Ron Paul’s Buccaneers

The difference, a tour guide informed me on a recent trip to Cartagena, between a pirate and a buccaneer is that latter is officially sanctioned by a state. So, while Queen Elizabeth I rewarded Sir Francis Drake with a percentage of his bounty, pirates just divvied treasure amongst themselves. Texas Congressman and former presidential candidate Ron Paul this week suggested in a youtube video bringing back buccaneers to help deal with the increase in pirates around the globe, particularly off the Horn of Africa. But before you go dreaming up images of Minutemen in tripped-out yachts (as I did), Paul, a long-time libertarian, meant simply reissuing “Letters of marque,” often granted by Congress through the 18th Century to merchant ships empowering them to arm and defend themselves. “I think if every pirate knew that this would be the case,” Paul said in the video, “they would have second thoughts because they could probably be blown out of the water rather easily if those were the conditions.” While certainly this solution would be a cheaper, free market way to deal with pirates, the booty incentives hidden in the holds of the Somali pirate ships aren’t quite the riches enjoyed by Drake, who once ransomed Cartagena back to Spain for two million gold pieces. In other words, the Somali pirates shouldn’t be worried about becoming “marked men” anytime soon as the cost benefit of flying out to Africa, outfitting a ship and hunting down pirates in international waters, even in this economy, promises to be too thin. That said, arming the heck out of merchant ships through these letters might well give those Somali pirates some pause.

Subscribe to Jay Newton-Small on Facebook
Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Morning Must Reads: Severe

    Romney: I Was A 'Severely Conservative' GovernorHuffPost Politics

    Seth Wenig / AP

    Birth Control Debate: Why Catholic Bishops Have Lost Their Grip on U.S. Politics—and Their Flock

    The clash with the White House over birth control is a reminder of just how much influence the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has lost in the 10 years since the child sex abuse crisis erupted in America.

  • 53_3

    b-b-b-but I thought pirates were those “sixteen or seventeen year old Black kids” that our newest Black Activist cum Leader of the Conservative movement cum, well, just plain come, when it comes to teabagging, if you know what I mean, said when he accused Obama of killing ‘em simply because they were Doing Whatever it Was they Were Doing While Black.
    .
    Just to make political points, not less…

  • 53_3

    Oh, FYI, there’s “Driving While Black” or DWB, so that is actually DWIWTWDWB.
    .
    Rush Limbaugh is such a great Black Activist, ain’t he…

  • 53_3

    On a more serious not, even a libertarian has cronies.
    .
    In the “contractor” trade…

  • FlownOver

    “Tricked-out yachts,” perhaps? “Tripped-out” suggests a psychedelicized crew.

  • queencersei

    So Ron’s advocating a sort of Black Water on the high seas? Just a month or so ago a Thai fishing vessel was mistakenly identified as a pirate ship and sank by an Indian crew. I could just see this happening more and more. The whole idea just seems preposterous. Better to address the piracy problems at its root source in Somalia, while working with professional navies to curb the pirates in the mean time.

  • 53_3

    Plus, they might go under and we’d then have to bail them out too!

  • davidwaters1

    I’m not sure how well buccaneer ships would work, but I think what would work to defeat these pirates is to give coastal Somalians geater incentives to pursue a productive and honest living on the mainland. The U.S. strategic foreign aid budget could help catalyze this process, and an increase in funding in this highly successive department is necessary. The Borgen Project has good info on the estimated cost of ending global poverty:

    $30 billion: Annual shortfall to end world hunger.

    $550 billion: U.S. Defense budget.

  • gysgt213

    “sixteen or seventeen year old Black kids”
    .
    Maritime organizers.

  • textee

    Evidently, Jay Newton-Small and Time magazine haven’t gotten word of the new, politically correct word for what Newton-Small maliciously calls “pirates”. Race baiter Al Sharpton has now declared said “pirates” are to be called the “voluntary coast guard” of Somalia. Get with the program, Time magazine.

  • jarais

    the booty incentives
    .
    There’s a teabag joke in here. I’m just too tired to find it.

  • Jay Newton-Small

    textee: I’d imagine those Somalis probably prefer the term priate, if one were to ask them. Much cooler.

    53_3: very witty, re: bailout.

    FlownOver: tricked out is probably more apt, though I’m not sure that pimping out the yachts would help catch the pirates, except to blind them in the sun. I meant tripped-out, like crazy.
    JNS

  • Jay Newton-Small

    jarais: LOL.

  • Commenter 2B named later

    From http://www.illegal-fishing.info:

    “An estimated 700 foreign-owned vessels were engaged in unlicensed fishing in Somali waters in 2005, according to the Somali fishery country profile compiled by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO). However, the agency said it was ‘impossible to monitor their fishery production in general, let alone the state of the fishery resources they are exploiting. There is also strong suspicion of illegal dumping of industrial and nuclear wastes along the Somali coast.’ ”
    .
    So this piracy isn’t exactly coming out of nowhere. I’m just saying.

  • FlownOver

    If tripped-out is what you really meant, fine. I’d have thought the crew might be tripped-out, but not the vessel.
    Maybe that’ll become the Refrain of the Repentant Pirate, per Donovan circa 1966: “Could’ve tripped out easy but I’ve changed my ways.
    .
    In any event, the response is much appreciated.

  • greentraveler

    The idea of swashbuckling privateer heroes ridding the seas of these parasites is a grand one, but a romantic dream symbolic of past foreign excursion blunders. Anyone ever year of human shields? The International Maritime Bureau reports at least 260 hostages reported I wonder if Commodore Paul would make the call to “Take ‘em out, me hardees!” with hostages sitting in the bow?.
    .
    We need to move on to more intelligent options in the short term and work on righting the ship of Somalia for its people in the long.
    .
    Where’s demwoman when you need her? Arggggh.

  • greentraveler

    Oops, re-proofing always good when one’s been interrupted.
    .
    s/b The International Maritime Bureau reports at least 260 hostages being held in the country by pirates.

  • FlownOver

    Sorry – neglected to close Donovan quote from “Sunshine Superman.”

  • Cliff

    While certainly this solution would be a cheaper, free market way to deal with pirates
    .
    I don’t believe that for a second. Give some proof for it.

  • sacredh

    Since it was Ron Paul that suggested it, I guess we don’t have to worry about it ever happening.

  • Cliff

    Commenter 2B named later: On another blog I frequent, the author posted recommendations for Somalia. The blog was immediately invaded by Somalian commenters, furious at his hubris.
    After talking with them for a little bit, several mentioned what you did – that the pirate fleets come as a response to illegal fishing in their waters (which I hadn’t known before).

  • hellslittlestangel

    Ron Paul is intelligent, serious and lucid. For a right-winger.

  • keillrandor

    53_3:

    At least buckets shouldn’t be too expensive if they need bailing out?

  • g_crush

    .
    So, while Queen Elizabeth I rewarded Sir Francis Drake..
    .
    If we can get Ron Paul to dress up in Queen Elizabeth drag, I’ll happy to let Ron Paul write Letters of Marque to his heart’s content…
    .
    …Mr. Paul? Ralph Nader called to remind you that your 15 minutes are up.

  • sacredh

    Ron Paul dressed up in Queen Elizabeth drag? Doesn’t Rudy Guliani have some kind of GOP copyright protection in that area?

  • 53_3

    “At least buckets shouldn’t be too expensive if they need bailing out?”
    .
    Depends on just which sea they’re sinking in…

  • yutsano

    Ron Paul dressed up in Queen Elizabeth drag? Doesn’t Rudy Guliani have some kind of GOP copyright protection in that area?
    -
    I just want you two to know that I will NEVER get over the extreme psychological damage that mental image has seared into my brain.

  • yutsano

    BTW this post just SCREAMS for Pirate Wench commentary! Where is our resident buccaneer?

  • jcapan

    Cliff, fishing may just be the least of it:
    ~
    Jeremy Scahill @
    http://rebelreports.com/post/95749163/when-will-the-media-interview-somalis-about-the

  • sacredh

    OT, but a couple of weeks ago my MIL came out into the living room dressed for church in a new outfit. She asked us if she looked good. I told her that she looked better. Looking good was just wishful thinking. She looked like a fat-@ssed George Burns in drag.

  • rose83

    jcapan, thanks for the link.
    .
    JNS, that sounds like something worth further investigation.

  • Cliff

    BTW this post just SCREAMS for Pirate Wench commentary! Where is our resident buccaneer?
    .
    Aye! The resident seadog be fallin’ down on her job! I do be hopin’ her archnemesis CP in FL hasn’t done her in!

  • Cliff

    And what Rose said – thanks for the link.

  • apollyon07

    People opposed to them being armed kind of reminds me about when some people were opposed to pilots being armed in the cockpit post 9/11. I remember one even saying they shouldn’t be armed because “they really need to be in control of that airplane”.
    .
    And I didn’t believe that Al Sharpton thing at first but then I remembered that he is Al Sharpton so it’s probably true. Just for laughs, I found the clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUbsLKNCUoA

  • gysgt213

    “Aye! The resident seadog be fallin’ down on her job!”
    .
    Have some respect. How do you know she wasn’t taken out on a raid on the galley?

  • jcapan

    And further context, re: media coverage and western narrative-making about Africa:
    ~
    http://www.africa.upenn.edu/Workshop/chavis98.html
    ~
    A little dated (goes back to my grad school days), but most of his pts. remain operable. However, China’s stunning rise alters his closing sentiment–exploitation obviously can’t be reduced to race alone.
    ~
    So, when indigenous Nigerians attack oil rigs or Somalians attack western vessels, I always take it with a grain of salt.

  • jwadvocate

    Great, so overzealous ships can blow fishermen from other countries out of the water.

    “Hey, we’re just fishermen” (said in Somali language)
    “Yeah, right, I’ve heard THAT one before!” (armed merchant)
    BOOM!

  • jcapan

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090421/ap_on_re_us/piracy_suspect
    ~
    Now if only the world could see Cheney & co. shackled like this kid.

  • rustyreturns

    The real “Pirates” are Congressional Representatives and Senators. It is truly that simple.

  • jlmadrigal

    Of course it would work, and it is the Constitutionally correct solution. If Letters of Marque were used to capture Osama bin Laden – as Ron Paul advocated at the time of 911 – he would have been captured and tried long ago at a fraction of the cost, without the bloody Iraq and Afghanistan distractions. Air piracy is piracy too.

  • pirate wench (demwoman)

    I be here, mateys, I be here…but I just be readin’. It be not be a particular good time t’ be a pirate – wench or otherwise these days. Me comments keep windin’ up in th’ moderation brig :) !
    .
    YARR!

  • 53_3

    Yay!
    Pirate Wench:
    .
    Do you think you could see your way to sinking Rusty’s garbage scow?
    .
    With all hands, preferably…

  • pirate wench (demwoman)

    53 – rusty be right adept a’ sinkin’ ‘is own garbage scow, don’t ye be thinkin’? Firin’ down right through ‘is decks willy-nilly wi’ ‘is cannon? Rusty’s sorry wee raft o’ soggy ideas be not worth botherin’ t’ pull out th’ blunderbus fer, by my lights…it be wallowin’ an’ sinkin’ wi’out any o’ th’ rest o’ this fine crew troublin’ themselves on ‘is account. We wouldn’t be wantin’ t’ be gettin’ our own fine boots covered wi’ rustycrud, me hearty!
    .
    Now, let’s be seein’ if this ‘ere comment be making it through th’ moderatin’ armada…
    .
    Arrgh!

  • 53_3

    True, true, piratewench. Just put your bow on him and leave him to the sharks.
    .
    Now, for pure enjoyment, take a look at this:
    http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/04/21/alleged.pirate.new.york/index.html
    .
    Now I ask anyone who cares to answer, just why does this guy seem so happy? I can think of a couple reasons, but a want to hear others…

  • yutsano

    Now I ask anyone who cares to answer, just why does this guy seem so happy? I can think of a couple reasons, but a want to hear others…
    -
    My reasons are probably the same as yours, but he’s now in the US, he’s probably had more food in his captivity than in his whole life, and even if he’s a prisoner (and most likely will be for a very long time) he’ll have a life beyond his imagining in the US. That’s enough to make any kid with little understanding of the whole situation happy.

  • 53_3

    I think you hit that on the nail, yutsano.
    .
    Maybe we should threaten to send him air drop him near the inland border of Somalia. That way, he’d have to take his chances hiking back…

  • yutsano

    Maybe we should threaten to send him air drop him near the inland border of Somalia. That way, he’d have to take his chances hiking back…
    -
    Even worse: any and all Somali pirates get deported to…Ethiopia. That should be fun.

  • 53_3

    “Even worse: any and all Somali pirates get deported to…Ethiopia. That should be fun.”
    .
    I’ll go for that. There’s something about this whole thing that appeals to that inner Republican in all of us, don’t you think?

  • yutsano

    I’ll go for that. There’s something about this whole thing that appeals to that inner Republican in all of us, don’t you think?
    -
    Well my excuse is I’m slightly sadistic like all Scorpios are. However I wonder how much I feel towards this particular suspect. It’s kind of like the whole torture mishegas: he’s just a low-level player. Get the head pirates involved and things might get more, uhh, vengeful.

blog comments powered by Disqus