In the Arena

Yes We Can…Leave Iraq

AP is reporting that the Obama Administration will opt for a 19-month timetable for leaving Iraq. I’m told that the President will give a speech on Friday. The withdrawal will still leave 30-50,000 U.S. troops in place to continue training the Iraqi military and for special ops. There will, no doubt, be carping from the right–and perhaps some from the left, given the size of the residual force–but the situation in Iraq has improved and a fairly rapid draw-down is not only practicable but necessary. The Army and Marines remain over-deployed, there are budgetary considerations and the Af/Pak situation obviously has become a higher military priority. There are still serious problems in Iraq, especially along the Arab-Kurd border in the north, but nothing like the chaos that existed two years ago and the recent elections show a very positive nationalist and, to a lesser extent, secularist trend.

In any case, a dreadful chapter in the history of American policy–a bloody war of choice launched thoughtlessly–seems to be coming to a close.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / White House

    Obama’s Persuasive Powers on Gay Marriage Manifest in Maryland

    When President Obama endorsed gay marriage earlier this month, the media grappled with two basic political questions: Was his personal “evolution” a case of a politician transparently following a national trend toward accepting same-sex unions (accelerated, perhaps, by his chatty No. 2), and would it hurt his re-election chances by alienating socially conservative voters like black churchgoers? Sure, there was a recognition that it marked a gratifying moment for gay-marriage advocates — as well as some grumbling about the President’s view that it remains a state issue, not a federal one. But by and large, there were few suggestions that one man, even the President, would shift public opinion on the issue or affect public policy. Based on a new Public Policy Polling survey out of Maryland, it seems this possibility was underestimated.

    Lewis Eisenberg, Major Romney Donor, Accuses Obama Of Demonizing Wall StreetHuffPost Politics

    Cherokee Zero

    Apparently, Massachusetts voters don’t mind that Elizabeth Warren foolishly identified herself as a Native American early in her academic career–it was, apparently, a case of family pride and wishful thinking about a Cherokee ancestor. That’s good. Warren may be the best public figure when it comes to explaining the depredations of the financial industry and [...]

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    Joe Klein, if Friday comes and there is no 30k residual force you might consider that link I have been posting on your threads for about 3 weeks. There is a systematic attempt to get ahead of President Obama by Odierno/Keane/Petraeus to put pressure on him to do it THEIR way. That residual force has been mentioned as Odierno’s baby and a way to keep combat troops in the country just by relabeling them. I am not saying its for sure a head fake, but like I said if it happens then I think you might be wanting to give Gareth Porter a call.

  • flagrantenigma

    “…a bloody war of choice launched thoughtlessly..”

    And supported by a certain Joe Klein. No doubt, thoughtlessly.

  • plukasiak

    There is a systematic attempt to get ahead of President Obama by Odierno/Keane/Petraeus to put pressure on him to do it THEIR way.
    _
    you seem to be under the impression that JK isn’t part of that effort, but he’s been a petraeus groupie (and mouthpiece) from way back…
    _
    and lets face it, 30,000 troops is not a residual force, its a military occupation force for a nation that has been “pacified”
    _
    moreover, the “success” in Iraq has been rented (I was going to say bought, but that implies some kind of permanency), and if/when the US withdrawals its slush funds, the real fun will begin in Iraq. JK knows it, but he doesn’t seem to care…

  • Joe Bftsplk

    Question, Joe-
    One of the many questionable (and by “questionable” I mean criminally stupid, if not stupidly criminal) things that the Bushies did in Iraq was to outsource military functions to contractors like Blackwater. So the question is, if we have a “residual force” of 30,000 actual troops, how many contractors and civilians does that mean will be there to support and/or supplant them?
    I know Blackwater can’t operate there (under its current name, anyway), but I’d shudder to think of a few thousand mercenaries representing the face of America to a shell-shocked populace. Not to mention the expense.

  • destor23

    I’m not so sure I buy leaving up to 50,000 troops in the country as “leaving.”

    It’s a start. But that’s a lot of troops and it’s still very expensive. I’m going to carp from the left here. I want them all out.

  • stuartzechman

    The withdrawal will still leave 30-50,000 U.S. troops in place to continue training the Iraqi military and for special ops.
    .
    Joe Klein:
    .
    Any word on for how long these forces will be deployed, i.e. when will we be done “training” the Iraqi “military”?
    .
    Any word on how much the continued operations will cost, i.e. how much the Treasury will need to borrow above and beyond the 2 trillion dollars in stimulus spending to maintain our presence?
    .
    Any word on the size/cost of military contract personnel still to be deployed in Iraq?

  • jcapan

    Will they only be stationed near the oil-rigs and puppet palaces?

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    OT but fyi
    .
    David Shuster is correcting folks on hardball via Twitter. Chris Matthews has got to go. He just brought up the none existent rail line from vegas to LA unprompted after Shuster debunked it just yesterday. What a loon!
    .
    http://twitter.com/Shuster1600

  • cincinnatus est exterminata!

    “AP is reporting that the Obama Administration will opt for a 19-month timetable for leaving Iraq.”
    .
    Do we have confirmation from a legitimate news source?

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    “In any case, a dreadful chapter in the history of American policy–a bloody war of choice launched thoughtlessly–seems to be coming to a close.”

    Yes, let’s clone Saddam and put him back in power, intentions unknown (other than his track record).

    [If Jihad Joe Klein had been FDR's supreme allied commander, we'd ALL be speaking German and smelling French.]

    Mind you, Hitler never attacked America either.

    Now back to SKIPPY OBONGO BLAMES BUSH, already in retreat…

  • cincinnatus est exterminata!

    SG, saw it….Tweety just dutifully nodded his head the whole time. Seemed to agree w/ Ensign that government spending caused the Great Depression. Any minute now Tweety will again admonish the new President that 40% of the people don’t know what’s in the stimulus or how it will work! The great mis-informer wringing his hands at the mis-informed public…too rich for words.

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    “But with the economy in a recession that already has lasted longer than any other in a quarter-century, that was the dominant topic.

    The president aimed to drive home several points:

    • He inherited the mess, and a quick turnaround is unlikely. Not only did the recession emerge on Bush’s watch, the Bush approach wasn’t the right one…”

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/obama_speech

    When haven’t the libs blamed Bush — for the cowards Pelosi, Reid, Murtha, Frank, and Leahy?

    Obama’s going to throw some more CRAP on the walls of Congress tonight, hoping that some spastic socialist change sticks?

    Audacious, indeed.

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    American Idol, American Idle.

    American Idle, American Idol.

  • formerlyjames

    Never fear, all of those withdrawn troops will be relocated to Afghanistan.

  • formerlyrainbow68

    About time!

  • sevenoaks07

    Give Tweety his due: he is a dumbass. After Shuster’s take down of Issa you’d think this a**hole would know. But each one of these pidiots lives in his/her own bubble. Likewise with Joe and Mika.

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    In the question of soveriegnty/self-determination, 30-50K is an adequate force to make sure that Iraqis remain uncomfortable with the notion of NOT remaining a US puppet.
    .
    I shudder to think what a future under McCain would have looked like but Obama strikes me as an admixture of equal parts Bill Clinton and LBJ.

  • http://brusqueness.com/2009/03/19-months-ctd/ 19 Months, Ctd. | Brusqueness

    [...] Klein seems to like Obama’s Iraq withdrawal plan:…a dreadful chapter in the history of American policy–a bloody war [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus