEMOCRACY? They don’t need no stinkin’ democracy!
    .
    Arrgh!

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    The wingnut Pee Wee Herman defense: “I know you are but what am I”

  • FlownOver

    Those of us who are reasonably well acquainted with Sam Brownback know that Klein is being generous in his description. He’s the closest thing the Senate has to an outright religious fanatic, anxious to impose his own freedom of choice through the force of government on everyone else. I’ve never seen him do or say anything that was NOT the product of political calculation, nor has he expressed an original idea at any time in his elective career. The good news for the country is that he’s not running for re-election; the bad news for Kansas is that he wants to come home and be elected governor.

  • textee

    What happened to that so-called “civil war” that political advocacy groups like NBC alleged existed in Iraq? I don’t remember, but was Time magazine one of those political advocacy groups which also alleged that a so-called “civil war” existed in Iraq? That long forgotten loon Michael “Charlie Manson” Ware did. Wasn’t he previously employed by Time magazine to write al Qaeda press releases?

  • http://lifeissweet.wordpress.com/ blazin

    solipsistic is my word for the day . . . thank you Joe!

  • shepherdwong

    “What happened to that so-called “civil war” that political advocacy groups like NBC alleged existed in Iraq? I don’t remember, but was Time magazine one of those political advocacy groups which also alleged that a so-called “civil war” existed in Iraq?”
    .
    It’s bubbling along quite nicely:
    .
    http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/04/13/MN6A171LIK.DTL
    .
    …although a little less red hot since we facilitated the murder and ethnic/sectarian cleansing of millions of innocent Iraqi men, women and children from their homes. But you probably figure that link is from some “political advocacy group”, i.e., not Rush Limbaugh, FOX or News Corp., so, please, do feel free to check it out for yourself on your next vacation. I’m sure you’ll love the peace and tranquility now that the war is over. Bon voyage.

  • patroclus7

    Mr. Klein has a son??!!!

    (I am reminded of a scene from the musical 1776 where John Adams is trying to convince Jefferson to author the Declaration while TJ is demurring and insisting on going home to be with his beloved wife. TJ says: “but I burn, Mr. A!” And Adams responds: “so do I, Mr. J.” And then Franklin chimes in with a “Really?! Who’d have thunk it?”)

    Not that I’m necessarily comparing Mr. Klein to Adams although I’d wager that if Mr. Klein had been around in Adams’ day, Mr. Klein would have found some way to completely justify the Alien and Sedition Acts and to lambaste any critics thereof.:-)

    Mr. Klein has a son??!! Who’d have thunk it??!

  • jcapan

    Something about an apple and a tree springs to mind. Time and State–two essential propaganda tools to any empire.

  • Deggjr

    “The Dems held up scads of Bush nominees when Bush took office.”
    .
    Name 15, which would only be a fraction of a scad.

  • 53_3

    “The Dems held up scads of Bush nominees when Bush took office”
    .
    Is that wrong? Who wouldn’t have done so. That was the primary means to stop the Bush/Cheney/Rove trinity from completely politicising most or all of our governmental departments a la the DOJ.

  • 53_3

    “Wasn’t he previously employed by Time magazine to write al Qaeda press releases?”
    .
    He doesn’t work for the RNC.

  • sacredh

    Brownback is everything I admire in a republican. A tireless worker doing his best to make sure that his party alienates everyone who isn’t a wingnut.

  • pobo1

    I don’t think the Republicans believe in democracy. What happened to having the people you (the President) want to serve in his cabinet? And why does anyone listen to a christianist like Sam Brownback anyway? He is not a patriot, he puts his religion before his country. As Jon Stewart said recently “You lost” That’s how a democracy works. We didn’t like it when Bush “won” in 2000 and again in 2004, I abhorred his policies, positions and personality but he was, sadly, my President. Get over it. Obama is your President now.

  • sevenoaks07

    Joe: best wishes to your son who is going to a tough post.
    I don’t know what happens to some Senators: Brownback, Inhofe, Bunning and a slew of others.They seem to assume they have been anointed. Brownback is an example of an a##hole who thinks he can drive negotiations with the North Koreans by issuing instructions to a State Department official.

blog comments powered by Disqus