In the Arena

To The Mountaintop

Word comes that Barack Obama’s grandmother has died. The timing is ridiculous. But think, for a moment, if you will of Madelyn Dunham, a white woman from Kansas, strolling the aisle of a supermarket, or having lunch in a coffee shop, with her grandson–way back at the turn of the 1970s, when such sights were uncommon, even in Hawaii. Think about what her friends might have thought, or said, about her…situation. Think about what she poured into the child during the years when her daughter was in Indonesia and she was the closest thing to a mother that Obama had; think about the impact that she and her husband had on creating the man we’ve come to know, and the satisfaction she must have felt in her dying days.

Some politicians simply are larger than life. Their stories are the stuff of high drama. Over the past few days, I’ve been hearing about the high emotions out in the field, as volunteers flood Obama offices to help canvass–and, in some places, find they have to wait on line for a spot on a phone bank. It is almost banal at this point to say that this has been the most remarkable election I’ve ever seen. It’s been a privilege to be a small part of it, to have had a ringside seat. And now, there is a sense that tomorrow will be the sort of day none of us ever forgets, one way or another–a day of reckoning, in the purest sense, when we will suddenly see ourselves and our country differently, for good or ill.

It will also be the first day that Barack Obama lives without the presence of the woman who was his surrogate mother. How sad for him, how remarkable that it would happen this way.

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Swampland

    Pete Souza / The White House via Getty Images

    Political Picures of the Week, May 18-25

    TIME’s photo editors bring you the best pictures of the past week from the Beltway and beyond.

    Obama Administration Blocks Global Health Fund To Fight Disease In Developing NationsHuffPost Politics

    From left: AP; ABACAUSA

    The Phony War: Obama and Romney Are Debating Character, Not Policy

    More than five months from Election Day, the back-and-forth about Mitt Romney’s record at Bain already feels played out. Unfortunately, there’s good reason to expect the campaign continues in this vein indefinitely. Neither Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney are terribly interested in dwelling on policy platforms. Romney’s plan to slash spending and keep taxes low on the wealthy isn’t especially popular, at least not at any level of detail beyond a blithe promise to shrink the deficit. Meanwhile, Obama’s signature first-term achievements, like health care, the stimulus and Wall Street reform, are all unpopular or tricky to sell. (The Dodd-Frank bill is the most popular of these, but hyping it means offending wealthy donors.) So what we’re getting instead is a superficial duel about character–and, worse, one that’s based on the largely false premise that the better man can better “manage” the economy back to health.

  • tyrantking

    How very poignant. Well said Joe Klein.

  • Tom in The Swamp

    Joe, what’s your opinion of the RNC (through the California Republican Party) choosing today of all days to file suit against Obama for taking the campaign plane to visit his dying grandmother?
    .
    Are they evil, or pure evil?

  • Tom in The Swamp
  • jarais

    You’ve captured this moment, Joe. It all starts tomorrow.

  • kristiia

    It is terribly sad.

    It is one of those things people try to make sense out of in some cosmic way. You can imagine it as his Grandmother getting to watch tomorrow night’s results from Heaven, together with Barack’s Grandpa and Mom.

    I’ve heard people say that you never truly grow up until you’ve lost both your parents because someone will always see you as and treat you with the loving support of a parent. For Barack, it would be his Mom and Grandparents in that role. As he said about his Grandmother “she’s the last one left”. :(

  • bitterpill8

    Thanks Joe and thanks to KT. I have posted at Karen’s and just wish to add: the timing is awful but that is life. My whole family is here now and we are going to sit down to dinner. But the shock is palpable, the sadness genuine and the determination to vote tomorrow: 110% – yes 110%.

  • dfh

    Thank you Joe Klien. You left me in tears.

  • newfloridian

    Tom in the Swamp:

    If that is true they are neither evil or pure evil. They are just a reminder of how small the Republican Party has beome. Hope it is well covered by all the press.

  • tyrantking

    It is as though God said, “What does Obama need me to do to clench this election for him?”

  • http://pourmecoffee.blogspot.com pourmecoffee

    The strategy, the message, the ground game … all well done by Obama and staff. The deep well of calm and considered judgment that resonated so profoundly with the American people and won him this election — everyone who has ever been a child knows from where such stuff comes.

  • pneogy

    “And now, there is a sense that tomorrow will be the sort of day none of us ever forgets, one way or another–a day of reckoning, in the purest sense, when we will suddenly see ourselves and our country differently, for good or ill.”

    Indeed. And let’s ask ourselves why each one of our yesterdays of the past years have been so forgettable.

  • ivb3016

    I’m so sorry she didn’t live to see him become President, but I’m sure she knew from him it was all but certain.
    .
    How disgusting for the RNC. Of course, not a surprise. Yet another reason to not be a Repub. Is there any reason he could not have taken the plane and reimbursed the campaign? How about all the time Johnny Mac spent on Cindy’s plane during the primaries?

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    Thanks Joe — for remarking on the largeness of all of this. I know I’m not alone when I say that my anger at the antics of the McCain campaign islargely because they participated in a manor that suggests they didn’t understand or respect how big this thing really is. I can’t imagine the loss he must feel at not havng her to witness this historic moment.

  • heckslittlestangel

    Very well said. Thank you.

  • bbpdx

    She’ll be watching along side his grandfather, at peace.

  • sgwhiteinfla

    Joe Klein,
    .
    First thank you for the post about Obama losing his grandmother. But I want to ask that you or someone on the Swampland roster expose the kinds of stuff that is said on right wing blogs. All this campaign season there have been false equivalencies given to explain away bad behavior by people at McCain-Palin rallys and to explain away some of the stuff that McCain surrogates have said. A frequent target of these false equivalencies is DailyKos.com. Now I blog at DailyKos and I can tell you that every once in a while commentors there get over the top. But never to the extent that I have seen on a regular basis at websites like redstate.org and freerepublic.com. I just ask that you read some of the comments on this post at freerepublic.com and if it sickens you as much as it sickens me then the next time you hear a conservative/republican complain about dailykos you cut them off and point to this WingNut site. I wish there was a way to expose the people behind these posts so their true nature can be seen by the public at large.
    .

    http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2123979/posts

  • davemc321

    I grew up in small towns on the Texas Gulf Coast. My lingering memories are of sweltering heat and shopping trips to Houston with my mother. I still remember the Colored Only water fountains, which my horrified mother wouldn’t let me drink from even though it was closer. It never made sense to me, not even then. Water is water.

    On Friday, I voted for for a black man for president, something I was certain would never happen in my lifetime. It is that strength of character, calm deliberation and intelligence that got my vote — characteristics clearly inculcated from childhood and the wise woman who raised him. Godspeed, Ms. Dunham.

  • kevpvp

    Well said, Joe.

  • JennOfArk

    When I signed on and saw this news on my homepage, I was just heartbroken. How sad – for both Obama and his grandmother – that she did not live to see tomorrow.

  • Ohg Rea Tone

    We live in rural Missouri and we knows what you means. Most of the folks around here is tight knit – but some of the young folks went off to college and come back with a different look and different talk. It was good cause one of them started the Newspaper here. …………

    http://thefiresidepost.com/2008/11/03/redneck-gazette-obama-uses-common-sense/

  • lafloran

    beautiful. thank you for saying it for me.

  • davemc321

    sg, I understand your anger. Those sites — and I’d add LGF and Pammycakes’ to the list of hateful rightwing spew — make you feel unclean in the reading.

    They remind me of the kind of stuff in publications once found wet in the gutter or distributed by pale, narrow creatures in bus stations that attacked anything good, decent and clean. Until the internet made all thoughts available instantly, most of us never saw this stuff. Sometimes I fear it threatens to drive out the good.

  • http://whatnot.bombdotcom.net/ John D. Moore

    Nicely said, Joe. Through his first book, I came to have a great deal of respect for Ms. Dunham. She seemed like one hell of a woman, and the love between her and her grandson was deep. She must have been too proud for words.

  • formerlyrainbow68

    I’m so sorry to hear this! I was so hoping she’d make it to see him elected. At least she knew the position he’s in now. She did a great job supporting him and helping to make him the man he is today.

  • http://thefiresidepost.com/2008/11/03/to-the-mountaintop/ To The Mountaintop – The Fireside Post

    [...] Read Full Post Here Book Mark it-> del.icio.us | Reddit | Slashdot | Digg | Facebook | Technorati | Google | StumbleUpon | Window Live | Tailrank | Furl | Netscape | Yahoo | BlinkList Tags: grandmother, Joe, Klein, mountaintop, Obama, prejudice, Time [...]

  • sharkfin

    it is very sad that none of his parents and parents surrogate will witness the fruits of their labor of love in raising him..but then it is said, “parents are like Moses.” ” they prepare and take you to the promised land even if they themselves will not be able to reach it”.
    congratulations, Ms. Dunham, for a work well done!

  • Jarrod Myrick

    Thanks, Joe.

  • indybikehiker

    Well said, Joe. Thanks for framing the larger perspective. Even as I stare digustingly at one more hate-mail full of falsehoods from some unidentifiable source feverishly forwarded to me by fear-full fellow evangelical Christians (so-called), I wonder what these all-but anonymous rumor-mongerers might say of Madelyn’s passing? Where’s the grace?

  • Larry

    Thank you, Joe. I’ve appreciated your work and perspective throughout this election cycle. I feel this loss as I think of my own parents, and my heart joins davemc321 in wishing “Godspeed, Ms. Dunham.” And Godspeed Barack & Michelle, regardless of the outcome tomorrow.

  • pbr

    Will the folks who are trying to pivot off this post into a partisan agenda realize what a tin ear they are demonstrating? I’ve had a lot of problems with Joe Klein’s work in the recent past, vis a vis FISA and a dozen other things. But these words of his are uncommonly graceful, and emotionally beautiful. They deserve a little space in the clearing, away from the noise.

    Thanks for your eloquence Mr. Klein. It stopped me in my tracks today, and deepened my appreciation of the man who stands on the verge of the Presidency.

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    SG –
    .
    I understand why you want to bring attention to the rightwing nuts so that we can end this ridiculous homage to false equivalencies.
    .
    But you should have added a stronger warning label because I could have gone the rest of my life quite nicely never knowing human beings could spew such venom.

  • kathy

    Thank you for saying this Joe. I know that it is very very different to expect someone you love to die, and to have it happen. But it’s also true that he’s now free from the pain he had for her pain, and because of the particular things he has said about his faith, I think he believes that she is with him.

  • http://www.str33tcouture.com Lola

    Great article. It’s a bitter sweet moment….a sad day for the loss of his grandmother, but a sweet victory come tomorrow night.

  • James Lawrence

    Well done, Joe. Poignant without being mawkish. In other words, sincere and heartfelt. Thank you.

    I’m surprised to find I feel a touch of grief myself. With all the people in the world to care for, that this young man somehow reached into my heart with his simple American story and made me feel for his family is testimony to the power, truth and intimacy of his candidacy.

    What difficult timing, though, for Obama, on this eve of probably the greatest day of his life, to lose this wonderful woman who meant so much to him.

    Likewise for his wife, and their children, who have lost their great grandmother. A sad day and I, as I am sure millions of people around the world, offer his family sincere condolences.

    And God bless and keep this woman who did such a fine job with a difficult challengem raising a black child in a world that still has a long, long way to go toward racial harmony.

  • Terrapinion

    How crushingly sad for Obama and his family.

    How utterly sickening of the RNC.

  • Karl (Australia)

    Beautifully written Joe. My condolences and sympathies to the Obama family.
    I have been watching this election for the last year or so from my small town here in Australia. I think the whole world is awaiting to hear the results of tomorrows election. As most of us, even on the other side of the world, are effected by how the results pan out. Hopefully the winds of change will be blowing strongly in the USA tomorrow!

  • bryanfromhouston

    Joe, in a word, exceptional. You are a class act unlike some on the other side of the aisle. I am struck by the tinge of sadness within my heart. I feel like I have lost my very own grandmother…it is amazing the connection that one can make in such a short time. RIP Madelyn and God bless Obama and his family in their moment of loss.

  • nibblybits

    Yesterday was the NYC Marathon. 39,000 runners. It’s one of the best things about living in this city, because the residents are so good about lining all 26 miles through 5 boroughs, braving the cold like we did yesterday, to cheer on the fastest, the slowest and everyone in between. I’ve volunteered or cheered this race for almost 20 years.
    .
    Yesterday, I stood, with some friends, with a big Obama sign on a stick in one hand and a cow bell in the other. We stood at mile 7, in the stretch up 4th Avenue in Brooklyn, when the runners are still happy and fresh, then we jump on the subway to get to mile 22, up in Harlem, when the runners are hitting the wall, cramping, bleeding and hobbled with pain.
    .
    Though every year I usually have a big sign, my Obama sign got the biggest reaction I’ve ever received. Runners threw up their fists or their arms yelling “Obama” or “Yes We Can”. Many pointed to their Obama shirts or the bumper sticker on their bodies. Some stopped to take photos. People of all colors and stripes. So many from other countries with their shirts labeled ‘France’ or ‘Italy’ or ‘Australia’. The joyfulness was tremendous. And it wasn’t just at mile 7 when the race was still a party. At mile 22, as many were shuffling towards the finish, grimaces pulling at their faces, they still managed to raise a fist and call out an “Obama”. There’s just something about this election that is really special, and it’s amazing to me how engaged everyone is. And we are shouting it with signs and wearing it on our shirts and finding solidarity with others who are looking for change, and we’re hopeful again.
    .
    I’ve already got my alarm clock set for early tomorrow morning.

  • Barbara J Battle

    Obama’s grandmother has finished her work on earth…and with such great results. Rest in Peace, Mrs Dunham “Toots”

    Thanks Joe

  • O

    She only left him at a point when he is about to become the most powerful person on earth…

  • sgwhiteinfla

    Dee,
    .
    I am truly sorry but I did want there to be a shock factor, not for you but for Joe Klein should he happen to read this blog. I want him to see what false equivalencies really look like. I want him to know what kind of filth resides in the republican party and in the conservative brand. I want him to see why people bring up race and how it is affecting this election and how its NOT just playing some mythical race card. I wanted him to know for himself just how much worse the whackjobs on the right are than those on the left that he won’t possibly ever let that kind of false equivalency happen again.
    .
    I apologize again Dee but I hope you understand my intent

  • cj from minn

    SOME OF THE BEST MEN IN THE WORLD COME FROM THE STRONGEST WOMEN IN THE WORLD.

    SHE MAINTIANED LIKE MICHELLE DOES, THAT A GREAT MAN MUST LEARN HIS WAY BY UNDERSTANDING LIFES LESSON WHICH INCLUDE >>TRUTH>>INTEGRITY>>FORTITUDE>>>POWER>>POISE>>>HUMBLENESS>>> AND GRACE.

    SOME OF THESE MAN LEARNS ON HIS OWN BUT MOST COME FROM A STRONG WOMAN

    MAY SHE REST IN PEACE AND PRIDE

  • http://www.czelticgirl.com/?p=1893 RIP, Toot | Czeltic Girl

    [...] Klein has a very well-written post on the death of Obama’s grandmother, Madelyn [...]

  • JJ

    Very well put, Joe. Condolences to Barack Obama’s family. I hope he finds some peace of mind in all the tumult of the next few days…

  • singlemomvoting

    This breaks my heart for Barack and his sister. His grandmother did not have very much time left and they all knew that but how very sad that she will not see tomorrow and the goal. I pray for this family because it is so hard to lose anyone who means so much.
    I know this is a political forum but I am truly glad that the people who write these editorials maintain their humanity. I am glad that someone finally brought out the unspoken achievement. People don’t like to remember how much of a social stigma it would have been for Mrs. Dunham and for the young boy. I remember; my high school friend was the only black girl in my high school. I am glad my children live in a better society and my grandchildren are going to have even better than this.
    I pray her family finds peace and comfort in the future knowing that she has contributed to it even though she is not here to see.

  • Chris
  • http://swampland newfloridian

    Condolences to the Obama family. She did her job very, very well and we should all thank her for her magnificent skills in raising a grandson that will change America. .

  • http://rochesterturning.com TomT

    I’ve got to think there’s some way that Salter and Schmidt can turn this into an attack on Obama.

    I hope I’m wrong.

  • MyAudacity

    My condolences to the Obama family. The impact she has on his life will be greater after death than when she was alive. Speaking from personal experience, the things long forgotten will become more pronounced memories, and I pray that tomorrow, he can smile and say Toot, yes we did!

  • http://www.metafilter.com/76220/Obamas-grandmother-dies-hours-before-the-election Obama’s grandmother dies hours before the election | MetaFilter

    [...] election. Madelyn Lee Payne "Toot" Dunham, 86, died of cancer, Obama and his sister say. The timing is ridiculous. He saw her last last week, knowing she was failing. The Free Republicans are already calling for [...]

  • mchampion

    I posted a few minutes ago on KT’s comment that his grandmother’s work here on earth was done – she helped raise an extraordinary young man and I’d like to think she went knowing that he will be our next President.

    Last week I flew to TN to vote – I didn’t want an absentee ballot – I wanted the pleasure of standing in line and filling out the form and watching the machine register my choice. I also wanted the perverse pleasure of being the only person in Roane County to vote for Obama. As I left I realized I would not have that pleasure; there were 5 young African Americans going through the metal detectors as I left. Mt first thought was “I didn’t realize that ANY African Americans lived in Roane County” and the second was “God bless them”. This is the first election in my 47 years that has ever inspired me to this degree (and I was the nerd who faked sick so I could watch Nixon be inaugurated in 1968) and it has inspired so many others who became disillusioned and lost hope and never believed that it could be anything better. That the US could never be anything better.

    Tomorrow will be better and we will never be the same.

    RIP Toots, you’ve earned it. And thank you.

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    SG — Oh I get it and I’m not mad at you. I just wanted to make sure you knew that I found these remarks as despicable as you. Joe and the rest of the country should be aware of the depravity that’s holding up this party. To tell you the truth I think that’s the reason we are seeing so many establishment Republicans jumping ship. I think they believe that this is their opportunity to purge the party of this element and many of the more moderate Republicans don’t even know it exists. At this point I think we need to come up with a new name for them because wingnuts sounds too endearing a nick name for what these posters really are. These posts are way too vile just to chalk it up to nuttery.

  • kleeks

    My grandmother served as mother to me and my 4 siblings as my mother went to work everyday. This is one of the many reasons I support Obama. He knows first hand what it is like to grow up in a family that sacrifices and works together. So bittersweet the timing, but I know, that today, the Catholic Feast of All Souls, she is looking down and watching her son become our next president!!! Thanks Joe for the lovely tribute.

  • gysgt213

    Obama had tears in his eyes just now in first speech since grandmother died.

  • http://www.mutanteggplant.com/vitro-nasu/2008/11/03/trisha-brown-and-blue-kaipoi/ Vitro Nasu » Blog Archive » Trisha Brown, and Blue Kaipoi

    [...] Madelyn Dunham (Obama’s Grandmother) – To the Mountaintop – Joe [...]

  • freeenterprisechic

    To the Mountaintop? Is that suppose to be a comparison to Moses?

    And tomorrow is a day of reckoning for good or ill?

    Please stop drinking the Kool – Aid and making a sham of your journalism profession.

  • Lisa

    This almost Shakespearian in its tragedy. This is so heartbreaking. She was the last one left of all people who raised him and to die the day before the election…words cannot describe it. The hate on the right wing blogs is horrific. They are accusing him of timing her death- even for the nightly news. They are sick hateful people- THE PALIN PEOPLE are the sick ones. Good riddence to them.

    The GOP even filed suit against Obama today for using his campaign plane to visit her last week before she died. Of course, they all accused him of nefarious conduct back then too. SICK SICK SICK. Get rid of the HATERS and that includes Sarah Palin- the leader of the HATE!

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    To the Mountaintop? Is that suppose to be a comparison to Moses?

    Bring it down a notch it was a reference to a Martin Luther King speech. My God why have you let your politics strip you of your humanity.

  • Dave, New Zealand

    We in the world are watching with baited breath, sensing a positive turning point for America. We see a new dawn arriving not just for Americans, but for the entire world. A new era where prejudice and bully boy aggression are replaced with empathy and inclusion and goodwill. An era where material and monetary greed are replaced by family and personal values as the measure of success in all of our lives. R.I.P Ms Dunham, and thankyou for moulding such a real and grounded human being, a true leader. His time is now.

  • http://pourmecoffee.blogspot.com pourmecoffee

    “To the Mountaintop? Is that suppose to be a comparison to Moses?” Dangerous unselfishness.

  • Jerrica Benton

    As someone who was also raised by grandparents my heart just breaks for Obama and his family.

  • sgwhiteinfla

    freeenterprisechic Says:
    To the Mountaintop? Is that suppose to be a comparison to Moses?

    And tomorrow is a day of reckoning for good or ill?

    Please stop drinking the Kool – Aid and making a sham of your journalism profession.
    …………………………………………………..
    How about you drink a big glass of SHUT THE PHUCK UP! Go find a rock to climb under you phucking loser!!!

  • sgwhiteinfla

    freeenterprisechic Says:
    To the Mountaintop? Is that suppose to be a comparison to Moses?

    And tomorrow is a day of reckoning for good or ill?

    Please stop drinking the Kool – Aid and making a sham of your journalism profession.
    …………………………………………………..
    How about you drink a big gla$$ of SHUT THE PHUCK UP! Go find a rock to climb under you phucking loser!!!

  • Shannon O’Connor Smith

    I’m thankful he took the time away from the campaign to spend a few quiet hours with her. It speaks to his character that nothing, not even getting elected president, would stop him from flying all the way home to be with her. I am so proud of him. I know that she will be watching from the heavens tomorrow.

  • sputnik

    The freerepublican people are sick. Just sick. I don’t really understand how you could spew such hate and still claim to be Christian.

  • readinwritin

    Dear America,

    The world loves you–truly it does. We have missed you so much these last few years. They have been hard on us and hard on you, too.

    But we want the America we have always admired back. Without you, the world is adrift.

    Whatever some of you think of Barack Obama in Berlin, Americans should feel proud that only an American could draw a crowd like that in Europe.

    Astride that stage and with lit by the sun, Obama embodied the moral force of the American dream. And Europe and the world knelt before it.

    For non-Americans, this was our only chance to show you how very much it matters what you do.

    As you enter the polling booth tomorrow, remember that you carry our hopes and dreams for the future with you. God bless.

    Signed,

    The World

  • hickoryduck

    My only hope for humanity is that everyone who posts at FreeRepublic is struck by lightning.

  • http://jonorato42.wordpress.com/ John O

    Thanks, Joe.

    This turn of events is unspeakably, terribly sad.

    I was very close to my Grandparents. It’s awfully easy to relate for me.

    May she rest in peace.

  • basilbrush

    If the parent is measured by the child, Toot must have been a marvel. Rest in peace.

  • http://Time.com Cathie B

    Please pass this along to the Obama family….
    Our hearts go out to you at this time of your
    loss. Please accept our sincere condolences.
    My son is biracial and spent two years with his
    white grandmother – somewhat similar to your
    experience, Senator Obama. We remember the good,
    laugh at the “odd”, and know she loved my son
    most of all in her life.

    Peace be with you and all who mourn your gramdmother.

    Cathie & Eric Brown

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    And now, there is a sense that tomorrow will be the sort of day none of us ever forgets, one way or another–a day of reckoning, in the purest sense, when we will suddenly see ourselves and our country differently, for good or ill.

    Thank you for in both this post and the one before for noting just how momentous this occasion is, no matter who wins tomorrow.

  • Matt

    Joe, you’re more than a little fawning with this. But I can’t deny that this is very historic and Obama is a remarkable candidate. But lay off the over-the-top stuff…

    http://www.political-buzz.com/

  • liz

    Thank-you for a beautiful article. I truly believe that his grandma, mother and grandfather will be watching tomorrow and will have reason to smile in heaven.

  • Casey Morris

    These is a tough day for Barack, and the timing explains why he was so emotional at the end of his speech this morning. It was his first speech after her death. A couple of hours later Michelle spoke at a different event in a different state. She spoke with such quietude and tenderness in her voice, a sort of softness that I haven’t heard before. She is always kind and strong, but there was such a tender and nurturing quality to today, I felt her connect on a whole other level.
    _
    Even through the sadness, it’s clear to see that they are both leading with their hearts, and from a strength that has such a deeply connected personal quality to it. A quiet courage.
    _
    It is odd to think of him moving forward into the election and the future it portends, with no parents, or grandparents to bear witness. At some point, it will strike him that he is an orphan. And that will be a profound moment of emotional finality. A final untethering from childhood into the completeness of adulthood.
    _
    It’s hard, but it’s also can have it’s liberating moments as well. You get to embrace the role of adulthood in a way that you don’t while you still have a parent/primary caregiver living. If you are blessed, as Obama was with Toot, you have a rich array of choices in deciding how you want to shape the memory book of your life together, and how you want to pass the story-telling and narrate that relationship for your own children, so that relationship lives in them also. For it is also true, that as long as Barack is alive, Too will never be dead, for she lives on in every detail, every experience, every memory, every kiss, every hug, every pat on the head or swat on the behind. And his children will bear witness to that love. He is blessed to have them and they will help heal him.
    _
    I went from having two parents to being an orphan in five months. I remember thinking to myself, thank god I am a parent. I don’t know how people without children do it. They give you a clear vision of how to move forward, and that, in fact, you must. You see in front of you the continuity of life, and that is a great comfort.
    _
    I hope Barack and his family are comforted by the love and presence of one another during this difficult time. If you believe in God and heaven, and just rewards, then I hope that the Obama’s are comforted by Toot’s joyous home-going, into the arms of God, and her being reunited with her beloved daughter Ann, who left this earth much too soon, and much too quickly.
    _
    All growth is full of shock, change, joy, laughter, tears, freedom, responsibility and opportunity. Death, is a part of growth, and in Obama’s case, as has been the case his whole life, this change is destined to be too big to be contemplated at once, and it will no doubt be writ large upon the soul.
    _
    I wish them all peace and love.
    _
    With our prayers,
    _
    Casey

  • Dee in Columbia MD

    Matt Says:
    Monday, November 3, 2008 at 7:19 pm
    Joe, you’re more than a little fawning with this.

    What is so over the top for a journalist, in his position as a first responder to history, remarks on the grand scope of this moment in time. Frankly, it is so demeaning to relegate this momentous occasion to being over the top. stop thinking about winners and losers and the impact of this on your own small life. And start reflecting on where your country has been, where it is now, and the possibilities of where it will be going and then ask yourself how will you answer your grandchildren when they look up from their history text books and ask you for a first hand account of what it was like? Oh I know — you’ll say it was no big deal right?

  • formerlyrainbow68

    Paul Dirks: Beautifully put. I couldn’t agree with you more.

  • Casey Morris

    Freenterprisechic: It’s an MLK, Jr. reference. Get an education or get some xanax.

  • Casey Morris

    Joe,

    Free your commenters from their prison of moderation.

    We beg of thee.

    Signed,

    People who write more than three sentences per post.

  • Nancy

    Thank you, Joe, for a lovely tribute to Madeleine Dunham. But hickoryduck — let’s take a page from Obama’s book, and start thinking about unity. That is what has inspired me so much about this campaign — we really can come together as Americans. That means we have to look beyond those angry, ugly words, and start building the country together again. Some of those people who are spewing hate may stop and join us. but we cannot start hating them back.

  • http://blogs.crikey.com.au/us08/2008/11/04/joe-the-journalist-on-toot/ Joe the Journalist on Toot – US Election 2008

    [...] Klein on Time’s Swampland has blogged a poignant response to the news of Obama’s grandmother’s [...]

  • shinealighton

    Supper post, Joe. Thanks a million

  • sgwhiteinfla

    Matt Says:
    Monday, November 3, 2008 at 7:19 pm
    Joe, you’re more than a little fawning with this. But I can’t deny that this is very historic and Obama is a remarkable candidate. But lay off the over-the-top stuff…

    http://www.political-buzz.com/
    ………………………………………

    If you dont like it, dont read it a$$hole

  • singlemomvoting

    Just read the Huffington Post and put up my own post as follows:
    Incredible that the RNC could not resist one last knife.
    Actually, you hatemongers, I am glad you gave in and I hope EVERYONE in America knows about this before they go to the polls so they will know what low life greedy sob’s you really are.
    Your incredible lack of decency leaves me shocked and I did not think you could get any worse.
    By the way; if every penny of my small contribution to the Obama/Biden campaign went into paying for that trip then I am happy because it means that I helped do something nice for that lovely woman. Worth that and the same amount again.
    Crawl back into your hole you horrible people!!!

  • annie ellis

    Thanks Joe, very keen insight. very well said.

  • Tom in The Swamp

    ivb3016 asked:
    Is there any reason he could not have taken the plane and reimbursed the campaign?
    .
    In fact, the RNC/McCain campaign has no idea whether or not Obama reimbursed the campaign, and they won’t know until the campaign makes its filing for October, which isn’t required to happen until November 20. They don’t know, and they don’t care; they just wanted to throw one more big ball of mud in his face the day before the election, knowing that it would fool a few idiots.
    .
    Any doubts you may have about that being their intention will be dispelled immediately upon reading their own press release.
    .
    It should not go unnoticed that the Obama campaign, by withholding their announcement of the news they had received early in the morning until the end of the day, wisely invited the Republicans to make themselves look like heartless animals on the Evening News tonight, and the Republicans were more than eager to oblige.

  • Clair Peers

    Well Done Joe
    My condolences to the Obama family. It is difficult to imagine how Barack Obama must feel at this critical time in his life. I (& Friends) have watched the events of this campaign unfold from another part of this continent, Nova Scotia Canada.

    The results of this election seem as important us, your neighbours as they are to the American people. A glance at the previous elections in America makes this one look like the most important one in all American History. Everything here in Canada is so reliant & driven by the US economy, policys etc etc. The outcome of this election is so very important to us. We wish the Obama campaign all the best.
    Sincerely
    Your friends in Canada

  • Mark

    I am sure Obama will be fine after his grandam passed away. He is fine with his brother and aunt living in sqaller. ANd, I mour her passing as I would mourn anyone’s passing. And, Obama is bigger than life to whom?

  • 53_3

    sg:
    .
    Your posts echo what I’ve been saying here for the past two years:
    .
    What is even more interesting is, that I and some of the other Swamp critters here watched and possibly even played a role in Joe’s evolution from a kneejerk wingnut to a thoughtful Republican.
    .
    That breed is rare at this moment, and Joe and others, after this election, are going to have to take up the fight to retake their own party.
    .
    I think there should always be an opposition to the establishment, and as sure as anything, we will have our turn, and the new reconstituted GOP will have to serve as the balance checking us from committing excesses. That guy who said that ‘absolute power corrupts absolutely’ was right.
    .
    Right now, we do need that type of power, because the GOP is not a rational balance, it’s an instrument of hate. But afterwards?
    .
    There is going to be a need for a new GOP, and unless they want someone like Palin driving into the fringe, they will need people like Joe!
    .
    We are all gonna make history!

  • centfan

    It’s weird how the wingnuts always come back to the “Messiah” comparison. I’ve never heard the most drooling Liberal with a capital L ever describe Obama that way. Perhaps the right wing is missing something from their lives… something they lost trying to crush the people under them while they fight their way to the top… after they screamed “Fire” in the crowded theater.

    I can believe Obama had a clear picture of his grandmother’s condition when he visited her. I’m sure she had a clear picture of his success. This was a terrible turn, but Obama was prepared as he will be prepared for anything that faces this country.

  • http://www.djheavyd.com/scratch/ Dave Otto

    Nicely said Mr. Klein. The timing seems almost cruel in some regards. I’m not sure why, morbid curiosity I guess, but I browsed the comments on the Michelle Malkin website to see the reaction. Wow. Deeply disturbing to say the least. Depraved in many ways.
    I’m a conservative voting for Obama. See why: http://www.djheavyd.com/scratch/2008/11/repost-voting-reason/
    What’s your voting reason? http://votingreason.com

  • mr albany

    How very sad. If only she could have made it one more day but hopefully now she is at least free of pain and I hope the stress of seeing her grandson in a presidential campaign didn’t contribute at all to her health faltering.

  • mr albany

    my condolences obviously to the president elect and future first family

  • GodBlessBarack

    I will be voting tomorrow for the best man, Barack Obama, to become President of this great nation.
    I know his Grandmother is with him and watching over him. May history show that America is still a forward moving leader by the choice its citizens will make tomorrow…

  • hickoryduck

    And also, the “mountaintop” line is most likely an MLK reference.
    -
    “I’ve been to the mountaintop, and I’ve seen the Promised Land,”

  • Marc Schulz

    The timing indeed is ridiculous. She died Sunday and the announcement came Monday. The announcement was released Monday so their is a larger outreach via television during the evening newscasts. She was supposed to have a broken hip and then she died from cancer. With all my basic medical knowledge it is impossible to suffer from cancer by having a broken hip. That is exactly how Barack Obama lies. May she rest in peace. Now Obama might get sympathy votes from the retirees and elder people.

  • Aoede

    She ALREADY had cancer, you ignorant, hateful twit.

  • piper1

    Money post from the Freeper link:

    “What does it say about Obama that many many of us didn’t believe for a moment that the woman was really at death’s door.”

    What does it say about you? Seriously.

    What is it in Obama’s past that would lead even an extremist to believe this? Considering the weakness of the kitchen sink of arguments the GOP has thrown at Obama, it is hard to believe he has some atrocious hidden secret like running a stop sign and killing someone or his family having profited illegally from trade with the Nazis.

  • 53_3

    Well, Marc Schulz:
    .
    You’re just going to have to hide your hate in smokey basements, worshipping child molesters and cultists like David Koresh.
    .
    Don’t forget jail-cell etiquette in your efforts to be heard…

  • http://hillblogger3.blogspot.com Anne de Brux

    A great piece Mr Klein… thank you.

  • Marc Schulz

    It was sold in the media, that she only had a broken hip – nothing more. That is the ridiculous thing that the media suggested a minor suffering (broken rip) which was in fact from the start a major suffering (cancer).

  • http://www.breakfreetoday.info Terri

    What an incredibly sad day! To miss seeing her grandson become president by one days seems terribly unjust. Thank you for the great article, Mr. Klein.

    I, too, would like know what you think of the RNC filing a complaint against Barack for going to see his dying grandmother. Can they stoop to any lower tactics????

    http://voices.washingtonpost.com/the-trail/2008/11/03/california_gop_files_fec_compl.html

  • sgwhiteinfla

    Marc Schulz Says:
    Monday, November 3, 2008 at 8:11 pm
    The timing indeed is ridiculous. She died Sunday and the announcement came Monday. The announcement was released Monday so their is a larger outreach via television during the evening newscasts. She was supposed to have a broken hip and then she died from cancer. With all my basic medical knowledge it is impossible to suffer from cancer by having a broken hip. That is exactly how Barack Obama lies. May she rest in peace. Now Obama might get sympathy votes from the retirees and elder people.
    “”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”
    You Phucking idiot she passed over night. Go back to watching kiddie p0rn jack a$$. This is the grown folks section

  • Mad As Hell

    This news is so unbearably poignant. I believe that she was lucky to pass away after she knew he was going to win but I so wished she could have seen his victory speech. At least she is no longer in any pain. That has to bring him some relief.
    -
    And let’s not forget that as soon as he wins, Barack Obama will have the weight of the world on his shoulders. At least he will know that Toot is at peace and not in pain.

  • Ian in WI

    My heart goes out to the Obamas.
    I just read dome of the stuff being written in the off-the-far-right-grid leaning blogs and I felft sick to my stomach.
    I can understand the heated dirty nature of politics and the lies, insults, misinterpretations, misrepresantations that go with it.
    But some of the innuendos and suggestion of these blogs are way off base!!! Inhuman is what I’d call them.
    I was undecided on this election, but after reading these blogs, ya’ll helped me make up my mind. It’s not a sympathy vote, it’s a protest vote.
    These folks are not helping their course by some of their vile blogs.

    That said, my heart and prayers go to the Obama family.
    I am sure Toot, her husband and her daughter will be watching with a smile on with their faces.

  • Ian in WI

    My heart goes out to the Obamas.
    I just read dome of the stuff being written in the off-the-far-right-grid leaning blogs and I felft sick to my stomach.
    I can understand the heated dirty nature of politics and the lies, insults, misinterpretations, misrepresantations that go with it.
    But some of the innuendos and suggestion of these blogs are way off base!!! Inhuman is what I’d call them.
    I was undecided on this election, but after reading these blogs, ya’ll helped me make up my mind. It’s not a sympathy vote, it’s a protest vote.
    These folks are not helping their course by some of their vile blogs.

    That said, my heart and prayers go to the Obama family.
    I am sure Toot, her husband, their daughter and Obama Sr. will be watching with a smile on with their faces.

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    It’s nice of Mr Schulz to remind everyone as to WHY McCain is doing so poorly. There are narrow but nevertheless important lines between what is considerred to be decent behavior and what is considerred appalling. McCain, aided by his more fervent supporters has crossed the line and simply appalled too many people.

  • singlemomvoting

    To Marc Shulz—
    Your medical knowledge has you bass ackwards…Mrs. Dunham was a cancer patient before the broken hip, which was caused by complications from cancer. I have been unfortunate enough to read some of the slime spilling out of the internet about all of this. It just makes me sick and I refuse to let it shut me up tonight. Shame on you for attempting to say that this woman’s illness or death were a political ploy. What do you imply here? That they are hiding her in the basement and pretending she is dead? You join the ranks, and I mean rank of jerks over this really sad day for a family. What a putz.

  • james

    Joe, I add my compliments to the others for your poignant post.

  • pierogielunaire (formerly superterrificdelegate)

    Thank you, Joe. We all owe Madelyn Dunham a debt of gratitude.

  • fourlegsgood

    Mark Schultz, please feel free to f**k off and die.
    .
    You are a despicable human being. Seriously.
    .
    And Joe, thank you for the lovely post.

  • jarais

    Marc Schulz,
    What’s wrong with you? A broken hip is often a death sentence for people that age.

    And what fourlegsgood said.

  • sgwhiteinfla

    This was stuck in mods from earlier
    .
    sgwhiteinfla Says: Your comment is awaiting moderation.
    Monday, November 3, 2008 at 8:27 pm
    Marc Schulz Says:
    Monday, November 3, 2008 at 8:11 pm
    The timing indeed is ridiculous. She died Sunday and the announcement came Monday. The announcement was released Monday so their is a larger outreach via television during the evening newscasts. She was supposed to have a broken hip and then she died from cancer. With all my basic medical knowledge it is impossible to suffer from cancer by having a broken hip. That is exactly how Barack Obama lies. May she rest in peace. Now Obama might get sympathy votes from the retirees and elder people.
    “”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”"”
    You Phucking idiot she pa$$ed over night. Everyone but your dumb a$$ knew she had cancer BEFORE she fell. When have you ever heard of someone dying over their hip dumb phuck? Go back to watching kiddie p0rn jack a$$. This is the grown folks section

  • grandsophy

    I’m heartbroken for Barrack Obama – he had to lose her at such a time but at any time it would be awful. Strength to Obama famiily and gratitude to Madelyn Dunham for her bravery so many years ago has given us this extraordinary leader today. I am so sad though. Puts everything in perspective.

  • davis2350

    Marc Schulz, as of tomorrow you’re what our country used to be. It’s over for you and I know you’re not going quietly but you’re going all the same. Trust that. Most people don’t hate like that anymore. Good luck acting this way in public, in mixed company. Times…they are a changin’, huh?

  • http://timlauer.org/2008/11/03/swampland-timecom-%c2%bb-blog-archive-to-the-mountaintop-%c2%ab/ timlauer.org » Swampland – TIME.com » Blog Archive To The Mountaintop «

    [...] Swampland – TIME.com » Blog Archive To The Mountaintop « Shared by timlauer Joe Klein’s post about Obama’s grandmother… Found it touching and inspiring… [...]

  • carotexas1

    KT thank you for the last update. I know he will have a lot to do but this is really something I feel we need, to have qualified in home help for the elderly to give them some dignity and able to stay at home. This will also help family’s with the burden of the care.
    My parents in Australia were able to have this and able to stay in the home they loved till they passed away this year.

  • http://www.telikompng.com.pg Corney ALONE

    This is really sad………tears…..tears…tears…

    It would have been nice for the grandma who lived through public sneering, abuse and intimidations to see/realise in person the fruits of her labour in seeing her grandson (Obama) sworn into the White House – the most powerful office on earth….tears….tears.

    I am 100 % convinced that Barack’s grandma’s death at this crucial time will tilt the 5% undecided voters in Obama’s favour.

    He will win BIG TIME.

    Papua New Guinean OBAMA Fan
    Port Moresby, Pacific Ocean

  • carotexas1

    Sorry wrong thread.
    Love your thoughts Joe.

  • Aoede

    Actually, there will always be hate, ignorance, and petty-mindedness. All we can hope is that more people in positions of responsibility grow away from that trend.

  • http://pourmecoffee.blogspot.com pourmecoffee
  • oizydoizy

    RIP Madelyn Payne Dunham. You raised one hell of a kid.

  • ivb3016

    nibblybits, thanks for your story of the NY marathon and your sign and the response at both points. Another tribute.

  • Joe Bftsplk

    Win or lose, Barack Obama would make his mother and granparents proud.
    Would that all candidates did so.

  • southernbell49

    Well said, Joe.

    My heartfelt condolensces to Sen Obama and his family.

  • http://blog.amber.org/2008/11/03/the-promised-land/ The Promised Land at Pensieri di un lunatico minore

    [...] news of Madelyn Dunham’s passing hit me harder than any death of a stranger has before. Not only have I, like many others, invested [...]

  • pseudonymous in NC

    Passing the torch. When you lose parents or grandparents, it brings home the responsibilities you take on as a parent or spouse. When you look at Obama and his family, it’s pretty clear that being a good father to his daughters matters viscerally more than anything he accomplishes in politics.

    And I think Ta-Nehisi Coates summed it up well:

    “…today, let us speak of people who were ahead of their times, who were outside of their times. Let us remember that Barack Obama learned the great lessons of life from courageous white people. Let us speak of those who do what normal, right people should always do when faced with a child–commit an act love. Here’s to doing the right thing.”

    http://ta-nehisicoates.theatlantic.com/archives/2008/10/i_hope_this_is_in_good_taste.php

  • formerlyrainbow68

    He’s a wonderful husband and father. Such a good role model.

  • Amy

    May her memory be a blessing to the Obama family.

  • Pat

    Thank you Joe Klein for your beautiful ,human piece.Yes , your country will be different tomorrow. Yes , the world will be too. Yes we the rest of the world will be holding our breath and praying for you all tomorrow , so you are as brave as in MLK times, when as a kid I ,far away ,was a silent witness of your epic struggle , when many of you were willing to risk your lives for justice to be done, when you were known for being a generous ,and bright country,that was stepping into the moon for all of us . I am one of those far south in this world, finis terrae land , that has had the fortune to meet, being helped and be friends with great american hearts , for many years . Down here my first teacher was a lovely not-too-young american lady that had the strange idea of funding a bilingual school as far away from home as posible. Thanks to her I am writing to you in your language today, thanks to her kindness I fell in love with your country and your ideals. I imagine Obama^s grandma so much like her ,and many of my american female friends: a quiet , steel magnolia the perfect blend between fortitude,hardworking spirit ,calm and goodness…it is also called character, and that is felt and nourishes the young .
    Joe can you please tell Obama, that remarkable man that made me cry when he accepted the nomination, that his dear grandma has given him the biggest lesson of them all, we are just wanderers on this Earth , one day the sun sets and the journey is over, make sure this day is as fulfilling as her`s, the measure is , as the egypsian tradition says, in the weight of your hearth !
    God bless America , and in doing so bless us all tomorrow…
    P

  • Slowhand Ted

    It is truly a shame that Marc Schulz and to a lesser extent freeenterprisechic have hijacked a thread about a remarkable woman. She shaped him and instilled many of his values, and that he has achieved so much is in large part due to her. And – as Obama said today – she was one of the quiet heroes, much like many of our own mothers and grandmothers who put themselves second, so we could have better lives than they did. May she rest in peace.
    .
    That freeenterprisechic doesn’t know a (very well-known) Martin Luther King reference somehow doesn’t surprise me. Looks like he/she could stand a little educating:
    .
    “We’ve got some difficult days ahead. But it really doesn’t matter with me now, because I’ve been to the mountaintop. And I don’t mind.
    .
    Like anybody, I would like to live a long life. Longevity has its place. But I’m not concerned about that now. I just want to do God’s will. And He’s allowed me to go up to the mountain. And I’ve looked over. And I’ve seen the Promised Land. I may not get there with you. But I want you to know tonight, that we, as a people, will get to the promised land.”

    .
    In other words, FEC, Obama’s grandmother may not have seen the end of the journey her grandson embarked upon, but she had seen enough to know that the day was coming. Your ignorance FEC is appalling, but then as Spike Milligan used to say, most ignorance is.

  • bethnva

    My God Joe, I see why it is you are writer. This is an excellent piece, and it captures so well these times, “for good or ill”.

    Such an unease, tension, and uncharacteristic quiet even amidst the bustle of our local Obama office here in Virginia tonight. Tomorrow it will rain on election day, and people will have to wait in lines in the rain. Tonight we’ve seen the Reverent Wright GOP smear piece on television over two dozen times on the local television. My hope and faith in our democracy and fellow voters is certainly being tested.

  • stunvegas

    Well said Joe, thanks.

    I volunteered this morning at Michelle Obama’s rally in Las Vegas. Michelle announced that Terence Tolbert (Obama/Biden campaign manager for Nevada) had passed away Sunday night. She did not mention Ms Dunham, I suppose she was waiting for the offficial announcement from the Senator. She told us Terence’s life was to be celebrated, and how proud he would be of the Senator, and the Campaign.
    Think of the whirlwind of emotions that must have been raging in this woman. Her husband is on the verge of becoming the President of the United States – daunting, regardless of his color, and doubly so because of it. Her husbands’ grandmother has just passed, as you correctly say, with ridiculous timing. Undeterred, she memorializes a friend, tells heart wrenching stories of people she’s met on the campaign trail who have placed their dreams in his hands, and reminds us of the good work yet to be done. I’ve seen her speak before and today she was good.
    I wish that I could have a fraction of the grace that Barack and Michelle Obama have displayed over the course of this campiagn.

  • james

    Pat Says:
    Monday, November 3, 2008 at 11:00 pm

    Pat, if Obama made you cry, you did that to me. Your post touched my heart and also the worst of America for the last 8 years. America will be restored tomorrow night and all the world will be better for it.

    Thank you very much.

  • Slowhand Ted

    Part of MLK’s ‘mountaintop’ speech:
    .

  • http://yahoo.com Dennis P. Baynas

    I’m not an American but my mother is a citizen and lives in Hawaii huddled with friends, instead of her own family. Two love ones have died (my brother and father) in the soil where our dreams as a family would have bloomed, in America. A dream that eluded us to this day. Yes, it’s amazing how our mother and our grandmother can leave a irrefutable light in our heart, that becomes our compass to the dark challenges ahead, today I’ve felt that lump of pain having lost those I love and never able to hug them in their painful moments before passing… to Obama, she is always where your heart is.

    We are a believer of Democracy even though my family have been separated by borders and policies… now only my mother stands tall in her ailing 60s she will cast her vote for that dream… she believes in Obama she believes in Hope… in family, in the Land of Diversity and Freedom.

    Obama made me look at the stars, there is always hope… what else could go wrong in a dream when the Star is guiding us to him.

    To Obama family my heartfelt condolence… be strong, the World and God is with you all…

  • http://aol.com teresaG in ga

    Mr. klien, your article was well written and very touching. AMERICA, what is really going on??? After reading the numerous comments about this article, I was very moved by most of the comments but very disturbed by quite a few of them. Here we have a (PERSON), in case some of you didn’t know that; whom have lost someone who not only loved him, but also apparently instilled in him MORALS about people; who are in dire need of HOPEFULNESS, HELFULNESS, and most importantly
    HAPPINESS. America look around you, can’t you see the PAIN, AGONY and FEAR that “everyone” (most) are experiencing? This is no joke!!!
    We need help, and we needed it yesterday… This is not a BLACK, WHITE, RED, or BLUE problem, this is a EVERYBODY problem. This
    not only affect AMERICA, but affects most countries. Take off
    the blinders, put aside PRIDE, put aside PREJUDICE, and put on PEACE… It is truly TIME FOR A CHANGE. We are talking about our
    children’s future. It’s so sad that we cannot come together for the
    benefit of our country. We must be a big joke to all of the other countries as they look at us bickering at each other. Let’s stop making a mockery of ourselves, let’s step up the plate and hit a home run and get to work on getting our house (USA) in order so that we can hold our heads up high again. But there is no way that we will be able to do this, if we keep up this charade of BACKBITING and a EYE for an EYE. What kind of expample are we setting for our children? Now you say you love your country and you want what is best for it and for yourselves. Then try putting aside your status as to whether you are a Democrat, Republican or etc, and make your decision on the basis and on the factors of what is RIGHT and FAIR; for the MAJORITY not just yourself. I don’t know about you,
    but I am ready for a CHANGE, and I need one REAL SOON! Oh yeah, one important thing and ingredient that we are all forgetting and
    missing is GOD, who is not asleep and who is STILL IN CHARGE!!

  • freeenterprisechic

    What a way to distract from the real issues at hand.

  • freeenterprisechic

    Seriously, should I just check my brain at the door.

  • singlemomvoting

    People post comments in blogs like this, not because they believe the person under discussion will literally read them, but because they wish to deal with their feelings by sharing them and seeing what other people have to say that is of value. I have read a great deal here that is of value. I don’t mean because it is pro-Obama; I mean because it is pro-America, because people are reaching out to each other and confirming to each other that we are really “in this together”….it is a good feeling and one I am proud to believe will bring positive change to my country. Yeah for my grandkids! So for people like Shulz and feeenterprisechic (which vp of what bailout comp are you?)….take your cynicism and leave this place, there is nothing for you here and nothing you have to offer the future.

  • http://www.myspace.com/darrentomlyn KeillRandor

    Obama mourning
    His Grandmother laid to rest
    A new day dawning

  • feed

    Here are several converting tools for you!drm removeripod transferipod movie converter

  • http://yellowromancandles.wordpress.com/2008/11/04/poised/ Poised « Yellow Roman Candles

    [...] leather faces who’ve seen it all before – get so excited about today’s outcome. Perhaps Time’s Joe Klein best sums up their feelings: Some politicians simply are larger than life. Their stories are the stuff of high drama. Over the [...]

  • Andy Schulkind

    I hope Barack and his sister get the opportunity to share some time together after the election.
    .
    It is interesting to me that while John and Cindy McCain expressed their condolences, I have not seen such a response from Sarah and Todd Palin. Please correct me if I am wrong.
    .
    On the train ride into work today, I thought of the end of the Watergate era and how one can hope that this will mark a new day forward, where the excesses of corruption and power for power’s sake will be replaced, by hope, decency, courtesy, and respect for all citizens of our country.
    .
    The challenges are looming, but the opportunities to put our country on the right track are great. As long as people get the opportunity to vote today, therein lies the greatness that is the United States of America.

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    What a way to distract from the real issues at hand.

    Interestingly enough, while there are many specific issues that need to be debated and that people can find themselves on several sides of, this campaign has unfortrunately become a referendum on whether hatred and fear will continue to sell.
    .
    It actually touches on all the other important issues, because when we deal with terrorism and threats abroad, it will be important that we deal rationally and with the knowlege that we are dealing with fellow human beings and not demons, and as we tackle a sinking economy, it will be imnportant that we realize that we are all in it together and that by sharing the burden and working togather we can lift ourselves out of the difficulty, but if we insist that it’s every man for himself, we’re doomed to do more harm to everyone.

    I have faith that most Americans realize this and that this will become evident as the day wears on.

  • http://www.ou-xu.com/2008/11/04/to-the-sky/ to the sky » Ouxu

    [...] a piece by joe klein of time’s swampland: [...]

  • bethnva
  • Pupster

    There seems to be a lot of confusion about the time Mrs. Dunham died. Let’s make this perfectly clear: She died in Hawaii right before midnight Sunday night Hawaii time, which is 5 am EST. Obama received his phone call at 8 am.

    There was no manipulation of the announcement. Can people please dispense with these ridiculously heartless conspiracy theories?

  • PeterfromOz

    I had intended to just read Joe’s tribute, But I’m so moved by it and many of the comments, that I felt compelled to add something. Barack’s grandmother’s death happening when he is on the threshold of the biggest moment in his life is heart-rending. She must have been a remarkable women.
    From the other side of the world, as we watch the final scenes of this political drama, we can only hope that the huge psychological investment which so many people have come to hold in Obama’s candidacy, will be realised.
    Everything we see of him suggests that he will respond effectively to the daunting challenges of current and prospective political problems. We’ve watched with a mix of fascination and horror as the US economy and its geo-political situation has deteriorated – because it affects us all.
    Good luck, people of goodwill around the world so much want (and depend upon) the success of the Obama Presidency.

  • DonnyC

    Hey Joe,

    Don’t you think your just a bit over the top here? By the way, this is not even close as far as the most remarkable election..it’s been tedious, fatiguing, boring, way too long and way too expensive. My only words are thank god it’s over and get ready to start all over again in two years. By the way, you don’t need to continue your love fest with Obama…we all know already.

    DonnyC

  • Roger Friedmann

    I want to offer my heart-felt thanks to Joe Klein for his deeply moving post about Madelyn Dunham. She was truly one of America’s unsung heroes. More attention deserves to be paid to the story Klein sketches in his post. Again, thanks Joe. You’re the only journalist talking right now about this truly remarkable woman. I hope you’ll have the opportunity to revisit this story and develop it more fully.

  • http://TimeDailyNews Donna H.

    Being born in 1950, I was a teen in the 60′s and young adult in the 70′s. My entire generation was embroiled in the civil rights movement, and the social change that accompanied it. I have wondered of late where our passion as a generation has gone….what happened to our idealism. Well, thanks to this man, Barak Obama, we have an opportunity to see the movement through. I vote for Barak, not solely because he is a black man, but because he is a man of passion, compassion, experience and intelligence. I understand the challenges that his mother and grandparents faced in those early days, and have an enduring respect for their courage. We all owe Barak’s grandmother a dept of gratitude for giving our nation such a man. My prayers are with Barak and his family today, as well as for our country.

  • http://ballotvox.prx.org/archives/818/condolences-to-obama-on-his-grandmothers-death BallotVox » Blog Archive » Condolences to Obama on His Grandmother’s Death

    [...] grandmother — Madelyn Dunham — died yesterday in Hawaii. One day before the election. RedneckCabbie, a 27-year taxicab veteran now living and working in [...]

  • bryanfromhouston

    To the hate-mongers (freeenterprise, MarcSchulz, etc.) who have posted here, may God have mercy upon your soul.
    .
    In the Bible, the question is posed, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” How do you answer that question? How do you respond to your neighbor in their hour of need? I pray that God will act upon your lives in a mighty way and show you a light from which you cannot hide. Amen.

  • http://chattygirl.womansfuture.info/2008/11/04/election-2008-the-calm-before-the-freakout/ Election 2008: The Calm Before the Freakout | “Girl Chat”

    [...] Obama’s grandmother passed away election eve (via Swampland), prompting right-wing HotAir to say, “our prayers are with the [...]

  • bensay

    Joe: thanks.

  • http://cyberaxis.wordpress.com/ cyberaxis

    You have no idea what your words have brought to millions of Americans trying to absorb the congruence or incongruence of Madelyn’s passing at this momentous cusp.

    There is indeed a balm in Gilead:

    http://cyberaxis.wordpress.com/2008/11/04/madelyn-dunham-in-memoriam-there-is-a-balm-in-gilead/

    On behalf of everyone who feels about this the way I do, THANK YOU.

  • http://cyberaxis.wordpress.com/ cyberaxis

    And I would like to second what Roger Friedmann suggested (Comment # 150 – Ref: fleshing out the Madelyn Dunham story). People who do not know the where, what and WHO of Barack’s story will never understand (or appreciate) his approach to life, people and politics. Thanks again.

  • http://yellowromancandles.ie/wordpress/?p=62 Poised | Yellow Roman Candles

    [...] But still, I am surprised to see seasoned commentators – men and women with leather faces who’ve seen it all before – get so excited about today’s outcome. Perhaps Time’s Joe Klein best sums up their feelings: [...]

  • http://yellowromancandles.ie/?p=15 Poised | Yellow Roman Candles

    [...] leather faces who’ve seen it all before – get so excited about today’s outcome. Perhaps Time’s Joe Klein best sums up their feelings: Some politicians simply are larger than life. Their stories are the stuff of high drama. Over the [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus