A Mea Culpa From One Titan Of Finance; Who’s Next?

Goldman Sachs’ chief executive, Lloyd Blankfein, has penned a confessional essay in the Financial Times explaining some of the lessons learned from the financial implosion. It is notably frank, detailed, and self-flagellating, and it also offers a clear argument against Republican attempts to loosen “mark-to-market” accounting rules. He writes:

People are understandably angry and our industry has to account for its role in what has transpired. Financial institutions have an obligation to the broader financial system. We depend on a healthy, well-functioning system but we failed to raise enough questions about whether some of the trends and practices that had become commonplace really served the public’s long-term interests.

Read the whole thing here.

Maybe as a condition of further TARP funds, President Obama should issue a similar writing assignment to key officials from the banks and investment houses that failed to anticipate this catastrophe–in the same way that high school teachers make students write out their reasons for ending up in detention. Such self-reflection is a neccesary early step in restoring public confidence. We could publish each one with the same headline: “How I Failed You.” Who will step to the plate next? Several financial titans certainly have a lot more free time on their hands these days. Robert Rubin? Phil Gramm? John Thain? Bueller? Bueller? We are all waiting.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / White House

    Obama’s Persuasive Powers on Gay Marriage Manifest in Maryland

    When President Obama endorsed gay marriage earlier this month, the media grappled with two basic political questions: Was his personal “evolution” a case of a politician transparently following a national trend toward accepting same-sex unions (accelerated, perhaps, by his chatty No. 2), and would it hurt his re-election chances by alienating socially conservative voters like black churchgoers? Sure, there was a recognition that it marked a gratifying moment for gay-marriage advocates — as well as some grumbling about the President’s view that it remains a state issue, not a federal one. But by and large, there were few suggestions that one man, even the President, would shift public opinion on the issue or affect public policy. Based on a new Public Policy Polling survey out of Maryland, it seems this possibility was underestimated.

    Lewis Eisenberg, Major Romney Donor, Accuses Obama Of Demonizing Wall StreetHuffPost Politics

    Cherokee Zero

    Apparently, Massachusetts voters don’t mind that Elizabeth Warren foolishly identified herself as a Native American early in her academic career–it was, apparently, a case of family pride and wishful thinking about a Cherokee ancestor. That’s good. Warren may be the best public figure when it comes to explaining the depredations of the financial industry and [...]

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    Wow Scherer, I didn’t know you had it in you. But this is good stuff. Not a chance in hell that the rest of them come clean though. They are too wedded to their ideologies for that.

  • FlownOver

    Watch what you suggest, MS. It would be just as easy to require a reflective essay on objective campaign coverage as a precondition to being called on during the press conference tomorrow evening.

  • cdrwayne

    MS – This is the first of what I hope will be several good posts on why the big banks nearly brought our country to its knees, and why we should not be listening to the repubs

  • cincinnatus est exterminata!

    “Maybe as a condition of further TARP funds, President Obama should issue a similar writing assignment to key officials from the banks and investment houses that failed to anticipate this catastrophe”
    .
    Sounds a little Klein-ian. How about we investigate the banks, investment houses and the SEC and prosecute to the fullest extent of the law where it can be shown that laws were broken? And believe me, prosecutable offenses have occurred, certainly within the SEC.
    .
    I’m part of the populist rage out there that Frank Rich wrote about:
    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/08/opinion/08rich.html?_r=1

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    Failures taxing me for more failures…

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090208/ap_on_go_co/stimulus_higher_education

    The percentage of Pell Grant recips that NEVER GRADUATE is freaking SKY HIGH.

    This is monstrously stupid, wasteful spending, not based on merit, but the perceived needs of coddled academic staffers that are significantly anti-military, anti-business (source of all tax revenue), anti-reality, and of course anti-American.

    We’re getting to the point where the IRS will have to open a new Service Center just to handle the influx of tax protest cases that refuse to pay for this and most of the other BS in the Obama 5 Minute Bankruptcy Assurance Plan (which will assure the nation’s fiscal frigidity for 10 years, at least, if put into play).

    There’s no sense on these massive projects — as the economy will soon enough recover even without guvment meddling.

    Absolutely abhorrent behavior, by the same flaming elites that brought you Fannie, Freddie, ACORN, SDS, and Bill Ayers.

  • cdrwayne

    Hula
    .
    Please link to something anything that says Pell grant recipients has a low graduation rates when compared to all college students.

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    You can preach like TD Jakes to a wall, in the end its still going to be a wall.
    .
    Don’t feed the troll please.

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    cdrwayne
    ……..

    “For every 100 ninth graders, only 18 will enter college and finish within six years.”

    PELL GRANT = FREE MONEY FOR TENURED SLACKERS

    Proof THIS:

    http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/1128/p02s01-legn.html

    “There are also wide disparities in college attendance and completion rates between ethnic and racial groups, with Hispanics and blacks lagging behind whites and Asians.

    The costs of higher education, as well as poor preparation for college, are holding back many minority students, experts say.”

    Or THIS:

    http://www.michigandaily.com/content/u-gets-low-marks-accessibility-poor-students

    Money does not equal success, just access, to be sure — but the problem remains the primary school derelicts that can’t find their own state on a map of America attempting to keep up with the Obamas based on funding alone instead of actual grades.

    Any dillweed can gain entrance to Junior College U. and call him/her/itself a “college student” under the liberal fantasy of total diploma millage for all.

    We’ve absolutely chucked EXCELLENCE but for the sake of socialist late term day care.

    I would advocate vocational training where it is indicated, not this loose change attempt to appease the hot-headed professorships before they take Obama to the woodshed for helping to bomb Pakistan into oblivion.

  • jcapan

    “Such self-reflection is a neccesary early step in restoring public confidence”
    ~
    Um, doubtful–whether it be the lords of finance, of gov’t or of the media, I have this nagging suspicion that confidence is a thing of the past.
    ~
    Frank Rich needs an f’ing editor, even worse than Dowd. A typical meandering, blowhardy walk through his stream of consciousness. With the occasional statement of merit thrown in.
    ~
    Though she’s channeling P-luk, Joan Walsh’s piece the other day, in particular the Reich quote, a much better read.
    ~
    http://www.salon.com/opinion/feature/2009/02/04/obama/index.html

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    CEO pay IS chump change compared to what Aunt Samantha is about to shell out to subsidize more dumb kids going to even dumber colleges — or don’t any of you guys watch Leno’s street interviews with “college students” that can’t name the last 3 presidents (in any order), their state seat of government, or three signatories to the Declaration?

    We are indeed becoming the Daycare Nation.

    Yes, the Wall Street crooks and professorial slackers should be frog marched to Mexico for the duration.

    It will raise the per capita IQ in both countries.

  • wvng

    MS, I wonder if we will ever receive a mea culpa from your BFF McCain. Here he is today, rising to the occasion at a moment of national threat: But most of all, because I think this can only be described as generational theft. What we are doing is amassing multi-trillions of dollars — if you look at what’s going to be announced Monday or Tuesday, a new TARP — we’ve already spent $700 billion, another how many have you trillion –
    .
    Shieffer responded with “This is aid to the banks –” but McCain was off to the races.

  • http://www.inworldstudios.com jayackroyd

    MS-
    .
    Belated. I thought the marijuana headline was really funny.

  • http://www.hulagate.org hulagate

    I have this nagging suspicion that confidence is a thing of the past.
    … … …

    We’ve replaced merit with cultish mantras, Mall parties, military bashing, and festering isolationism gaily daily paraded by the sycophantic press as the proper populism.

    They used to call it class warfare, when there was more than one class.

  • pneogy

    David Ignatius has an interesting op-ed column on the subject in today’s Washington Post:
    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/02/06/AR2009020602742.html

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    wvng
    .
    Did you see where Rush Limbaugh invented the GOP talking point term for the stimulus bill “porkulus”? They aren’t even trying anymore. Seriously. And yet the media still are keeping their heads in the sand.
    .

    http://thinkprogress.org/2009/02/08/limbaugh-gop-reins/

  • wvng

    sgw, watching this “debate” unfold, I am in a state of near total disbelief. The GOP is going places I never would have imagined they could go. Ensign out there accusing Obama of fearmongering and saying the states need to cut back on services – at this moment when his own state is in desperate straits. Kyl saying It’s ‘dangerous’ and ‘careless’ to describe a potential depression as a ‘catastrophe.’ McCain completely off the rails, obviously with his little Gramm doll whispering in his ear that we are all whiners. The Chamber of Commerce endorsing the plan and most Repugs ignoring them. DougJ at Balloon Juice says: I’ve always thought, though, that some day the Republican party would become so insane that it would begin to frighten big business. That day may have arrived.
    .
    Ionescu could not have written anything more absurd than the repuglicans today. And yet the media continues to enable them.

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    wvng
    .
    Notice that if he Chamber of Commerce of the US had come out AGAINST the plan then it would have been the headline of every MSM source and talking head show. But because the COC ENDORSED the bill all you get is crickets. I know Scherer would have been flogging the story had the COC come out against it. It would have “proved” that it wouldn’t be good for businesses. But since they didn’t he has blinders on now.

  • wvng

    sgw, that sounds like a challenge to MS. A good one. MS, what say you?
    .
    The media has generally been astonishingly one-sided.
    .
    Did you see the cover of this week’s Newsweek? “We’re all socialists now.”
    .
    Last week’s was “Afghanistan: Obama’s Vietnam.”
    .
    And Benen’s post this morning on THE NETWORKS’ ‘GOODWILL’ regarding the networks carping about the prime time address coming Monday.

  • cdrwayne

    SG.

    You are right. I don’t know what I was thinking, especially in light of the fact that neither of the items that he/she/it linked to had anything to do the comparing Pell grant recipients graduation rates to the general population of college students graduation rates.

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    wvng
    .
    Sadly No evicerated Newsweek for thta cover.
    .
    http://www.sadlyno.com/archives/16988.html
    .
    But really all the Time writers should read it as well!

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    cdrwayne
    .
    Trust me, I have been pulled in many times but after awhile it just is a waste of time even pretending like you will ever make a difference to a troll. And it just makes people have to waste their time reading through the troll’s responses which are usually inordinately long and ridiculous.

  • Deggjr

    Great alertness in highlighting this article, young Michael Scherer. Perhaps you will reach middle age wisdom at some point.

  • opensourcepundits

    I am glad to see one of the major CEOs fessing up to his role in the greatest economic crisis since the Great Depression.
    .
    So…how much of his millions upon millions of bonus money did he enclose with that essay?
    .
    Oh…he’s not quite THAT sorry, I guess.

  • wvng

    Totally OT, but kinda fun. As proof that MS isn’t the only msm blogger who says foolish things slanted by a RW perspective (not this post), here’s Marc Ambinder Explaining The Cable TV Booking Dispartiy. The comments shred his transparently wrong argument almost immediately.

  • jcapan

    Reason for hope:
    “I give people the benefit of the doubt and try to understand their point of view,” he said. “If I perceive that they’re trying to take advantage of that, then I’ll crush them”
    -B. Obama to the Keene (NH) Sentinel, Nov. 2007
    ~
    As he’s taking to the soapbox this week, it’s time to deliver up some “crush”

  • umeshgeeta

    So the question is – will this stop the clamor for ‘relaxing mark to market rule’? Lloyd made a solid case against such relaxation. GS’s performance all along speaks loud. So many folks what this ‘cool aid’ and there are signs that Obama/Geithner may fulfill that. Market may not like it; but it could be a long term positive if we stick to this rule.

    We exactly need more of such discussion happening now. Thanks for this blog post. Vilification of bankers, especially of Lloyd, that for ignorant to undertake.

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    wvng
    .
    I am calling foul because I tried to sign up for Ambinders site and they still haven’t sent my confirmation email. I was going to tear his ass up seriously. I might have to sneak in under a different name or something.

  • wvng

    Here’s the video of Obama in NH:
    .

    .
    Sleep well. :-)

  • http://smoothlikeremy.blogspot.com/ sgwhiteinfla

    Here is a very useful bit of information from Kagro X as to why forcing a filibuster wouldn’t have made much difference when it comes to the stimulus package because of a point of order related to deficit spending that still would have taken 60 votes to get around.
    It would have been nice if some MSM source had researched this and pointed it out but at least Kagro X is on the case!
    .
    http://www.congressmatters.com/storyonly/2009/2/7/161443/9275/436/583

  • jcapan

    Thanks for posting that WV–I read the briefer quote in the Progressive Populist and admit it’s more fun watching it. Reminds me of why this guy was so appealing in the first place. However, we’ll see if he can live up to the big talk this week. First real test of leadership. I’m not a big fan of the bill–I feel like he should have owned it from the word go, and I loathe the tax cuts. But it’s not too late to make the GOP look like the vision-less fools they are. Personally I’d like to see him call the MSM’s centrist cult out too. And you sleep well. It’s only 1pm in my n-hood.

  • sacredh

    @sgwhiteinfla: As a former troll myself on some wingnut websites, I have to disagree with you. You CAN make a difference. Some of the responses I generated were so passionate that I could almost see the spittle flying and the veins standing out on their temples. As a regular blood donor for Red Cross, I felt that even if I was responsible for causing an aneurysm to blow, my gift of life might possibly end up flowing through the veins of a right winger. Karma at it’s finest.

  • Mitch Guthman

    Talk is cheap. I notice he didn’t offer to give back any of the loot. Any of you actual Time Magazine journalists thinking about calling him up and asking him why, if he feels so badly, he does not seem to be planning on returning any money to his shareholders?

  • plukasiak

    So the question is – will this stop the clamor for ‘relaxing mark to market rule’? Lloyd made a solid case against such relaxation. GS’s performance all along speaks loud. So many folks what this ‘cool aid’ and there are signs that Obama/Geithner may fulfill that. Market may not like it; but it could be a long term positive if we stick to this rule.
    _
    a temporary relaxation of mark-to-market rules is actually a good idea. A recent examination of one mortgage backed security found that its actual value (in terms of its current default rate) was 87 cents on the dollar, and even if foreclosure rates doubled, it would be worth 53 cents on the dollar. But its trading at 38 cents on the dollar. (see http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/business/economy/02value.html?_r=1&hp)
    _
    The current price of the security bears no relation to its current value, or its value in the forseeable future; its depressed value is an entirely psychological phenomenon.

    Under mark-to-market, that security should be valued at 38 cents on the dollar — and the ultimate result of doing would put the bank in technical default, requiring a government takeover of the bank. And while I’m not opposed to the government taking over banks, there is a very practical question here — basically, the people who have to deal with banks that have been taken over are already burdened by the responsibility of dealing with WaMu, IndyMac, and other institutions (Lehmann, Franny & Freddie, etc).
    _
    I am opposed to the government buying these “troubled assets”, because either the government will wind up paying too much for them (87 cents on the dollar is probably too high), or they will buy them at “market” prices which doesn’t really help the banks much anyway (it would allow the banks to meet their cash reserves requirements, but the bottom line would still require a takeover).
    _
    Temporary easing of “mark-to-market” combined with an agressive mortgage modification program, would stabilize the mortgage backed securities market — and once that stability is achieved, investors will no longer be afraid of these securities, their “market” price will increase substantially, and “mark-to-market” can be reinstated.
    _
    (I do oppose easing mark-to-market rules on stock prices, however.)

  • wvng

    sgw – thanks for that Kagro link. As you said, it would have been nice if some msm types had known enough to wrote that story. Except, perhaps, that by not writing the story they enhanced the anger on the left, and lord knows they like to write about the angry left. As opposed to the calm and reasonable right with “spittle flying and the veins standing out on their temples. “

  • delmoi2

    Translation: We shorted all the other banks and we’ll make a killing if they don’t get bailed out!

  • gysgt213

    “President Obama should issue a similar writing assignment to key officials from the banks and investment houses that failed to anticipate this catastrophe–in the same way that high school teachers make students write out their reasons for ending up in detention.”
    .
    Let’s give them writing assignments. That will show em.
    .
    How about we investigate these people and find out what they actually did. If it is proven fraud they go to jail. If its just plain incompetence then they get fired. If you can’t prove either because of ineffective and unclear rules and regulations, change the rules so that in the future its not that hard to figure out.

  • spob

    What’s Gramm have to be sorry for?

    What about Barney Frank and Franklin Raines? Certainly Fannie and Freddie have a lot to answer for.

blog comments powered by Disqus